Skip to main content

Bizarre ....

Bizarre ....

Status
Not open for further replies.
OK I will explain why I chose those 15 games seeing you ask.

On post 37, Tugg stated "Grayson fucked up big time something that he often does".

My stance is that statement can be challenged as working with one of the three lowest budgets in the league, (apparently), that 15 game record I mentioned is very commendable.

We then come up against a Leeds side full of confidence (a club much bigger in financial terms than PNE by the way) who had won 8 of their last 10 matches, and fair enough, we get beat.

But looking at Grayson's record during that fairly long period of 15 games, I am not going to agree that "Grayson fucks up fairly often".

If you want to agree with Tugg's opinion, by my guest, but I will look at Grayson's record, and decide my self whether it is reasonable to agree with an opinion that a manager who holds that record "fucks up fairly often".

Grayson's record not only during that 15 game run, but overall since he took over at Deepdale, does not comply with a manager who "fucks up fairly often", depending of course on what one's definition of "fairly often" is.

Also it is "those" games, not "them" games.

Finally, why are you complaining to me when you finish by writing "mid table for me is a good job in my opinion". You should be challenging fucking Tugg, not me you prick.

I'm pointing out that you think you are clever by saying stats, and that stats seem to make what you write more important than someone's opinions. I was also pointing out that if you had actually bothered to use stats that say the whole picture i.e. the whole season so far, not just stats that suit your argument i.e. 15 games, then people might actually respect what you say a bit more!

Isn't it sad that you had to end your post with bad language. I thought old people were more respectful, obviously not!
 
I'm pointing out that you think you are clever by saying stats, and that stats seem to make what you write more important than someone's opinions. I was also pointing out that if you had actually bothered to use stats that say the whole picture i.e. the whole season so far, not just stats that suit your argument i.e. 15 games, then people might actually respect what you say a bit more
Hang on a second. You were the guy harping on about graysons 4 wins in 19 games back in september? And being very selective in doing so; including end of season kick abouts when we had nothing at all to play for bar pride. And you also offered me advice when i pulled you up on your stats...

You said... "When you're proving positive form you go from earliest point positive form started. If you're proving negative form, you go from earliest point when negative form started. That's football!"

People in glass houses...
 
Last edited:
I'm pointing out that you think you are clever by saying stats, and that stats seem to make what you write more important than someone's opinions. I was also pointing out that if you had actually bothered to use stats that say the whole picture i.e. the whole season so far, not just stats that suit your argument i.e. 15 games, then people might actually respect what you say a bit more!

Isn't it sad that you had to end your post with bad language. I thought old people were more respectful, obviously not!

What about when you used stats to highlight our lack of wins from the back end of last season into this season? Okay for you to do that to suit your agenda at that time?
 
Hang on a second. You were the guy harping on about graysons 4 wins in 19 games back in september? And being very selective in doing so; including end of season kick abouts when we had nothing at all to play for bar pride. And you also offered me advice when i pulled you up on your stats...

You said... "When you're proving positive form you go from earliest point positive form started. If you're proving negative form, you go from earliest point when negative form started. That's football!"

People in glass houses...

Oh, beat me to it ...
 
Hang on a second. You were the guy harping on about graysons 4 wins in 19 games back in september? And being very selective in doing so; including end of season kick abouts when we had nothing at all to play for bar pride. And you also offered me advice when i pulled you up on your stats...

You said... "When you're proving positive form you go from earliest point positive form started. If you're proving negative form, you go from earliest point when negative form started. That's football!"

People in glass houses...

I'm a reformed character. I'm all about the big picture these days.
 
I'm a reformed character. I'm all about the big picture these days.


I also remember you stating that "nobody can ever accuse this team of lacking effort." A sweeping generalization even for a man who now likes to look at the big picture.

Hope 2017 proves to be a more accurate year for you and your bold statements.
 
I also remember you stating that "nobody can ever accuse this team of lacking effort." A sweeping generalization even for a man who now likes to look at the big picture.

Hope 2017 proves to be a more accurate year for you and your bold statements.

I also remember you stating that 'Grayson has always had an eye for a decent striker.'

I hope 2017 brings world peace.
 
Despite the (now quite common) derailment of this thread, here are my thoughts on the OP.

"Starting a home game with 5 defenders, odd?"
Well yes, but Vermijl was playing as a winger (if you'd seen the game he was playing high up the pitch), with Baptiste, Clarke, Hunts and Cunningham as a back 4.

"Using a system that requires the ability to hold the ball up front with a striker that can't do that and a winger up front"
Maybe that wasn't the system - it seemed to me it was Makienok laying the ball off to Johnson/Pearson or flicking on for Robbo or Marnick.

"3 strikers on the bench" - options in case plan A didn't work.

"At half time when it's entirely obvious to everyone the problem is up front to not make any changes until the 65th minute"
Well bizarrely after half time we had our best spell. I think SG's mistake here was to make the changes in the 65th minute when we HAD got things working. So I agree but for different reasons.

"Not Graysons fault but he'd already lost the game for us by then. No doubt he'll be used as an excuse though"
Again, I think the timing of his subs was odd given we were on top, but Beckford being an idiot did cost us any chance of getting something from the game.

"So, then when you absolutely have to give it a go you don't take a defender off but a midfielder in order to make space for the missing striker"
I don't understand that statement - he took Robinson and Makienok off for Hughill and Beckford, then Johnson off for Doyle. Given Beckford was already off by then SG was only ever trying to play with two up front, and his hand was forced by the red card.

"Anyone that doesn't think he got it wrong today is insane." I'm not insane - I think he did get the formation/personnel slightly wrong, but had to give a starting position to those in the team that have been playing well recently.

"A decent manager could get something much more out of this set of players. If it was up to me he should have been put on the bus with the Leeds fans. Pathetic."
Debatable. Robinson flatters to deceive for me, Johnson can't tackle, and we let Leeds cut through us too often with very few challenges. Once again we looked lethargic until it was too late. A combination of a slightly miscaculated starting line up, and a lack of energy and we're 3-1 down.

I think SG is getting a LOT out of this group of players and your dislike of him is colouring your judgement. Just my opinion of course.

Live long and prosper. Happy New Year to you.
 
Once again we looked lethargic until it was too late. A combination of a slightly miscaculated starting line up, and a lack of energy and we're 3-1 down.

Why a miscalculated starting line up? Why were we lethargic? Why were we lacking energy?

I do wish our manager would take some responsibility for our results. It is his responsibility (and the rest of the coaching staff) to select the right starting line up, tactics and formation. It's also the responsibility of the same individuals to make sure the players are fit and ready and that they play with the required desire, tempo and effort.

If the above was not true, then we wouldn't need managers or coaching staff and we could just send 11 players onto the pitch to just get on with it. But good and great managers are worth their weight in gold. Witness Simeone at Athletico Madrid, Conte at Chelsea, Klopp at Liverpool and others at different levels. You can not over emphasise the importance of having a good manager.

Now I'm not saying we should have any of these 'super' managers in charge at PNE, just using them as examples to illustrate the effect a different manager can have, even with the same group of players.

Yes the players also have a responsibility to do their best, but they need managing, motivating, inspiring, encouraging, filling with self belief so they play with little or no fear. That's the real difference.

I've witnessed Graysons football, tactics and philosophy since he arrived at the club. I can remember games even in league 1 that we should have won easily (Chesterfield and Rotherham at home) and debacles away (e.g. Rochdale). Weaknesses, patterns of play and frailties that were there then are still there, with a set of completely different players.

Hence the question that keeps resurfacing at that back of my mind, asking if we do indeed have the right manager in place to progress and take us further. I have always had my doubts and will continue to have them, whilst hoping to be proven wrong.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top