In fairness, the 5-0 was a joke, we were down to 10 men through injury and somehow decided to virtually go with danger goalies in search of a goal. May seem strange to say it, but (seriously) the match was never a hammering, despite the 5-0 scoreline.
It's definitely about time we beat them though!
Yes - I was there and even at 2-0 you felt that if we could find a goal we would be right back in it. Nevertheless the fact we were 2-0 down was not a fluke and was the result of the formation we played - a flat 4.4.2 with Gallagher and Browne in the centre flanked by McGeady and Robinson. On paper that might look exciting but in reality it was hopeless because Browne could not win the midfield battle by himself and whenever Gallagher got the ball he was immediately under pressure and could do no more than either punt it aimlessly forward or push it square and wide to where one or other of the two wingers were stood waiting and then had to try to create something from a standing start. It was boring, pedestrian and predictable. The utter farrago of the last ten minutes was mainly the result not of going down to ten men but of making that weak central midfield even worse by replacing Browne by Johnson.
This being Preston North End we then notched up a superb away victory against Premiership opposition in our very next match by reverting to the wing-back formation that we could just as easily have used at Brentford. But remember what happened then - we went straight back to the formation we had used at Brentford albeit with Makienok instead of Doyle for that televised home match against Wigan. The consequences but for a flukish early goal on our part and some lamentable finishing by them were very nearly the same because for the first 70 minutes we were awful in exactly the same way we had been for the first 70 minutes at Brentford.
But then everything changed when we brought on Pearson and Johnson to join Gallagher in a three-man midfield and suddenly we had pace, invention, fluidity, movement and with Hugill, Robinson and McGeady upfront an attack that combined both width and a proper strike partnership when Robinson kept close by Hugill. That basic formation is the one that propelled us up the table and came close to beating Arsenal.
In recent weeks though we seem to have gone back to something more like that 4.4.2 and though with Pearson in there it is certainly better I am not totally convinced by it. It doesn't seem to have worked all that well at Barnsley though it was probably made worse by partnering Hugill and Makienok upfront - that duo just does not work. Frankly I would like to see us starting with a midfield of Pearson plus two from Gallagher, Johnson and Browne and upfront Hugill with Robinson, who is not a winger but a striker with the pace to run wide, and McGeady. With Horgan in reserve the option of changing to a 4.4.2 is still there and later on in a match against tiring opposition it might be a worthwhile tactical move - the same effect, of course, could be achieved by moving Robinson wide and partnering Hugill with Beckford or even giving a Makienok-Beckford duo a go.
Anyhow let's see what SG does. I still think a play-off charge is possible but we really need to get one underway pretty quickly. After that awful afternoon in West London a few months back it would certainly be rather neat if we could achieve that on Saturday.