- Joined
- Dec 29, 2007
- Messages
- 305
One of the most pleasing things about last night's win.With difficult up and ckming games I had feared Watford might have been the second defeat in a run of defeats.
Time for Reid and humphrey to leave the club.
Time for Reid and humphrey to leave the club.
I'm guessing you didn't go to the game on Saturday then? Humphrey was one of the best players on the pitch, as for Reid I would agree he probably needs to go he's had plenty of opportunitys and still hasn't made any significant contribution.
Time for Reid and humphrey to leave the club.
You'll find it hard to replace Humphrey at RWB. Can't do much better than him in that position for me. So tactically aware and stands a man up so well. He's rapid, very fit and strong. Everything you need for a RWB.
Showed what he could do vs Ipswich even in a RW role. MOTM for me on Saturday.
You'll find it hard to replace Humphrey at RWB. QUOTE]
Not really - that is what Vermilj is. Having said that Vermilj and Humphrey make a nicely contrasting set of options for the right wing-back position. Where we are short is on the left. We don't seem to have an alternative to Cunningham for the left wing-back role so with him out we have to revert to a back four - though it seems that Woods did well as a left-back last night.
The real problem then is not just that we don't seem to have any really effective wide players for a four-man midfield formation but that even if we did then playing that formation with Welsh in the centre and two strikers upfront would make impossible to have both Johnson and Gallagher in the side together. The wing-back formation enables us to do that and also means that with Kilkenny, Browne and Brownhill in reserve we have appropriate back-up options for the centre of the team.
Last night maybe also indicates that if we do play a back four then the best use of our existing resources is not to play a flat four-man midfield but something that enables us to support a striking partnership of, ideally, Garner and Beckford with four out of Welsh, Gallagher, Johnson, Kilkenny, Browne and Brownhill.
Plenty of opportunities? He played 26 games last season, 14 of which came from the bench, plus he'd missed the whole of pre-season after a bad knee injury. He played a few games in pre season and then last night was his first chance to have a run out and in general he did ok, was a threat with his pace and tracked back to help out the defence. Yes he missed a few chances but at least he was having a go.
As we don't have any other wingers in the squad or anyone else with that kind of pace I'd definitely be keeping him around.
You'll find it hard to replace Humphrey at RWB. QUOTE]
Not really - that is what Vermilj is. Having said that Vermilj and Humphrey make a nicely contrasting set of options for the right wing-back position. Where we are short is on the left. We don't seem to have an alternative to Cunningham for the left wing-back role so with him out we have to revert to a back four - though it seems that Woods did well as a left-back last night.
The real problem then is not just that we don't seem to have any really effective wide players for a four-man midfield formation but that even if we did then playing that formation with Welsh in the centre and two strikers upfront would make impossible to have both Johnson and Gallagher in the side together. The wing-back formation enables us to do that and also means that with Kilkenny, Browne and Brownhill in reserve we have appropriate back-up options for the centre of the team.
Last night maybe also indicates that if we do play a back four then the best use of our existing resources is not to play a flat four-man midfield but something that enables us to support a striking partnership of, ideally, Garner and Beckford with four out of Welsh, Gallagher, Johnson, Kilkenny, Browne and Brownhill.
Okay. So who would you bring in to replace humphrey if he left?
Baring we rarely play a system with out and out wingers. (352 and narrow 433) sometimes a 4231.
Which RWB would you like to come in?
Okay. Which RWB would you like to come in?
No-one - as I said Humphrey and Vermilj give us a nice set of options for the right wing-back position and as such I have no wish to see Humphrey leave. That is the point I was making - though of the two Vermilj probably has more of what it takes to succeed at Championship level and I would tend to see Humphrey as more of a back-up option.
It is on the left where we need another player since it seems that if Cunningham is absent we do not have anyone else who can play the wing-back role on that flank. That is a deficiency we will need to attend to because the wing-back formation seems to be the one that allows us to make the most of our current resources i.e. to get Clarke, Huntington and Wright on the field at the same time in reasonably central positions and to do the same with three of our current batch of midfielders.
Time for Reid and humphrey to leave the club.
No-one - as I said Humphrey and Vermilj give us a nice set of options for the right wing-back position and as such I have no wish to see Humphrey leave. That is the point I was making - though of the two Vermilj probably has more of what it takes to succeed at Championship level and I would tend to see Humphrey as more of a back-up option.
It is on the left where we need another player since it seems that if Cunningham is absent we do not have anyone else who can play the wing-back role on that flank. That is a deficiency we will need to attend to because the wing-back formation seems to be the one that allows us to make the most of our current resources i.e. to get Clarke, Huntington and Wright on the field at the same time in reasonably central positions and to do the same with three of our current batch of midfielders.
Ah okay fair enough.
For me its the other way round. Id see humphrey as a solid starter for 70 minutes, and if we needed to push forward a tad more to equalise or take the lead, bring Vermijl on as a more attacking option.
But you're right, 2 good options.
It's his attacking side that lets him down. Defensively, you're right that you can't ask for much more in a RWB, however you also need them to be able to get forward and beat a man, which he so very rarely does. He definitely isn't the man as a RW for me.
Having said that, his crossing has been top class so far this season, it's just a shame he can't get closer to the byline to whip one in as he doesn't know how to beat a man!