Skip to main content

Brownhill

Brownhill

Who deserves to be in ahead of him?

On current form not of them, but can you see Brownhill playing 90 minutes yet? He'll play 60-70 max, or less if he has a bad game, and the other midfielders we've got aren't exactly game changers. So IMO he's best kept on the bench for a few games until he's showing enough in his performances as a sub that he's ready to start.

Hayhurst made a great impact on his debut against Charlton and then got hauled off before half-time the week after at Bournemouth.
 
On current form not of them, but can you see Brownhill playing 90 minutes yet? He'll play 60-70 max, or less if he has a bad game, and the other midfielders we've got aren't exactly game changers. So IMO he's best kept on the bench for a few games until he's showing enough in his performances as a sub that he's ready to start.

Hayhurst made a great impact on his debut against Charlton and then got hauled off before half-time the week after at Bournemouth.


So no one playing better than him and because you feel he doesn't have 90 leave him on the bench , you also say we can't play him because he has no experience yet the only way to get some is play him !! thanks for clearing that up
 
So no one playing better than him and because you feel he doesn't have 90 leave him on the bench , you also say we can't play him because he has no experience yet the only way to get some is play him !! thanks for clearing that up

It's better for him to come into the first team one step at a time.

At Peterborough he travelled with the squad for the first time.

Against Oldham he made his debut in a cup game which didn't really have much riding on it.

Today he made his league debut, at home, against a team that we're sitting on their lead and looking to time waste.

To start an away game with less than 45 minutes of first team football, all at Deepdale, is too big a step.
 
It's better for him to come into the first team one step at a time.

At Peterborough he travelled with the squad for the first time.

Against Oldham he made his debut in a cup game which didn't really have much riding on it.

Today he made his league debut, at home, against a team that we're sitting on their lead and looking to time waste.

To start an away game with less than 45 minutes of first team football, all at Deepdale, is too big a step.


Well if our midfield wont or cant pull there fingers out we need to do something and seeing this young lad come in and give his all might be the kick up the ass they so richly deserve
 
Well if our midfield wont or cant pull there fingers out we need to do something and seeing this young lad come in and give his all might be the kick up the ass they so richly deserve

I fully expect Byrom to start next week, not that I think he should but because Grayson isn't the type of manager to reach for the panic button after a couple of bad results. But the sight of Brownhill warming up on the touchline should make it plainly clear to Byrom that unless he puts in a decent shift then he'll get 60 minutes max before he's hauled off.
 
Start Brownhill at Gillingham or bring someone in on loan. Plenty of teams have 17 year olds playing so why not us? If he's good enough play him. There's no other bugger showing any quality in that area.

I think it's probably about time we started moving on some of the dross. I thought we had quite a good squad but on the bench today were two players SG clearly doesn't rate or trust (and rightly so in my opinion) - Mousinho and Wroe. Get rid of them in January along with Byrom who is garbage.
 
Start Brownhill at Gillingham or bring someone in on loan. Plenty of teams have 17 year olds playing so why not us? If he's good enough play him. There's no other bugger showing any quality in that area.

I think it's probably about time we started moving on some of the dross. I thought we had quite a good squad but on the bench today were two players SG clearly doesn't rate or trust (and rightly so in my opinion) - Mousinho and Wroe. Get rid of them in January along with Byrom who is garbage.

Personally I'd go for the loan option.

Brownhill's one for the future, not a short-term fix. To expect him to be putting in match-winning performances at this stage of his career is far too much. After all, look what happened to Mayor and Barton (one good game against Burnley - which we even ended up losing) when Fergie Junior insisted on playing them ahead of seasoned professionals.

But look at Bailey Wright who took 3 seasons to establish himself as a regular. Brownhill's only 17, and along with Ben Davies who's on loan at York, if managed correctly he's a player who can serve the club well for years to come.
 
Personally I'd go for the loan option.

Brownhill's one for the future, not a short-term fix. To expect him to be putting in match-winning performances at this stage of his career is far too much. After all, look what happened to Mayor and Barton (one good game against Burnley - which we even ended up losing) when Fergie Junior insisted on playing them ahead of seasoned professionals.

But look at Bailey Wright who took 3 seasons to establish himself as a regular. Brownhill's only 17, and along with Ben Davies who's on loan at York, if managed correctly he's a player who can serve the club well for years to come.

Fair points and I won't argue with them but if Brownhill is outstanding then he should play. His performances in a very average youth team crop have been exceptional and he has won games on his own. He has a decent pedigree with Man Utd and is certainly a better footballer than Joel Byrom.
 
Fair points and I won't argue with them but if Brownhill is outstanding then he should play. His performances in a very average youth team crop have been exceptional and he has won games on his own. He has a decent pedigree with Man Utd and is certainly a better footballer than Joel Byrom.

Brownhill looks good but I wouldn't say he's outstanding. Hartlepool have a player in Luke James who looked far better at a similar age when he played at Deepdale a couple of years ago but he's now playing in a team in the bottom half of League 2 when he reportedly had 20 scouts watching him.

He threatened to beat his man a couple of times on the edge of the Crewe box today but looked slightly taken aback by the pace of the game, especially when he came on against Oldham.

And the key thing in this debate is that Grayson errs on the side of caution when it comes to tactics and making changes to the team so it'll be the Tranmere game at least before he gives Brownhill a start.
 
The lad looks a tidy player but I have seen nothing in the his two cameos that make me think he is the answer to our current run of defeats. I didn't think we played that badly today and created enough chances to have won the game despite their two goals.

The first came following a very weak free kick and the second we were beaten by a quality Finnish when they countered. We had over a dozen attempts and should have at least 1 point.
 
The lad looks a tidy player but I have seen nothing in the his two cameos that make me think he is the answer to our current run of defeats. I didn't think we played that badly today and created enough chances to have won the game despite their two goals.

The first came following a very weak free kick and the second we were beaten by a quality Finnish when they countered. We had over a dozen attempts and should have at least 1 point.

I'd agree with that, but sadly some people see enough negativity in today's performance to feel as if the season is already over, save a slide towards a relegation battle.
 
I'm very happy for Josh, but I'm very angry for the Nicky Wroe's situation

Exactly my thoughts! It's a joke when a YTS has beat Wroe into team. Has Grayson lost certain players like Westley did, when he putting young Ben Davies in instead of Buchanan? Just throwing it out there. Wroe scored 10+ last season and is nowhere near team.
 
Back
Top