Has Brownhill done enough tonight to keep welsh and keane out the team?
Brownhill
- Joined
- Apr 8, 2012
- Messages
- 6,513
Has Brownhill done enough tonight to keep welsh and keane out the team?
For me, absolutely. If anyone is to be replaced by most probably Welsh, it would be Kilkenny. I wouldn't change it though, we played nice football tonight. I'd put Gallagher up top with Garner, drop Davies and put Holmes on the left. That team could surely not fail to score.
- Joined
- Nov 16, 2004
- Messages
- 469
I thought he was man of the match tonight, always moves to create an option and think we need more of our play to go through him. He seems very comfortable playing one touch football and for the first time tonight he seemed to break up a lot of the opposition play.
- Joined
- Apr 8, 2012
- Messages
- 6,513
I think we're too lightweight with Brownhill and Kilkenny as the midfield. The amount of times their centre-backs strolled through the middle was worrying. One or the other for me.
If it's one or the other, it's got to be Brownhill. Does everything Kilkenny does while also attacking, creating and putting the odd tackle. It's a no brainer for me.
- Joined
- Oct 19, 2004
- Messages
- 14,851
There's no doubt he's a very good prospect and was the right choice for tonight because of the way Sheffield United play. He saw plenty of the ball and had lots of time to play as they basically conceded midfield and hardly made a tackle outside their own half. Against a more attacking team, particularly away from home, I would always have Keane or Welsh in ahead of him. I think he's looked quite effective when he's been brought on and played wide on the left late in a game but I don't think he's ready to be a regular starter.
Thracia
Club Owner, or wingback, depending on your view
- Joined
- Aug 1, 2011
- Messages
- 30,692
Yes.Has Brownhill done enough tonight to keep welsh and keane out the team?
- Joined
- Dec 4, 2005
- Messages
- 22,726
I actually thought Kilkenny was MOM.
Tonight we played a passing game rather than hoof ball, seems to happen a lot that when Brownhill is on the field.
Yes, not a coincidence.
I listened to the commentary on Radio Sheffield and lost count of the number of times he was praised not just for his passing and movement, attempts at goal but also for his tenacious defending and ball winning.
It's a fallacy that Keane is a better player to have in midfield away from home. He might be reasonable back up on occasions but he commits so many fouls in his attempts to win the ball and is a league or two below the rest of the team when we're in possession so slows our attacking play down to a completely ineffective pace. And Brownhill showed tonight that he's got great defensive qualities in addition to being probably the most talented young attacking midfielder in this division.
- Joined
- Apr 8, 2012
- Messages
- 6,513
I actually thought Kilkenny was MOM.
I disagree. Totally overshadowed by Brownhill and offers nothing defensively or as much attacking wise. While not giving the ball away much, his slowing down of the play wasn't always to our advantage.
I actually thought Kilkenny was MOM.
Certainly got a lot of praise from the radio commentators and it sounded like he helped control the game and made things happen.
I really like Kilkenny and Brownhill in midfield. Skilful and effective.
Yes, not a coincidence.
I listened to the commentary on Radio Sheffield and lost count of the number of times he was praised not just for his passing and movement, attempts at goal but also for his tenacious defending and ball winning.
It's a fallacy that Keane is a better player to have in midfield away from home. He might be reasonable back up on occasions but he commits so many fouls in his attempts to win the ball and is a league or two below the rest of the team when we're in possession so slows our attacking play down to a completely ineffective pace. And Brownhill showed tonight that he's got great defensive qualities in addition to being probably the most talented young attacking midfielder in this division.
Keane is a journeyman, an average-at-best journeyman.
To pick him in the team ahead of Brownhill is a footballing crime.
- Joined
- Dec 4, 2005
- Messages
- 22,726
I disagree. Totally overshadowed by Brownhill and offers nothing defensively or as much attacking wise. While not giving the ball away much, his slowing down of the play wasn't always to our advantage.
Fair shout, I just like the way he's always open and keeps us moving and in possession.
Not taking anything away from JB, the two of them played really well together.
- Joined
- Dec 4, 2005
- Messages
- 22,726
Certainly to a lot of praise from the radio commentators and it sounded like he helped control the game and made things happen.
I really like Kilkenny and Brownhill in midfield. Skilful and effective.
I agree.
Keane is a journeyman, an average-at-best journeyman.
To pick him in the team ahead of Brownhill is a footballing crime.
Punishable by missing out on automatic promotion?
Punishable by missing out on automatic promotion?
Indeed.