Skip to main content

Brownhill

Brownhill

Fair shout, I just like the way he's always open and keeps us moving and in possession.

Not taking anything away from JB, the two of them played really well together.

Absolutely agree about the two of them linking up well. Passing and moving to very good effect at times. It's just a shame that in a two man midfield, they are just a bit too lightweight.
 
Yes, not a coincidence.

I listened to the commentary on Radio Sheffield and lost count of the number of times he was praised not just for his passing and movement, attempts at goal but also for his tenacious defending and ball winning.

It's a fallacy that Keane is a better player to have in midfield away from home. He might be reasonable back up on occasions but he commits so many fouls in his attempts to win the ball and is a league or two below the rest of the team when we're in possession so slows our attacking play down to a completely ineffective pace. And Brownhill showed tonight that he's got great defensive qualities in addition to being probably the most talented young attacking midfielder in this division.

There are always going to be some games when you need a ball winner and Keane, although he has his limitations, is the best ball winner we have. With respect, you didn't actually see the game tonight and whilst I agree that Brownhill made some decent challenges, I honestly don't think you could say that at the moment he has 'great defensive qualities'. He is certainly improving in that regard and will continue to do so as he gets stronger but there are still times when he is brushed off the ball too easily.
 
Keane is a journeyman, an average-at-best journeyman.

To pick him in the team ahead of Brownhill is a footballing crime.

Agreed. Brownhill is the real deal. Brightest thing I've seen for a long time.

The only reason not to pick him is if you believe the mantra that a young lad needs to be introduced slowly. (I do... but if I was in charge, I'd have played a bit more than he has)
 
Don't think he can control a game like Kilkenny and isn't as much of a presence as Welsh/Keane... but he's a class above all 3? It's such a strange one, I'd have a CM 2 and then Brownhill behind Garner. He is gonna be a major part of our team next season for sure.
 
for me NO, doesnt break up play, in some games that formation will do well but against tough opposition then welsh every time

Even with that argument, I'd play him before Kilkenny whose job in the team he is capable of doing with more attacking intent.
 
Shows how differently people can see games, I suppose. I wasn't impressed with Brownhill, particularly- thought Kilkenny outshone him in the centre, dictating play.
 
I thought Kilkenny shaded Brownhill for MoM, but it's not a coincidence we put on out best display of controlled possession football for a long time with those two running midfield. It was a pleasure to watch some if the patient build up play we worked, whereas often we do it for a few passes before panicking and just lumping it up.
 
I think Simon is handling the undoubted talent of Josh very well by not flogging him to death and having him in and out of the team as needs must.

Its far too easy to flog young players to death and set them back. Some times setting them back forever.

Hopefully Josh will be a key member of the midfield for years to come.
 
I think Simon is handling the undoubted talent of Josh very well by not flogging him to death and having him in and out of the team as needs must.

Its far too easy to flog young players to death and set them back. Some times setting them back forever.


Good comment.

In addition, maybe Grayson thinks that now is the time to finally unleash Brownhill so that he can grab a regular starting place. The business end of the season has started with 9 + 2 or 3 games remaining. The young lad is fresh and raring to go with his batteries charged thanks to Grayson keeping him in cotton wool. But from now on, there shouldn't be any problem for him to play in all of our remaining matches, I reckon.
 
I'd like to know some people's definition of a 'journeyman' if they include Keith Keane in that bracket.

27yrs old and playing for his 2nd club....
 
I'd like to know some people's definition of a 'journeyman' if they include Keith Keane in that bracket.

27yrs old and playing for his 2nd club....

+1, agreed. Ridiculous comment, but considering where it came from, perhaps that's to be expected.
 
There are always going to be some games when you need a ball winner and Keane, although he has his limitations, is the best ball winner we have. With respect, you didn't actually see the game tonight and whilst I agree that Brownhill made some decent challenges, I honestly don't think you could say that at the moment he has 'great defensive qualities'. He is certainly improving in that regard and will continue to do so as he gets stronger but there are still times when he is brushed off the ball too easily.

Keane's limitations were clearly displayed in our home match with Leyton Orient when from the first minute his focus seemed to be on battering his opponent at every opportunity and in such a crude and blatant way I thought he was lucky not to have been sent off. Their goal came as a direct result of one of his many needless fouls turning a situation of no pressure on us to a dangerous free kick which resulted in their goal.

He might be the best ball winner we have (in your opinion) but you have to balance his ball winning skills against his numerous fouls, his inability to use the ball when he has won it and is inability or unwillingness to "show for the ball" when we're in possession.

In contrast we have a class player like Brownhill who can win the ball fairly and most importantly use it so well. If you saw his performance at the City Ground in our first match against Forest you'd have seen how well he can defend and how composed he is in the defending third in his movement to create space and his accurate short passing to keep possession and calmly bring the ball forward and away from danger.

No I couldn't get to the match last night but listened to the whole match commentary on the radio and it sounded to me very much like Brownhill and Kilkenny controlled the centre midfield, ball winning, good movement, keeping possession and great forward passing.
 
I think Simon is handling the undoubted talent of Josh very well by not flogging him to death and having him in and out of the team as needs must.

Its far too easy to flog young players to death and set them back. Some times setting them back forever.

Hopefully Josh will be a key member of the midfield for years to come.

Spot on.

Josh Brownhill has the chance to be one of the best PNE players for many years.

It would be easy to stick him in every week but the last thing we want to do is burn him out or risking injry which would delay his development.

I fully expect Josh to play more regularly over the next 12 months, however I fully commend Simon's management of him.

Had the medal winner still be here I don't think we would even be having this conversation.
 
+1, agreed. Ridiculous comment, but considering where it came from, perhaps that's to be expected.

Well, instead of "journeyman" a better description of Keane would possibly have been "lower-league footballer". It would have reflected better what type of player Keane is compared to Brownhill, who many of us tend to thinks as "future Premiership player".

Personally, I think Keith Keane is a good player to have in our squad.
 
Spot on.

Josh Brownhill has the chance to be one of the best PNE players for many years.

It would be easy to stick him in every week but the last thing we want to do is burn him out or risking injry which would delay his development.

I fully expect Josh to play more regularly over the next 12 months, however I fully commend Simon's management of him.

Had the medal winner still be here I don't think we would even be having this conversation.

Indeed. Next game is Swindon away. I would be surprised if we lined up with the same central midfield pairing on Saturday.

Last night I thought both Kilkenny and Brownhill played well, but I'm not sure that Brownhill can yet dictate the pace of as many games as Kilkenny does. Given time and the correct nurturing by SG, I'm confident that eventually he could be twice the player, but he is only 18.
 
Whilst I appreciate Kilkenny does wonders for our possession stats linking up with our back four and going from side to side against a lone striker does not in itself lead to much.

In the final third, when we get there, Kilkenny does not have anywhere near the influence I would like him to have. His passing remains safe and often telegraphed particularly balls out wide which seem more often than not to give the likes of Humphreys more problems than the defenders he is up against.

On a couple of occasions Kilkenny and Brownhill exchanged passes moving forward but it was rare that this happened.

I understand that retaining the ball is a good thing but I felt that we missed opportunities to get the ball in from wide areas last night. In part this is due to the time spent getting the ball out there due to the pace dictated by Kilkenny.

Brownhill could play this role better alongside welch in a midfield four and would also create and get on the end of chances. Brown hills control movement and pace are very impressive for an 18 year old and if we do miss out this season it might be to his long term benefit if he becomes a regular starter in this league over a season before taking on the championship.

I enjoyed our performance overall last night not the scoreline.
 
You can't compare Brownhill and Keane, they both have different strengths. Decrying Keane as a journeyman is fine as long as he emulates journeyman Graham Alexander who was so called when he joined us also from Luton.
 
Back
Top