Buchanan
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2004
- Messages
- 2,870
Another very assured performance from Buchs. IMO he has been our best left back this season. I hope he keeps the shirt and gets a good run of games behind him.
+1
Excellent shout, Holdy la'. Was superb last night - defensively and going forward. A very dependable player.
- Joined
- Apr 8, 2012
- Messages
- 6,513
Normally I'd prefer Laird for his attacking capability, but he hasn't yet been as good as last season. Buchanan doesn't really offer much either but is reliable and keeps the ball. He had a very assured game yesterday albeit while having very little to deal with defensively. Probably has edged it out of the two left backs so far.
dirk pnemouse
The Gentry (RIP)
- Joined
- Nov 1, 2006
- Messages
- 26,968
Thought he was mom last night and looked great on the over lap just think he needed feeding more once he went
We need a left-sided midfielder who can play at the side of either a three or four-man midfield and form a partnership with either of Laird or Buchanan. That is the missing link in the side. Gallagher, even though he got past the defender on occasion last night, is not a wide player. With Humphrey for the right, a new player for the left and Holmes available for either we would have a range of options that we just don't currently possess. It is a pity that Hayhurst for whatever reason has not progressed as fast as it looked like he might. I still think it would be useful to have him back available for us.
- Joined
- Apr 8, 2012
- Messages
- 6,513
We need a left-sided midfielder who can play at the side of either a three or four-man midfield and form a partnership with either of Laird or Buchanan. That is the missing link in the side. Gallagher, even though he got past the defender on occasion last night, is not a wide player. With Humphrey for the right, a new player for the left and Holmes available for either we would have a range of options that we just don't currently possess. It is a pity that Hayhurst for whatever reason has not progressed as fast as it looked like he might. I still think it would be useful to have him back available for us.
Hayhurst would add nothing to what we currently have. He may be a useful player, but we need quality and he doesn't have it.
Laird has been slowly improving the last few weeks from what I've seen, particularly away from home, whilst Buchanan has been consistently very good all season.
The latter will have felt hard done by when out of the first XI as he hasn't put a foot wrong.
I am happy whoever plays but seeing as though Buchanan has proved to be dependable when called upon, he should keep his place for the Swindon game.
The latter will have felt hard done by when out of the first XI as he hasn't put a foot wrong.
I am happy whoever plays but seeing as though Buchanan has proved to be dependable when called upon, he should keep his place for the Swindon game.
- Joined
- Dec 10, 2009
- Messages
- 2,876
Let's not forget Lairds leg brake. It can take a player several months to regain confidence, mental strength and skill levels after a serious injury.
Buchs had a great game last night and it's good we have a choice of two of the best backs in the league.
Buchs had a great game last night and it's good we have a choice of two of the best backs in the league.
- Joined
- Apr 8, 2012
- Messages
- 6,513
Thought he was mom last night and looked great on the over lap just think he needed feeding more once he went
Played well yes. Man of the match, not for me. He does overlap and keep the ball well but he doesn't know what to do in attacking positions when he does overlap.
Buchanan is not only are best left-back but 1 of the best in league1 any time he's played this season he's been outstanding, I like laird but this season, buchs has be a far better player, if you look most of our clean sheets have came with him in the starting 11
Buchanan is quite simply a hoof merchant.
Not once does he try to attack the oppo's fullback like Laird does. He simply hoofs it in at around 45* from the halfway line which is easy to defend against. Last night, certainly 1st half, being a prime example.
The stats for assists this season between both players lends weight to my argument about his distribution.
Laird >>>>>>>>>>>> Buchanan.
Not once does he try to attack the oppo's fullback like Laird does. He simply hoofs it in at around 45* from the halfway line which is easy to defend against. Last night, certainly 1st half, being a prime example.
The stats for assists this season between both players lends weight to my argument about his distribution.
Laird >>>>>>>>>>>> Buchanan.
- Joined
- Jul 5, 2004
- Messages
- 5,200
Didn't really understand what Buchanan did to get dropped in the first place. Our most consistent player. When picked.
Buchanan is quite simply a hoof merchant.
Not once does he try to attack the oppo's fullback like Laird does. He simply hoofs it in at around 45* from the halfway line which is easy to defend against. Last night, certainly 1st half, being a prime example.
The stats for assists this season between both players lends weight to my argument about his distribution.
Laird >>>>>>>>>>>> Buchanan.
Ur 100% right if he had a few assists in him he would be playing in the premier league,
Ur 100% right if he had a few assists in him he would be playing in the premier league,
I suspect that you're taking the piss with me.
Do you not agree that his distribution is awful?
Wiseman (as well as Laird), on the other hand, is everything that Buchanan should aspire to be as a modern day fullback.
- Joined
- Mar 22, 2007
- Messages
- 4,619
Buchanan is quite simply a hoof merchant.
Not once does he try to attack the oppo's fullback like Laird does. He simply hoofs it in at around 45* from the halfway line which is easy to defend against. Last night, certainly 1st half, being a prime example.
The stats for assists this season between both players lends weight to my argument about his distribution.
Laird >>>>>>>>>>>> Buchanan.
Are you serious JD?
Buchanan has been the better left-back all season for me, shame as I like Laird, but Buchs has been in good form all season.
As for not attacking the full-back, what about the assist for Kev Davies' goal vs Coventry.
Think we're watching different games.
dirk pnemouse
The Gentry (RIP)
- Joined
- Nov 1, 2006
- Messages
- 26,968
I must of been watching a different game to everyone else! I thought he was very poor the other night.
Easiest way is to ask you what he did poorly
- Joined
- Apr 24, 2005
- Messages
- 262
Firstly, we have two very good left backs at this level. But I have to agree with JD, Laird just offers more going forward. He has more of an attacking instict. Neither are helped, I don't think, with the way Gallagher plays in front of them (I do like PG by the way, just not sure where he is best suited).