Skip to main content

Buchanan

Buchanan

Are we rating defenders for how many goals they get now? Fuck it, let's bring back Neill Collins.
So let's get this right. You prefer a defender who has the same defending ability as the other but can't score goals?
 
So let's get this right. You prefer a defender who has the same defending ability as the other but can't score goals?

i think the majority of fans would agree that Buchanan is better than Laird defensively. Laird was much better offensively than Buchanan before his injury but subsequent to his injury he has been poor at both. Davies is promising but badly lacks experience and has been crucified by Coppinger and Campbell-Rice this season. None of our three left backs are good enough. Ideally loan out Davies to York again, get rid by loan or sale of Laird and Buchanan and get one cracking left back to replace them. Use Callam Woods as back up. Simple really.
 
From where i was sat it was cleared on the left by Buchanan (who was then fouled) It was then played through the middle, gave away by our midfield & back past our centre halfs who clearly had no communication all evening. Either way imo Buchanan was 1 of our better players.
 
Are you for real? He was one of the only committed players tonight! Wish more players were going in for challenges like he was! Least he didn't stand off the players like Woods and the midfield three did!

"Going in for challenges" hardly makes him a good defender which is his role in the job first & foremost.

As another poster said his performances in the Play Offs were abysmal. Laird should be starting.
 
I don't know why Laird isn't in the team.

Buchanan can do a job, he can nullify a winger but he isn't someone who can provide a viable outlet going forward because he has no end product.

The question is, can young Ben Davies add this to his game? Having three left backs isn't helping, one of them needs to go. My ideal would be to send Davies out on loan again.
 
I don't know why Laird isn't in the team.

Buchanan can do a job, he can nullify a winger but he isn't someone who can provide a viable outlet going forward because he has no end product.

Buchanan is the better full-back for me. If you want a fancy left-back who is prone to getting beat then Laird is the answer unquestionably. However if you want someone solid, who fine might not be the fanciest on the eye but undoubtedly does a job to a good standard then Buchs is the man for me.

The question is, can young Ben Davies add this to his game? Having three left backs isn't helping, one of them needs to go. My ideal would be to send Davies out on loan again.

Not good enough yet at this level. Needs to go back out on loan.
 
Back
Top