Skip to main content

Callum Robinson

Callum Robinson

rem

Joined
Jun 7, 2004
Messages
13,345
AVillaFan blog:-

"At the start of the season, Callum Robinson looked set to be catapulted into first team action. Since then, the young Englishman has been sent out on loan to gain experience with Preston North End. Can Robinson cut the mustard? Villa Park is a graveyard for academy prospects who fail to deliver such as Luke Moore, his brother Stefan and Nathan Delfouneso. Is Robinson destined for the same fate or is he the next teenage prodigy?

Paul Lambert has shown a lot of faith in the youngster, who recently signed a new deal with Aston Villa Football Club and started to chalk up appearances towards the back end of last season. At his age, you would expect him still to be developing into a full player. Simon Grayson is the perfect manager to nurture Robinson, given his Villa links. Many see Robinson as a direct replacement for Agbonlahor. I see a lot more in the youngster. He has an impressive goal-scoring record in the academy ranks for club and country.

While gaining experience in League One, he is learning his game and more about his strengths and weaknesses. He is a player who has a lot of ability. Will he be well nurtured by Keane and Lambert? Both have a big part role to play in Robinson’s career. The youngster needs guiding to the top.

So far, Robinson has not started a game for Preston North End but he has played the last twenty minutes of the past few games. This does not give him much chance to score or make his mark. Perhaps the thinking behind his loan move to League One was to toughen him up, as happened with Jack Grealish last season. He could be starting at Preston but Preston’s current striker, Garner, is in fine form".
 
Seems highly thought of.

Hopefully he will get more time with us; otherwise he will probably be recalled.
 
I'd like to see him play but we don't currently need him and wouldn't change a winning formula just to accommodate him. Especially if only here for a month. If got him for the season then I'd utilise him more.
 
Seems highly thought of.

Hopefully he will get more time with us; otherwise he will probably be recalled.

He'd only go back to their Under-21s, better to train and be involved with our first-team. Who would you put him ahead of at the moment? Gallagher has played better in the last couple of games and Humphrey is back in on the right. Could change to a 4-4-2 and have him up there with Garner, or have him playing behind Garner in Brownhill's position?
 
He'd only go back to their Under-21s, better to train and be involved with our first-team. Who would you put him ahead of at the moment? Gallagher has played better in the last couple of games and Humphrey is back in on the right. Could change to a 4-4-2 and have him up there with Garner, or have him playing behind Garner in Brownhill's position?

I agree with that but why did SG sign him? Humphrey, Davies, Little and Hugill were unavailable but he still has only had about 40 mins in 3 games and only Hugill of those 4 will be out for much longer.

If he can't get a game when 4 players are out, he is unlikely to feature much in the future. Despite what you say about their Under-21's I am sure that Lambert only loaned him to us to get "game" time. I just feel that it a pity he hasn't had that although I accept that it is now difficult to play him ahead of the other 3 you mention following our upturn in form. The best opportunity was to play him ahead of Gallagher just after he signed but Gallagher's form has improved since which may be connected.

I am worried that we might have a great talent on our books for a month, as supported by the initial blog, and he will go back to Villa without us having the opportunity to see much of this talent.

He needs more than the occasional 20 mins to impress. If he was playing regularly and playing well, I feel that both clubs would want to extend the loan.
 
I agree with that but why did SG sign him? Humphrey, Davies, Little and Hugill were unavailable but he still has only had about 40 mins in 3 games and only Hugill of those 4 will be out for much longer.

If he can't get a game when 4 players are out, he is unlikely to feature much in the future. Despite what you say about their Under-21's I am sure that Lambert only loaned him to us to get "game" time. I just feel that it a pity he hasn't had that although I accept that it is now difficult to play him ahead of the other 3 you mention following our upturn in form. The best opportunity was to play him ahead of Gallagher just after he signed but Gallagher's form has improved since which may be connected.

I am worried that we might have a great talent on our books for a month, as supported by the initial blog, and he will go back to Villa without us having the opportunity to see much of this talent.

He needs more than the occasional 20 mins to impress. If he was playing regularly and playing well, I feel that both clubs would want to extend the loan.
I'm sure that Grayson will have assessed him in training. I'm equally sure that we wouldn't have signed someone not to play them. He may not be fit, he may not fit a particular game plan, he may need to learn how we play. There could be umpteen reasons why he hasn't played a lot so far. Doesn't mean, we won't use him or that his loan won't be extended.
 
Possibly Robinson was brought in to be the reserve option for Garner while Little and Davies are absent, which would explain why he hasn't been used much. There might be a case for starting him ahead of Humphrey on Saturday given that the latter puts in a lot of defensive work in away matches but often doesn't pose too much of an attacking threat in home games though if we were to make such a switch then you imagine Reid might get the nod. Maybe Robinson will get a start in the next Paint Pot match.
 
I agree with that but why did SG sign him? Humphrey, Davies, Little and Hugill were unavailable but he still has only had about 40 mins in 3 games and only Hugill of those 4 will be out for much longer.

Aye but Humphrey missed 1 game, and he and Little were replaced by wide players i.e. Hayhurst. Davies and Hugill were subs so he has actually replaced them by taking their spot as being back up front man. Unless he needs to replace Garner, or we're behind and need to change it with 2 up front I wouldn't expect to see much more of Robinson, especially with Reid edging towards a start or at the very least longer sub appearances.

We may well not see the best of him, and he may well go elsewhere and bag plenty, but I can't see Grayson changing things around formation wise to accomodate a player on a months youth loan.
 
Getting the odd 15-20 minutes here and there at League One level and probably starting in the JPT is better than playing U-21 reserve games.
 
I'm not sure how people wanted Grayson to use this lad in any other way than he has. As far as I can see he has done the following:
- Given him game time in a difficult match when under the cosh on the very day that we signed him, ultimately we conceded when he was on the field whilst not scoring (not saying any of this was his fault)
- Kept him on the bench in a dominating display v Crawley
- Managed to give him 20 or so mins in an overall great display v Coventry

What else do people want? Drop Garner? Play 4-4-2 to accommodate him?

Hopefully, we won't need to play him much more than we are doing. However, if we do need him then I hope that he is able to contribute to winning us a lot of points.
 
I'm not sure how people wanted Grayson to use this lad in any other way than he has. As far as I can see he has done the following:
- Given him game time in a difficult match when under the cosh on the very day that we signed him, ultimately we conceded when he was on the field whilst not scoring (not saying any of this was his fault)
- Kept him on the bench in a dominating display v Crawley
- Managed to give him 20 or so mins in an overall great display v Coventry

What else do people want? Drop Garner? Play 4-4-2 to accommodate him?

Hopefully, we won't need to play him much more than we are doing. However, if we do need him then I hope that he is able to contribute to winning us a lot of points.

No reason why he couldn't be used as one of a front 3, in a 4-3-3 formation. No need to change formation to accommodate him, just depends on whether ST wants to use him.
 
He's a loan player. He's here as cover. If we hadn't signed him we'd have no striker on the bench, and then what would happen if Garner got a knock or we had to chase a game? Why drop a senior player and disrupt the rhythm of the side in order to accommodate a guy who's only here for a month?

I'm really not sure what people expected to happen when we signed this lad. If he was here a bit longer then maybe he'd have time to get a few more minutes, prove himself and earn a starting place. As it is he could go back barely having played, and I'm fine with that if it means the teams performing well.
 
Pretty sure Robinson will be here all season. He's settling in at the moment which I think is actually good management. No need to rush him in, let him get used to this level gradually. It's a long season and he could have a major impact as it wears on. If he is anything like as good as Jack Grealish then I will be more than happy.
 
He's a loan player. He's here as cover. If we hadn't signed him we'd have no striker on the bench, and then what would happen if Garner got a knock or we had to chase a game? Why drop a senior player and disrupt the rhythm of the side in order to accommodate a guy who's only here for a month?

I'm really not sure what people expected to happen when we signed this lad. If he was here a bit longer then maybe he'd have time to get a few more minutes, prove himself and earn a starting place. As it is he could go back barely having played, and I'm fine with that if it means the teams performing well.

My thoughts pretty much exactly.

As for saying he could play in a 4-3-3, maybe that is the case, but would he do the job as well as the players that we already have? Not so sure myself, and I think that is what SG think too at the moment. Also, when does 4-3-3 become 4-5-1?
 
My thoughts pretty much exactly.

As for saying he could play in a 4-3-3, maybe that is the case, but would he do the job as well as the players that we already have? Not so sure myself, and I think that is what SG think too at the moment. Also, when does 4-3-3 become 4-5-1?

When we don't have the ball.
 
Back
Top