Skip to main content

Callum Woods?

Callum Woods?

Arfield was still reletively young at 24, when he was released. And signed for a club with great players playing around him.

And Tom Clarke being in the run in for our player of the year isn't saying a great deal either, if we're being totally honest. We finished 5th in League One.
Clarke is decent, but not 'next level' decent.

Southern & P. Clarke? Well...........

I wouldn't want Southern or P. Clarke but it's still unfair to disregard every released player. I think tom Clarke could do a job in the league above too, nothing amazing but competent.
 
I wouldn't want Southern or P. Clarke but it's still unfair to disregard every released player. I think tom Clarke could do a job in the league above too, nothing amazing but competent.

Yeah, I don't usually just disregard every player that gets released. That would be daft.

As long as they're of the right age, room for improvement etc, then they're worth giving another chance.

Players that are getting released at the age of 28 and above, having previously been given a chance at a higher level, and not cut the mustard so to speak, aren't the type of player we should be looking at, IMO. Not for where we want to be heading anyway (Championship, asap)

I seriously can't see this lad Woods being better than anything we've already got for RB or LB. And at 28, isn't going to suddenly turn into Cafu or Paolo Maldini.
 
Sounds like Wiseman Mk II.

In what way? As he's a RB?

Been released by Huddersfield means he's probably 'not that good'

I'm sick of us being linked with Huddersfields dead wood. We're better than this.

We're in league one... still.

In fairness, they released Scott Arfield who was probably Burnley's player of the season, behind their front two.

Tom Clarke was in the running for our player of the season too.

Good post.
 
Tom Clarke is decent enough at this level but; would he have gotten into the Wolves, Brentford or even Rotherham & Leyton Orient teams, this year?

He's decent, but not as good as some make out.

Clarke was our POTY by a country mile IMO, consistent week in week out, good defender, can play across the back 4 & chips in with goals, can't see what else you'd want.

He would get into pretty much any team in League 1. How would he cope with a step up a level? Who knows but I'd be replacing plenty of others before him if we did go up.
 
Tom Clarke is decent enough at this level but; would he have gotten into the Wolves, Brentford or even Rotherham & Leyton Orient teams, this year?

He's decent, but not as good as some make out.

Rotherham have Craig Morgan and Kari Arnason. Rotherham's defensive record is much much worse than ours. Go figure. Brentford and Orient both have an average set of defenders but are helped out by their attacking players. You have a point with Wolves but they shouldn't have been in this division in the first place. They've probably spent millions on their defence, whilst we got Clarke on a free.
 
Yeah, I don't usually just disregard every player that gets released. That would be daft.

As long as they're of the right age, room for improvement etc, then they're worth giving another chance.

Players that are getting released at the age of 28 and above, having previously been given a chance at a higher level, and not cut the mustard so to speak, aren't the type of player we should be looking at, IMO. Not for where we want to be heading anyway (Championship, asap)

I seriously can't see this lad Woods being better than anything we've already got for RB or LB. And at 28, isn't going to suddenly turn into Cafu or Paolo Maldini.
So "as long as they're of the right age, room for improvement etc, then they're worth giving another chance", provided there's also a chance they'll "suddenly turn into Cafu or Paolo Maldini"?
 
Craig Morgan has improved greatly since his time with us, and has had a more successful season than Tom Clarke.

Ask a Rotherham fan if they'd swap Morgan for Clarke and they'd tell you to get shafted.

I'm not saying one is better than the other but, Morgan has been part of a better all round team, and had more success than Tom Clarke. The facts don't lie.

For me Morgan is one of north ends worst all time centre halves admittedly in champ.
 
For me Morgan is one of north ends worst all time centre halves admittedly in champ.
He was awful but probably not even as bad as St Ledger who played alongside him (post-Boro) was at the time. And he was certainly no worse than Neill Collins.
 
Back
Top