Skip to main content

Callum Woods

Callum Woods

Joined
Jan 27, 2012
Messages
4,558
Location
Manchester
Not sure this lad fits the bill for me. Quiet clear he is one of Simon's faves but i feel for Wiseman who is in my opinion a much better player for that position.

I think that Wiseman is better defensively and also offers much more going forward.

Woods is a bang average League One defender who is helpful to have in our squad because of his versatility. However, in terms of being a dominant RB who offers a threat going forward.... sorry he is not that player.

I suppose that if you sign someone on a free you have to accept that.
 
Woods was dog shit on Saturday.

Wiseman has a mistake in him but he is very good going forward, calm in possession and has the pace to recover when he's out of position or in trouble. Much better player than Woods imo.
 
Woods was dog shit on Saturday.

Wiseman has a mistake in him but he is very good going forward, calm in possession and has the pace to recover when he's out of position or in trouble. Much better player than Woods imo.

Completely agree. I don't see what he offers to the team other than running around a bit. You want players that are dynamic and are prepared to step up and offer something. Woods is not that player. If anything i quiver when the ball/opposing player goes near him.

Wiseman on the other hand (Rotherham away in the play offs aside) seems much more assured. The runs he was making from full back last season offered us a new dimension in attack and allowed the forward players to get into the box more often. He was arguably MOTM away at Tranmere last season. The run he made later in the game when he fed Garner was marvellous.
 
Wiseman was class at both Tranmere and Oldham last season, set up a goal in both I think.

Also thought he had a really good game against Forest at Deepdale too, even though we lost.
 
Wiseman was class at both Tranmere and Oldham last season, set up a goal in both I think.

Also though he had a really good game against Forest at Deepdale too, even though we lost.

Agree. Really don't understand why he has fallen out of favour so much? Grayson brought him here!
 
Wiseman on the other hand (Rotherham away in the play offs aside)

When he was not match fit and played out-of-position in that 'wing-back' we used then. Bizarre thinking by SG that night when he ditched the defensively reliable if unadventurous in attack duo of Humphrey and Laird in favour of the obviously ineffective - in those roles - Wiseman and Buchanan. Nothing against Woods himself who seems to be a reliable but unremarkable trier but why we ever signed him with Wiseman already on-board and Keane, even King, even possibly Humphrey (who might make a better right-back than 'winger') as back-up is a mystery. It would be interesting to see if Wiseman and Laird might give us a bit more going forward than we have had at times over the past few games. Laird will presumably now get the chance to play a few games with Davies on loan and Buchanan injured. Perhaps Wiseman will as well at some point.
 
Incidentally, i felt that Laird played much better than Buchanan when he came on at HT on Saturday.

At present, my preferred back four would consist of the following:

RB - Wiseman
CB - Tom Clarke
CB - Bailey Wright
LB - Scott Laird
 
I don't understand why SG felt that we needed another right back when we had Wiseman and Keane in reserve. It is a wasted salary in my view which could have better spent in strengthening another position.
 
I don't understand why SG felt that we needed another right back when we had Wiseman and Keane in reserve. It is a wasted salary in my view which could have better spent in strengthening another position.

I tend to agree, but I think Grayson considered Keane's time up at Deepdale. I also believe that Woods can play/has played left back, and now that Buchanan seems injured and with Davies having gone out on loan, PNE might only have one left back in Laird. He (Woods) might be the emergency left back for the next few weeks.
 
Woods was dog shit on Saturday.

Wiseman has a mistake in him but he is very good going forward, calm in possession and has the pace to recover when he's out of position or in trouble. Much better player than Woods imo.

Agree with most of this. Imo we have 2 decent left backs in Buchs and Laird. The rest of the defence can piss off elsewhere. Wiseman is one of those for me - as you say he gets out of position and gets in trouble. If someone who does that is better than what we've got then all we've got is rubbish!
 
I agree with everybody on here. Wiseman should be starting ahead of Woods. Wiseman offers much more going forward. On Saturday, Woods only got forward a couple of times and that was near the end of the game. I'd pick Wiseman over Woods, but at the end of the day it's up to Grayson
 
Woods looks like he might amount to being a solid full-back option, although he has been terribly inconsistent since arriving. I'd even hazard a guess that 'solid, if uninspiring' might be the pinnacle of his potential here at North End.

Wiseman offers different attributes, which although they're more exuberant, I fear make him equally as disappointing.

I have held the following opinion for a long time, and that is: I cannot understand why Keane in not our first choice Right-back. He's got a great engine, tough in the tackle and he closes players down quickly. As well as being very neat and composed on the ball, he's also a leader - a quality which seems to have been traded in for (at best) like-for-like replacements.
 
Wiseman has the physique to be a central defence alternative to Bailey Wright, and the skill to bring the ball out of defence.
 
Keith Keane is the best right back on our books atm and we've shipped him out. Leaving us with flimsy weak efforts that can't tackle and certainly don't scare any winger. When Woods or Wiseman come on the pitch you don't get their name chanted by the fans. With Keano you do ... which speaks for itself!
 


Off topic, but that video also highlights how woeful Kilkenny is at defending (around 1:03). He was much more effective and influential on Saturday when he was allowed to get forward rather than sitting and shielding the back 4. He is a liability defensively. Certainly for away games, I would play King, or Welsh when fit, as the defensive midfielder, with Kilkenny and Browne allowed to get forward. Of course, the ideal player for that defensive role would be Keane, who more than makes up for his lack of frills by actually tackling and winning the ball to break up opposition attacks, thereby lifting his team mates and the crowd.

As for Woods, I agree with most posters that he is distinctly average.
 
Last edited:
Keith Keane is the best right back on our books atm and we've shipped him out. Leaving us with flimsy weak efforts that can't tackle and certainly don't scare any winger. When Woods or Wiseman come on the pitch you don't get their name chanted by the fans. With Keano you do ... which speaks for itself!
And yet when Keith Keane regularly played at right back for us under Mr Medals, opposition wingers apparently did not wilt in the face of his run-through-walls-get-a-yellow-card approach, preferring instead to go home with some or (more often than not) all of the points instead.

Grayson may have had a couple of looks at Keane at right-back, but I'm pretty sure he always played Paul Connolly, Tom Clarke or Someone Else there when he had an option (and wasn't using wingbacks), didn't he?
 
Incidentally, i felt that Laird played much better than Buchanan when he came on at HT on Saturday.

At present, my preferred back four would consist of the following:

RB - Wiseman
CB - Tom Clarke
CB - Bailey Wright
LB - Scott Laird

But Bailey Wright is such a liability, has at least one rush of blood per game, a blooper which has nearly cost us dear. We need a Centre half to replace him asap or give Huntingdon a run in the side.

Wiseman gives us a better option going forward but is also prone to losing his man, woods is two footed that's what SG will like in him, its a 50/50 between them. I would say sue Wiseman at home and woods away
 
Back
Top