Skip to main content

Central defence

Central defence

Joined
Nov 9, 2010
Messages
8,292
Location
York
Very optimistic about this season but I have one niggling doubt. Bailey is excellent and should be playing at a higher level. Hunts is OK, decent enough at this level. SCS is not really good enough and his career is on the downward spiral. Clarke is a right back who can cover at centre half.

I think we are a bit light in this area and I'd be very worried if Bailey got injured, I think we'd really struggle without him. Obviously the budget is now very stretched but maybe we could get a good youngster from the prem to act as cover. Yeovil had Dan Burn from Fulham last season and he was a huge part in why they went up. I know he has moved elsewhere now but someone of that ilk would be great.
 
Very optimistic about this season but I have one niggling doubt. Bailey is excellent and should be playing at a higher level. Hunts is OK, decent enough at this level. SCS is not really good enough and his career is on the downward spiral. Clarke is a right back who can cover at centre half.

I think we are a bit light in this area and I'd be very worried if Bailey got injured, I think we'd really struggle without him. Obviously the budget is now very stretched but maybe we could get a good youngster from the prem to act as cover. Yeovil had Dan Burn from Fulham last season and he was a huge part in why they went up. I know he has moved elsewhere now but someone of that ilk would be great.

Jack King can play there also and so can Ben Davies. Personally I'd rather we got a creative midfielder rather than a centre half, if we were to get someone in.
 
I agree, with Robertson gone we are a decent central defender short. We have good cover in the other defensive positions - Laird/Buchanan for LB, Keane/Clarke for RB - however Wright & Huntington are our only central defenders I have confidence in. SCS and Ben Davies could cover but I would want another back up in case either of the first choice pairing get injured.
 
Jack King can play there also and so can Ben Davies. Personally I'd rather we got a creative midfielder rather than a centre half, if we were to get someone in.

Take your point, I suppose I'm just worried if Bailey got a long term injury as the two you mention are short term cover options in my opinion.

Re creative midfielder, SG does not operate with creative midfielders. He gets decent wide men and a big man up front to hit as early as possible. Central midfielders in his teams are always scrappers (i.e. Welsh and Keane). Its the way he's always set his teams up.
 
Take your point, I suppose I'm just worried if Bailey got a long term injury as the two you mention are short term cover options in my opinion.

Re creative midfielder, SG does not operate with creative midfielders. He gets decent wide men and a big man up front to hit as early as possible. Central midfielders in his teams are always scrappers (i.e. Welsh and Keane). Its the way he's always set his teams up.

Fair enough if Grayson doesn't use creative midfielders. I just feel it's one area where we lack quality more than any other. To be honest though I wouldn't complain about any incoming player in any position, as long as they are a decent player.
 
I thought SCS looked pretty good at the start of last season before he (along with the rest of the team) was messed around by Westley

I think he panics too much when players run at him and he ends up fouling them, giving away penalties and sometimes getting sent off as a result. That said though he is a solid enough backup in my opinion and probably is on a favorable wage for the club.
 
Ben Davies at centre back? are people mental?

He's about 5'10" and absolutely rake thin. Looks a great left back but he would get annihilated against some of the big forwards in this league.

My Huddersfield supporting mate says Tom Clarke's best position is easily centre back.
 
Ben Davies at centre back? are people mental?

He's about 5'10" and absolutely rake thin. Looks a great left back but he would get annihilated against some of the big forwards in this league.

My Huddersfield supporting mate says Tom Clarke's best position is easily centre back.

Got to say, after watching Clarke on Saturday I do think he would be more suited to centre half. Think he would be a really useful centre half. Decent size, decent pace. Put in one or two decent tackles too.
 
Ben Davies at centre back? are people mental?

He's about 5'10" and absolutely rake thin. Looks a great left back but he would get annihilated against some of the big forwards in this league.

My Huddersfield supporting mate says Tom Clarke's best position is easily centre back.

I'd have to disagree, having seen him almost get beaten to a header by Jordon Ibe. Although he probably would survive at centre back against the poorer sides in the league. As for Davies he looks a decent player and as he played centre half throughout his time in the youth team, he could probably do a decent job there. Being a centre back is not solely about physical attributes, so to discount him purely on that is a bit unfair.
 
Ben Davies at centre back? are people mental?

He's about 5'10" and absolutely rake thin. Looks a great left back but he would get annihilated against some of the big forwards in this league.

My Huddersfield supporting mate says Tom Clarke's best position is easily centre back.
Agree with some points but Ben Davies has said that he wants to & does prefer playing CB cos that where he's played most of his young life & it was GW who picked him at LB, but if it was up to himself he wouldn't play at LB.
 
I'd have to disagree, having seen him almost get beaten to a header by Jordon Ibe. Although he probably would survive at centre back against the poorer sides in the league. As for Davies he looks a decent player and as he played centre half throughout his time in the youth team, he could probably do a decent job there. Being a centre back is not solely about physical attributes, so to discount him purely on that is a bit unfair.

One pre-season game against Liverpool and you know better than someone who has watched him play since he was a youth player? fair enough.

As for Davies, physical attributes are pretty important in this league for a centre back, there is no way B.Davies is out muscling or winning an aerial battle against the likes of Lee Miller, Clayton Donaldson, Akpo Sodje, Matias Pogba... Maybe in a few years but he's not ready yet aged 17.
 
Agree with some points but Ben Davies has said that he wants to & does prefer playing CB cos that where he's played most of his young life & it was GW who picked him at LB, but if it was up to himself he wouldn't play at LB.


Looks a naturally gifted full back to me, I think Westley may have called that one right.
 
OK but Ben has said in a interview that he prefers playing at CB.

Fair enough, I for one would be very wary of him playing there at the moment though. Given time perhaps but at the moment I think he would get found out at this level when the ball is in the air a lot and strikers are given license to be physical.
 
Ben Davies at centre back? are people mental?

He's about 5'10" and absolutely rake thin. Looks a great left back but he would get annihilated against some of the big forwards in this league.

Remember a rake thin...... Mark Lawrenson.

Also agree with earlier posts - would like to see Jack King given a game in per-seaon at C/B sure GW said once it was his best position.
 
One pre-season game against Liverpool and you know better than someone who has watched him play since he was a youth player? fair enough.

As for Davies, physical attributes are pretty important in this league for a centre back, there is no way B.Davies is out muscling or winning an aerial battle against the likes of Lee Miller, Clayton Donaldson, Akpo Sodje, Matias Pogba... Maybe in a few years but he's not ready yet aged 17.

Of course I'm not saying I know better than someone who seen him play since he was a youth player. I can only base my opinion on what I've seen so far, and from that I wasn't convinced. I would love to see Clarke do well though at centre back if required.
 
I agree with the OP, need some extra cover - probably on loan. Davies will not be a centre half for at least another 1-2 seasons (if at all at this level), King isn't good enough, not sure about Clarke and SCS is ok at best.
 
Back
Top