Skip to main content

Central midfield yet again

Central midfield yet again

A churlish thread, our players did us all proud last night, showed class, dignity and lots of fight. Didnt bottle it at all. We were up against 200 million quids of talent and we nearly did it.
 
I called it months ago about Kilkenny and like most things people are finally realising I'm right.

Not good enough.

Match Reporter from Britain's biggest selling daily rag :
Quote "With Neil Kilkenny pulling the strings intelligently, Preston were growing in confidence ....

And against an £100m+ midfield ....

Funny how opinions differ .....
 
I actually thought Kilkenny started well last night and seemed to be offering more energy, movement and thinking more positively. His influence waned though and, especially when he was wider going up against the united left flank in the second half he struggled.

If he can show the same dynamism going in coming games our midfield would be much the better for it.
 
A churlish thread, our players did us all proud last night, showed class, dignity and lots of fight. Didnt bottle it at all. We were up against 200 million quids of talent and we nearly did it.
exactly and if Kilkenny was good enough to impose himself on their midfield then he clearly wouldn't be playing for us
 
We still need another central midfielder. The Cup run - as SG seems to have indicated - has provided the funds to get one. Next week will see the point where a loan period would include the play-offs. Surely SG must have a couple of targets, so by the end of next week we will hopefully have made the one acquisition we really need.
 
We are still an assertive, quality central midfielder short of where we need to be. Last night simply showed that with particular clarity. Laird is also now verging on being too slow to be really effective in that 'wing-back role - he simply can't get past a fullback way out wide - he is at his best popping up in more central positions as he did for that glorious moment last night.

He was up against Valencia ffs !
Welsh was being pretty assertive last night , he was putting challenges In all over , pair him with Johnson and see how it works .
 
He was up against Valencia ffs !
Welsh was being pretty assertive last night , he was putting challenges In all over , pair him with Johnson and see how it works .

I'm well aware of who we were up against. As I've said before Welsh has been a fine servant of the club and he probably made the difference between us being relegated or not a couple of seasons ago - so we owe him a lot. But he has been in visible decline for a couple of seasons and a younger, faster player is needed. I will pay Welsh the compliment of saying that what we need is another version of the player he was a couple of years ago.
 
It's hard to single out any players for being poor against Manchester United.

Yes Kilkenny wasn't great, but he was against a midfield of Di Maria, Fellaini, Blind and Herrera, which cost approximately £130m.

That said, I think CM is the area we need to strengthen in the loan window, and Kilkenny has been quiet for a few months now, but it's hard to criticize him after playing a £130m midfield.
 
Laird is also now verging on being too slow to be really effective in that 'wing-back role - he simply can't get past a fullback way out wide - he is at his best popping up in more central positions as he did for that glorious moment last night.

Laird isn't slow, but he may have looked it last night against Valencia. I guess with the way that Shaw went past Humphrey in the first half you will be declaring him slow as well?
 
I don't mind Kilkenny and Welsh but this was the centre two which wasn't good enough in the playoffs last year.

We have only improved the starting XI (my choice) with:

Johnstone
Robinson
Johnson

We never hadn't the experienced centre mid we had been crying out for a good while now...
 
Laird isn't slow, but he may have looked it last night against Valencia. I guess with the way that Shaw went past Humphrey in the first half you will be declaring him slow as well?

Laird has never been particularly fast. When played at left-back before his injury he was effective as an attacker not by getting up on the overlap but by getting up on the underlap if you like and finding space in and around the penalty box - exactly what he did last night for the goal. It seems he was effective in the 4th Round replay because again he took up a lot of central positions. Experience shows that the 'wing-back' formation with Humphrey and Laird wide is effective at getting the points away from home but not against teams that sit back at our place because neither of them can get past a fullback with any frequency. At the moment I would say that Laird would be most effective at our place as part of a midfield three in front of a back four with Woods at left-back or if we do play the 'wing-back' formation as one of the central two. A really pacy left-sided player with a bit of creativity and enough strength to put in a tackle so that they could play that wing-back - which Reid cannot because he totally lacks defensive application - would improve our options. Perhaps Woods could provide that.
 
If you are going to criticise Kilkenny on last night's performance then you'll have to also single out others too. Kilkenny was nipping into tackles throughout and probably tired into the latter third. Garner, by the same yardstick, failed to impress too but I suppose critical analysis is coloured by reputation and previous successes.
North End were outstanding and it took a strong and pumped up effort from the visitors to push them aside.
 
If you are going to criticise Kilkenny on last night's performance then you'll have to also single out others too. Kilkenny was nipping into tackles throughout and probably tired into the latter third. Garner, by the same yardstick, failed to impress too but I suppose critical analysis is coloured by reputation and previous successes.
North End were outstanding and it took a strong and pumped up effort from the visitors to push them aside.
Well said. I thought Killkenny did ok. Welsh put in a few great blocks and tackles as well.

I don't think I could criticise any of our players last night, great performance against the minted, cheating elite.
 
Back
Top