Skip to main content

Central midfield

Central midfield

Joined
May 5, 2009
Messages
12,038
Apart from Keane breaking up play I havnt seen anyone who is up to scratch.

Welsh
Wroe
Byrom
Mousinho

Just not good enough, just a bunch of very ordinary players, and Keane certainly isn't creative.

We need creativity, pace and someone who can carry the ball forwards!!

We need this area strengthening and quickly to keep up our promotion challenge.
 
Apart from Keane breaking up play I havnt seen anyone who is up to scratch.

Welsh
Wroe
Byrom
Mousinho

Just not good enough, just a bunch of very ordinary players, and Keane certainly isn't creative.

We need creativity, pace and someone who can carry the ball forwards!!

We need this area strengthening and quickly to keep up our promotion challenge.

This is the one for me and something I've thought for a long long time. Who was the last central midfielder who could actually run at defences and beat a man??

Holmes can do it when central but I mean a real genuine CM.
 
This is the one for me and something I've thought for a long long time. Who was the last central midfielder who could actually run at defences and beat a man??

Holmes can do it when central but I mean a real genuine CM.

Coutts probably fits that deacription. Though usually he was played out of position as a result of his ability to beat a man.
 
Apart from Keane breaking up play I havnt seen anyone who is up to scratch.

Welsh
Wroe
Byrom
Mousinho

Just not good enough, just a bunch of very ordinary players, and Keane certainly isn't creative.

We need creativity, pace and someone who can carry the ball forwards!!

We need this area strengthening and quickly to keep up our promotion challenge.

Croasdale seems to have that in his locker but is still young.
 
Apart from Keane breaking up play I havnt seen anyone who is up to scratch.

Welsh
Wroe
Byrom
Mousinho

Just not good enough, just a bunch of very ordinary players, and Keane certainly isn't creative.

We need creativity, pace and someone who can carry the ball forwards!!

We need this area strengthening and quickly to keep up our promotion challenge.

Wroe was disappointing last night. Had he played okay, would have been tempted to play him against Crewe instead of Byrom.
 
Agree with the above.......only player beating a man last night was Buchanan.

would go back to 4-2-3-1 for Saturday with players available

Rudd

Clarke Huntington Wright Laird

Welsh Keane

Holmes Beavon Buchanan

Davies​
 
This is the one for me and something I've thought for a long long time. Who was the last central midfielder who could actually run at defences and beat a man??

Holmes can do it when central but I mean a real genuine CM.

Do many teams have that kind of player? isnt it like the mythical "30 a season" striker that every team needs?
 
Swindon are a similar side to Crewe, Keane & Byrom absolute dominated their midfield so I see no reason why we would change after losing to Peterborough who will give most sides a tonking this year.

Away from home it might be worth giving Welsh a run out but our midfield has been effective in our last two home games.
 
Why can't we go to MOYSIE and get an up and coming player from utd. we did it with beckham, we had danny welbeck and matty james and david Jones.

the players are there and its what we need. Last night we were completely overrun - embarrassing
 
They come with a bigger price tag than we've got available I'm afraid.

Over the two games that I have seen any of the Oldham midfielders would walk into our team. I haven't done any research but doubt very much a large price tag was involved.
 
Over the two games that I have seen any of the Oldham midfielders would walk into our team. I haven't done any research but doubt very much a large price tag was involved.

IMO Schmeltz and Wesolowski for them were great last night, and that Schmeltz was even better in the first Oldham game (2-1), whether he's better than Humphrey or not I don't know, but still would be good enough for most teams in this league.
 
Why can't we go to MOYSIE and get an up and coming player from utd. we did it with beckham, we had danny welbeck and matty james and david Jones.

the players are there and its what we need. Last night we were completely overrun - embarrassing

Yet in the second half we bossed the game and should have at least reduced the arrears.

So far under Grayson we have become a solid effective unit with a first 11 clearly starting to take shape in a new system that is aimed at balancing our defensive strength with creating sufficient chances to get results.

Neil mellor made a point post match that players wanting to make a positive impression maybe failed to perform but had one of nicholson welsh wroe or garner been added to the first 11 then they may have fit in better and looked decent.

I think in terms of creativity the current system looks to Davies to spearhead our attack with support from two of Hume beavon garner or Holmes with the wingbacks getting forward to be direct and also to counter attack. Our 3 centre halves are their to defend and the two central midfielders are to sit in.

The shape and in particular cover from team mates looks good when we have our first 11 out and we have, at home, looked strong. A Jose Baxter type central midfielder is not what grayson appears to want sat in front if the back 3.

One problem with this system is that Humphrey and laird look good wingbacks but there is no obvious replacement for either.

Goal scoring central midfielders are wonderful but with 3 up front and two wingbacks I would not mind returning to welsh and Keane for solidity.
 
Two losses, a tough away and a relativerly unimportant cup match playing a weakened team doesn't mean we need to press the panic button.

This disappointing midefield has just racked up 5 successive wins and, that Oldham game aside, we have been generally good value for those wins. At present, the midfield is pretty well proven to give the side what is required. The issue is backup for injuries, callups and losses of form - at present the loss of Humphrey as wing-back looks difficult to deal with as it looks to require a change to the side but Welsh has shown for a season that he can perform well at this level and would be able to step in.
 
jesus wept, last night when given the chance to prove something he was terrible as was Nicholson, Brownhill seemed comfortable though during his brief stint.

So that's your mind made up on Croasdale after one half of senior football is it then?
 
So that's your mind made up on Croasdale after one half of senior football is it then?

having watched Croasdale coming through the youths whereas you have probably never seen him until this season, I was hoping for much better things from him last night, great chance but he was well short, looked lost and was rightly subbed.
 
I've never seen him play at all.

Based on your description it sounds like he has some ability so hopefully he'll get another chance. I don't think its fair to judge any young player too quickly.
 
We have been short of a creative midfielder ever since Coutts was sold.

However Westley didn't do creative so signed the "grafters" we have now along with some utter garbage like the moose who I still find astounding was actually made club captain.

I still think we need one, however we will need to get shut of some before we can sign anyone else I would imagine.

We could look at the loan market but signing young lads from the Premier League can be pot luck on if they are up to the right level.

All that said it is worth remembering prior to Saturday we had been unbeaten and going along quite nicely. So still no need to panic in my eyes.
 
Back
Top