Skip to main content

Central Midfield

Central Midfield

Yep, I agree.

I think people really underestimate the way Kilkenny dictates play in midfield though. Plus, he's also very good without the ball and here's why we didn't see that last night:

All central positions are based on partnerships. Huntington and Clarke are immense together, Davies and Beckford have clicked, albeit lacking in goals and Welsh and Kilkenny work very hard for each other.

It's often not as easy to just bring in the 'right' player, they have to fit the way the team plays. That midfield duo play in close contact with each other, working together to stifle the opposition's threat and in building play from midfield. If we were to sign an attacking midfielder and play him as you suggest then our entire dynamic would be hampered.

It's just like bringing in a 'young fast goalscorer' but then partnering him with Beckford, then be surprised why neither of them is scoring. Because they'll be in the same positions, they won't have anyone to hold up the ball or bring it in to play from deep. Then someone will find another area to criticise the team based solely on the unbalanced nature caused by tinkering in the first place.

Accurate and well balanced posts such as this one are considered heresy on here. The regulars will be out with the pitch forks and torches.
 
The problem with a concise and logic laden account is that is kills a thread dead in the water. A voice of reason out shines those with agendas and promotes new positive driven and constructive criticism.
 
Kilkenny - takes two seconds too long for every pass, Crewe away we were looking to go on and win the game and Grayson throws him on, he slows it all down and goes backwards and sideways. A useful player at home against teams sitting back and when we are trying to patiently break teams down but last night he was rubbish at this. Although he can have good games, I'm starting to have doubts about this guy.

Browne - can show real moments of class and control of the ball but he can't play alongside Kilkenny which hampers the whole midfield and leaves us way too open at the back. Of our whole midfield last night there was only Humphrey doing his defensive duty consistently. I thought we missed Welsh a lot last night. If Grayson wasn't so against playing him, I thought Keane would have been a great option.
 
Last edited:
He takes two seconds too long because he's insuring that we don't lose possession by making the wrong pass. Although, I entirely agree with what you're saying.

Welsh was missed last night as he often is.
 
Kilkenny is a vital cog in graysons style of play. So if you dont like Kilkenny you basically dont like graysons tactics. He wont be dropped this season. If hes fit he'll play. Or be rested if the game isnt as important. I can understand why people moan about him, because most defensive midfielders are easy targets. I very much doubt he could step up to championship level but at league one he is very good at what he does.

Neither Browne or Brownhill is ready to step up to have a real impact on central midfield. Brownhill seems out of sorts and perhaps would suit a five man midfield better with less responsibility to defend. While Browne looks more versatile, last night he got into some great positions 35 yards from goal but never chose the right ball or simply lacked confidence. They both need more time. And need to be used sparingly.
 
For the last 2 matches Browne has played well in the first half and fades away in the second.
 
Kilkenny is a vital cog in graysons style of play. So if you dont like Kilkenny you basically dont like graysons tactics. He wont be dropped this season. If hes fit he'll play. Or be rested if the game isnt as important. I can understand why people moan about him, because most defensive midfielders are easy targets. I very much doubt he could step up to championship level but at league one he is very good at what he does.

Neither Browne or Brownhill is ready to step up to have a real impact on central midfield. Brownhill seems out of sorts and perhaps would suit a five man midfield better with less responsibility to defend. While Browne looks more versatile, last night he got into some great positions 35 yards from goal but never chose the right ball or simply lacked confidence. They both need more time. And need to be used sparingly.

Grayson's tactics, although very cautious, are very effective and got us into the playoffs last year, and just off the automatics this. I don't doubt Grayson's tactics whatsoever, they are proven to bring results and therefore success should soon follow. Don't have a problem with those.

If fully fit, our starting midfield should be Humphrey Kilkenny Welsh Gallagher, but we have no replacement for Welsh when he is missing. That is the priority for me in this Transfer Window, as well as bringing back Robinson.
 
we have no replacement for Welsh when he is missing

True - but the nearest we have got in terms of authority and ball-winning ability is King, yet he wasn't used last night or at least not in that role. Is Welsh going to be available on Saturday - either way we need another quality, experienced central midfielder with drive and presence. That is one thing that was made absolutely evident last night.
 
How many goals this season have been scored by a central midfield player?
Also how many goals have been scored from direct free kicks? I have a faint memory of Byrom scoring one last season. Have we scored any this season? We really need a Alexander, Eyres, Lewis etc type of free kick taker.
 
How many goals this season have been scored by a central midfield player?

Browne - 3
Brownhill - 1
King (apparently a CM, amongst other things) - 1
Kilkenny - 1

If you include Gallagher as a CM, as he does sometimes play in an advanced central position, he has got, but he is usually on the left so it's tricky.
 
Also how many goals have been scored from direct free kicks? I have a faint memory of Byrom scoring one last season. Have we scored any this season? We really need a Alexander, Eyres, Lewis etc type of free kick taker.

This is it. Walsall had 3 free kicks last night, scored with one, hit the post with one and brought a save out of Stuckmann with the other.
 
Its meant to be Gallagher.
I think I am right in saying that Gallagher hasnt scored any direct free kicks from outside the box this season. And he scored only two last year (one against Shrewsbury and one against Rotherham). Over the last 18 months that is a very poor return for our main free kick taker.
 
I think I am right in saying that Gallagher hasnt scored any direct free kicks from outside the box this season. And he scored only two last year (one against Shrewsbury and one against Rotherham). Over the last 18 months that is a very poor return for our main free kick taker.

Direct free-kicks result in goals really quite rarely. I don't have any stats but I wouldn't have thought 2 last season was particularly poor, unless anyone can prove otherwise?
 
Back
Top