Central Midfield
- Joined
- Jun 8, 2004
- Messages
- 6,810
Got to agree that Welsh and Buchs much better than Browne/Laird imho. Browne potters around doing not much and Laird still not over injury. Think its too late for this tie, but hopefully SG will have learned something...something he should have learned from the Rotherham first leg too. Also agree that subs were poor, Reid looks dire tbh. 🙁 Ah well, on to the Bescot ..!
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2004
- Messages
- 13,345
Got to agree that Welsh and Buchs much better than Browne/Laird imho. Browne potters around doing not much and Laird still not over injury. Think its too late for this tie, but hopefully SG will have learned something...something he should have learned from the Rotherham first leg too. Also agree that subs were poor, Reid looks dire tbh. 🙁 Ah well, on to the Bescot ..!
Why does Laird not get closer to his winger. He allows them far too much space and therefore never intercepts passes to the winger. Also he gets caught upfield and then ambles back instead of busting a gut to get back.
- Joined
- Oct 17, 2004
- Messages
- 882
Kilkenny is great when we're on top and in possession. However, he might as well not be there when they've got the ball, and a team like Walsall are very good at keeping possession, therefore he was none existent tonight.
Exactly, players all have their strengths and weaknesses especially as you move down the leagues; but there is a minimum acceptable level, Kilkenny's ability to tackle is woefully short of the minimum I would expect of a League 1 level central midfield player. When we haven't got the ball he tends to run alongside the guy with the ball in a way you would normally only see in an under 8's game, when he isn't doing that he's pointing at the free opposition players expecting the rest of the team to pick them up rather than closing them down himself. Add to this the fact that he rarely poses a threat in the opposition box and he is more or less a passenger for the majority of the game when we don't have the ball. What's worse I think Grayson knows this. Hence he tends to play 3 central midfielders when Kilkenny is in the team, 1 to provide defensive cover, 1 who can push on and pose a threat in the opposition box and Kilkenny to knock the ball around. Unfortunately whilst this may suit Kilkenny it doesn't tend to get the best out of the rest of the team, especially the strikers as we normally only play 1 up front when he's in the team. Tonight he did play him in a standard 442, which unfortunately exposed his weaknesses big time.
Why does Laird not get closer to his winger. He allows them far too much space and therefore never intercepts passes to the winger. Also he gets caught upfield and then ambles back instead of busting a gut to get back.
Think everyone can see buchs is the main man at left back laird has been giving his chance
- Joined
- Dec 12, 2014
- Messages
- 683
Exactly, players all have their strengths and weaknesses especially as you move down the leagues; but there is a minimum acceptable level, Kilkenny's ability to tackle is woefully short of the minimum I would expect of a League 1 level central midfield player. When we haven't got the ball he tends to run alongside the guy with the ball in a way you would normally only see in an under 8's game, when he isn't doing that he's pointing at the free opposition players expecting the rest of the team to pick them up rather than closing them down himself. Add to this the fact that he rarely poses a threat in the opposition box and he is more or less a passenger for the majority of the game when we don't have the ball. What's worse I think Grayson knows this. Hence he tends to play 3 central midfielders when Kilkenny is in the team, 1 to provide defensive cover, 1 who can push on and pose a threat in the opposition box and Kilkenny to knock the ball around. Unfortunately whilst this may suit Kilkenny it doesn't tend to get the best out of the rest of the team, especially the strikers as we normally only play 1 up front when he's in the team. Tonight he did play him in a standard 442, which unfortunately exposed his weaknesses big time.
Agree totally. With Garner fit we can get away with the 1 up top system but with us needing 2 strikers to play, it can expose our midfield weakness. We've done well with this system recently but I think John Welsh was missed tonight. Not a tackle between Browne and Kilkenny, just a lot of pointing.
Wiseman is a disaster defensively, he has cost us god knows how many goals this season in not that many appearances.
But has created some, been part of a defence that has been one of the most solid in the league and has scored 2 goals one against MK Dons..........remember?
- Joined
- Dec 12, 2014
- Messages
- 683
But has created some, been part of a defence that has been one of the most solid in the league and has scored 2 goals one against MK Dons..........remember?
Woods has one game and all of a sudden he is the messiah and Wiseman the anti-christ! He can be error prone but contributes to many of our attacks and has been part of our strong defensive displays this season as you point out. Just had a poor game tonight.
Woods has one game and all of a sudden he is the messiah and Wiseman the anti-christ! He can be error prone but contributes to many of our attacks and has been part of our strong defensive displays this season as you point out. Just had a poor game tonight.
My point exactly, personal witch hunts are happening tonight.
Thracia
Club Owner, or wingback, depending on your view
- Joined
- Aug 1, 2011
- Messages
- 30,692
Is that someone fishing over there?
- Joined
- Jul 23, 2010
- Messages
- 850
I can't say I agree with a single word of this thread.
The defense has been excellent this season. Three days ago we were praising the depth of our defensive qualities. Huntington, and more specifically, Clarke, were excellent tonight. The fullbacks made some poor decisions tonight, especially late on. However, I won't be drawn in to believing they're poor because of one bad performance in 10.
We missed Welsh, as we did on Saturday, but Kilkenny has been back to form recently and their partnership has been key to our success in our latest purple patch. Browne had a good first half, but faded later on. No qualms.
Kevin Davies, who has been excellent as of late, just wasn't getting the run of the green tonight. Grayson had every right to hook him but unfortunately when combined with Beckford's forced substitution we became stagnant and toothless upfront.
I'm happy with the squad, I'm happy with the spirit but I'm unhappy with our dismal second half display. Let's hope that we bounce back immediately, as we've done so often under Grayson.
The defense has been excellent this season. Three days ago we were praising the depth of our defensive qualities. Huntington, and more specifically, Clarke, were excellent tonight. The fullbacks made some poor decisions tonight, especially late on. However, I won't be drawn in to believing they're poor because of one bad performance in 10.
We missed Welsh, as we did on Saturday, but Kilkenny has been back to form recently and their partnership has been key to our success in our latest purple patch. Browne had a good first half, but faded later on. No qualms.
Kevin Davies, who has been excellent as of late, just wasn't getting the run of the green tonight. Grayson had every right to hook him but unfortunately when combined with Beckford's forced substitution we became stagnant and toothless upfront.
I'm happy with the squad, I'm happy with the spirit but I'm unhappy with our dismal second half display. Let's hope that we bounce back immediately, as we've done so often under Grayson.
I can't say I agree with a single word of this thread.
The defense has been excellent this season. Three days ago we were praising the depth of our defensive qualities. Huntington, and more specifically, Clarke, were excellent tonight. The fullbacks made some poor decisions tonight, especially late on. However, I won't be drawn in to believing they're poor because of one bad performance in 10.
We missed Welsh, as we did on Saturday, but Kilkenny has been back to form recently and their partnership has been key to our success in our latest purple patch. Browne had a good first half, but faded later on. No qualms.
Kevin Davies, who has been excellent as of late, just wasn't getting the run of the green tonight. Grayson had every right to hook him but unfortunately when combined with Beckford's forced substitution we became stagnant and toothless upfront.
I'm happy with the squad, I'm happy with the spirit but I'm unhappy with our dismal second half display. Let's hope that we bounce back immediately, as we've done so often under Grayson.
Wow, you're brave. Using logic and informed reason on here. Mental.
I can't say I agree with a single word of this thread.
The defense has been excellent this season. Three days ago we were praising the depth of our defensive qualities. Huntington, and more specifically, Clarke, were excellent tonight. The fullbacks made some poor decisions tonight, especially late on. However, I won't be drawn in to believing they're poor because of one bad performance in 10.
We missed Welsh, as we did on Saturday, but Kilkenny has been back to form recently and their partnership has been key to our success in our latest purple patch. Browne had a good first half, but faded later on. No qualms.
Kevin Davies, who has been excellent as of late, just wasn't getting the run of the green tonight. Grayson had every right to hook him but unfortunately when combined with Beckford's forced substitution we became stagnant and toothless upfront.
I'm happy with the squad, I'm happy with the spirit but I'm unhappy with our dismal second half display. Let's hope that we bounce back immediately, as we've done so often under Grayson.
Excellent post.
- Joined
- Jul 31, 2011
- Messages
- 29
I can't say I agree with a single word of this thread.
The defense has been excellent this season. Three days ago we were praising the depth of our defensive qualities. Huntington, and more specifically, Clarke, were excellent tonight. The fullbacks made some poor decisions tonight, especially late on. However, I won't be drawn in to believing they're poor because of one bad performance in 10.
We missed Welsh, as we did on Saturday, but Kilkenny has been back to form recently and their partnership has been key to our success in our latest purple patch. Browne had a good first half, but faded later on. No qualms.
Kevin Davies, who has been excellent as of late, just wasn't getting the run of the green tonight. Grayson had every right to hook him but unfortunately when combined with Beckford's forced substitution we became stagnant and toothless upfront.
I'm happy with the squad, I'm happy with the spirit but I'm unhappy with our dismal second half display. Let's hope that we bounce back immediately, as we've done so often under Grayson.
You don't agree with a single word of what's said on this thread but if you read back I didn't have a go at anyone apart from our weak midfield which you agreed with as you said we missed welsh. I said I prefered Buchanan over laird (but he's still a good player) but the rest I'm happy with apart from centre midfield, which I'd what the thread is about. Yes we missed Welsh but still think we are one strong midfielder away from a league winning team. We have to many midfielders that are good with the ball but poor without it. We need a strong midfielder that can win the vulval and drive forward with it, not sideways. Browne did it for 20 minutes in the first half and he will only improve with age so will Brownhill.
Our strikers are working well together especially Davies who creates so much if not directly just by occupying defenders and I feel the goals might come with Beckford.
- Joined
- Jul 23, 2010
- Messages
- 850
Yep, I agree.
I think people really underestimate the way Kilkenny dictates play in midfield though. Plus, he's also very good without the ball and here's why we didn't see that last night:
All central positions are based on partnerships. Huntington and Clarke are immense together, Davies and Beckford have clicked, albeit lacking in goals and Welsh and Kilkenny work very hard for each other.
It's often not as easy to just bring in the 'right' player, they have to fit the way the team plays. That midfield duo play in close contact with each other, working together to stifle the opposition's threat and in building play from midfield. If we were to sign an attacking midfielder and play him as you suggest then our entire dynamic would be hampered.
It's just like bringing in a 'young fast goalscorer' but then partnering him with Beckford, then be surprised why neither of them is scoring. Because they'll be in the same positions, they won't have anyone to hold up the ball or bring it in to play from deep. Then someone will find another area to criticise the team based solely on the unbalanced nature caused by tinkering in the first place.
I think people really underestimate the way Kilkenny dictates play in midfield though. Plus, he's also very good without the ball and here's why we didn't see that last night:
All central positions are based on partnerships. Huntington and Clarke are immense together, Davies and Beckford have clicked, albeit lacking in goals and Welsh and Kilkenny work very hard for each other.
It's often not as easy to just bring in the 'right' player, they have to fit the way the team plays. That midfield duo play in close contact with each other, working together to stifle the opposition's threat and in building play from midfield. If we were to sign an attacking midfielder and play him as you suggest then our entire dynamic would be hampered.
It's just like bringing in a 'young fast goalscorer' but then partnering him with Beckford, then be surprised why neither of them is scoring. Because they'll be in the same positions, they won't have anyone to hold up the ball or bring it in to play from deep. Then someone will find another area to criticise the team based solely on the unbalanced nature caused by tinkering in the first place.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Oct 18, 2004
- Messages
- 2,066
Yep, I agree.
I think people really underestimate the way Kilkenny dictates play in midfield though. Plus, he's also very good without the ball and here's why we didn't see that last night:
All central positions are based on partnerships. Huntington and Clarke are immense together, Davies and Beckford have clicked, albeit lacking in goals and Welsh and Kilkenny work very hard for each other.
It's often not as easy to just bring in the 'right' player, they have to fit the way the team plays. That midfield duo play in close contact with each other, working together to stifle the opposition's threat and in building play from midfield. If we were to sign an attacking midfielder and play him as you suggest then our entire dynamic would be hampered.
It's just like bringing in a 'young fast goalscorer' but then partnering him with Beckford, then be surprised why neither of them is scoring. Because they'll be in the same positions, they won't have anyone to hold up the ball or bring it in to play from deep. Then someone will find another area to criticise the team based solely on the unbalanced nature caused by tinkering in the first place.
Careful , that's 2 accurate sensible posts in one thread !