Skip to main content

CJ Hamilton

CJ Hamilton

Ando60

Hat Trick Hero
Joined
Aug 23, 2004
Messages
60,243
Location
Euxton
One or two people on the forum have suggested that we should possibly sign CJ Hamilton from Mansfield ..... I am watching the Mansfield v Newport play off semi and I have to say that he is definitely not good enough for the championship.

He might be having an off night , but his first touch is very poor and he looks pedestrian ....

Big difference between League 2 and the Championship.....
 
terrible player, not even good at that level...he has one attribute....hes fast in a straight line but don't expect him to bring the ball with him
 
Same here, some of the missed chances just highlight the different skills between the leagues. Wouldn't be anyware near good enough for us.
 
You can’t judge a player from viewing one game.

He’s scored 14 goals from wide areas this season, and has electric pace.

I think we need a more technical option out wide though.
 
One swallow doth not a season maketh.

Though a single swallow doth my summer holidays maketh back in 1988.

I suspect Hamilton could be a cut-price replacement for Robinson, should the latter leave. He is raw but filled with pace, has a good left peg on him and isn't afraid to shoot across goal on his weaker right.

Raw, with potential, athletic but inconsistent: cogito ergo about the best we can hope for. His crossing isn't bad and he tends to look up before sending it over which is always a bonus these days.

He's a long way behind Robinson in his current incarnation, as are/were most of our incomings over the years. Signing the real deal is way beyond us - something we thrive off with our developed players cherry-picked by the big boys.

I suppose we'll wait and see, but it would not be a huge surprise to go for Hamilton, nor disappointing. Of course, I'd rather keep Robinson and have CJ as a sub or backup. But that's probably a pipe dream unless we go all guns blazing for once.

The positive is that we are spreading our net far and wide and looking for youngsters with talent: with the glorious, unheralded Woods Manifesto reaching its glorious zenith.
 
Probably would make an ok replacement for Barky. If Barky stays there is no reason to sign him, really lacking in technical ability (albeit ive only watched 4 Mansfield games this season.)

CJ Hamilton is not the winger who can help us break teams down at home. Rather give Ginelly a chance who looked more skillful in a worse team in a better division.

In fairness to him, Mansfield were terrible against Newport, and without an inspired goalkeeping performance could have lost by 5. So potentially the occassion got to him
 
Back
Top