Clive Smith
No not ready
Not ready yet. But given time and a couple of loan moves he could become a very decent right back
- Joined
- Jan 17, 2010
- Messages
- 315
He looks as though he is trying to avoid making mistakes rather than trying to do anything clever,which shows quite a lot of maturity in my opinion.
Will he make it? Depends on what else he has in his locker that he hasn't shown us yet & how quickly the coaching staff can bring it out of him.
Time to assess him properly will be in another 1-2 years I suspect.
Will he make it? Depends on what else he has in his locker that he hasn't shown us yet & how quickly the coaching staff can bring it out of him.
Time to assess him properly will be in another 1-2 years I suspect.
How old is he? If he's 18 I understand he might need a bit of time. If he's 20 then I hope he's close to ready.
Isn't he a second year scholar? I don't think he's won a pro contract yet, so to be training with the first team at this stage of his career is promising. I can't see him being ready for Championship football, but hopefully a very good prospect.
Just signed for Burnley on a two year deal.
Just signed for Burnley on a two year deal.
Ha ha... They will have a team of right backs before the season starts !!
How old is he? If he's 18 I understand he might need a bit of time. If he's 20 then I hope he's close to ready.
I don't think age has anything to do with it. If he's ready, he's ready. If he's not, he's not.
Very exciting prospect from what I have seen. Grayson and Thompson rate him highly....but not ready for the Championship - yet.
- Joined
- Feb 12, 2005
- Messages
- 6,007
I don't think age has anything to do with it. If he's ready, he's ready. If he's not, he's not.
My point is not that he should be held back if he's 18 and ready. It's that if he's 20 and not played 1st team footie is he realistically going to make it.
- Joined
- Oct 25, 2004
- Messages
- 4,922
Please can we just sign a quality right back. Asap
Very exciting prospect from what I have seen. Grayson and Thompson rate him highly....but not ready for the Championship - yet.
Just curious - are your final words from the management, or your own words?
My point is not that he should be held back if he's 18 and ready. It's that if he's 20 and not played 1st team footie is he realistically going to make it.
He'll be 18 in December.
Just curious - are your final words from the management, or your own words?
They are my own view based on the lad being comfortable in pre season but with no football league experience at any level.
My point is not that he should be held back if he's 18 and ready. It's that if he's 20 and not played 1st team footie is he realistically going to make it.
I see. Well it looks like he's not even yet 18, so lots of time.
In 1983 Norman Whiteside scored in an FA Cup final. He was 18.
Fill your boots, Clive!
Fill your boots, Clive!