Skip to main content

Complete over reactions from last night

Complete over reactions from last night

Joined
Jun 18, 2004
Messages
19,172
First of all, let me state that we were dreadful last night. But last night was always going to be a tough game. Doncaster are a side who are in a play off position, and are also in good form, I believe 6th best in the league in the last 6 games.

There are a lot of factors as to why we were poor. Players possibly tired from recent run of games, bobbly pitch, a number of players having an off day, not changing our formation earlier etc.

But some peoples reactions are completely over the top. I genuinely don't believe a manager, at home, instructs his players to allow the opposition to have all the possession in the world, and to sit back and await them to score. Keep things tight yes, but you can do that by getting hold of the ball, and making the opposition work and chase after the ball. Unfortunately we didn't do this at all.

So what Grayson did, was he took a forward player off (who has a slight injury), and brought on Kilkenny, hoping the extra man in midfield would get us on the ball more. It will have been no good whatsoever in bringing on another attacking option, and trying to attack as we just couldn't get hold of the ball. Doncaster had all the momentum as they were chasing the game.

What then happened is Doncaster got 2 quick goals, and a complete change of momentum happened. Doncaster decided to hold onto the lead, we had to chase the game. So we had to take a risk and brought another forward on. And the risk worked. But it would have been wrong to make an attacking change a lot earlier in the half, as we just didn't have any possession of the ball to attack. We would have left ourselves more open.

As I said, last night was awful. There was a number of factors. But we got a point, and moved up into the automatic position. It's not a bad thing that after a poor performance against a top 6 side that you can still scrape a point. Be encouraged that the players are prepared to try until the end. To me, last night was a sign that promotion really is possible for us. The odd 'winning draw' can be the difference between 2nd and 3rd, and last night that was clearly evident.

Roll on Saturday!
 
This is pretty much how I saw things as well Norks.

The only difference being I would have liked to see KD on earlier as we needed to make the ball stick up top, but as I said, agree with the rest.
 
I was delighted with a point last night considering the terrible performance. Yes I know we were winning but we were completely out of the game for the 2nd half, so to get a point at the death was superb.

Factoring in the other results it turned out to be a good night for us.

A win on Saturday would put us in pole position for 2nd place so fingers crossed!
 
First of all, let me state that we were dreadful last night. But last night was always going to be a tough game. Doncaster are a side who are in a play off position, and are also in good form, I believe 6th best in the league in the last 6 games.

There are a lot of factors as to why we were poor. Players possibly tired from recent run of games, bobbly pitch, a number of players having an off day, not changing our formation earlier etc.

But some peoples reactions are completely over the top. I genuinely don't believe a manager, at home, instructs his players to allow the opposition to have all the possession in the world, and to sit back and await them to score. Keep things tight yes, but you can do that by getting hold of the ball, and making the opposition work and chase after the ball. Unfortunately we didn't do this at all.

So what Grayson did, was he took a forward player off (who has a slight injury), and brought on Kilkenny, hoping the extra man in midfield would get us on the ball more. It will have been no good whatsoever in bringing on another attacking option, and trying to attack as we just couldn't get hold of the ball. Doncaster had all the momentum as they were chasing the game.

What then happened is Doncaster got 2 quick goals, and a complete change of momentum happened. Doncaster decided to hold onto the lead, we had to chase the game. So we had to take a risk and brought another forward on. And the risk worked. But it would have been wrong to make an attacking change a lot earlier in the half, as we just didn't have any possession of the ball to attack. We would have left ourselves more open.

As I said, last night was awful. There was a number of factors. But we got a point, and moved up into the automatic position. It's not a bad thing that after a poor performance against a top 6 side that you can still scrape a point. Be encouraged that the players are prepared to try until the end. To me, last nMight was a sign that promotion really is possible for us. The odd 'winning draw' can be the difference between 2nd and 3rd, and last night that was clearly evident.

Roll on Saturday!

Can't argue with any of that....however I think most fair minded people will agree that we haven't been too great at home in the majority of games. It's far from doom and gloom but it's apparent that there is a lot of room for improvement even though we are second!
 
First of all, let me state that we were dreadful last night. But last night was always going to be a tough game. Doncaster are a side who are in a play off position, and are also in good form, I believe 6th best in the league in the last 6 games.

There are a lot of factors as to why we were poor. Players possibly tired from recent run of games, bobbly pitch, a number of players having an off day, not changing our formation earlier etc.

But some peoples reactions are completely over the top. I genuinely don't believe a manager, at home, instructs his players to allow the opposition to have all the possession in the world, and to sit back and await them to score. Keep things tight yes, but you can do that by getting hold of the ball, and making the opposition work and chase after the ball. Unfortunately we didn't do this at all.

So what Grayson did, was he took a forward player off (who has a slight injury), and brought on Kilkenny, hoping the extra man in midfield would get us on the ball more. It will have been no good whatsoever in bringing on another attacking option, and trying to attack as we just couldn't get hold of the ball. Doncaster had all the momentum as they were chasing the game.

What then happened is Doncaster got 2 quick goals, and a complete change of momentum happened. Doncaster decided to hold onto the lead, we had to chase the game. So we had to take a risk and brought another forward on. And the risk worked. But it would have been wrong to make an attacking change a lot earlier in the half, as we just didn't have any possession of the ball to attack. We would have left ourselves more open.

As I said, last night was awful. There was a number of factors. But we got a point, and moved up into the automatic position. It's not a bad thing that after a poor performance against a top 6 side that you can still scrape a point. Be encouraged that the players are prepared to try until the end. To me, last night was a sign that promotion really is possible for us. The odd 'winning draw' can be the difference between 2nd and 3rd, and last night that was clearly evident.

Roll on Saturday!

agree with you, but would like to see Beckford & garner start up front on Saturday though?
 
We kept hoofing the ball up to an isolated Garner so how would having an extra striker not have benefited us? The approach taken was wrong and proved that way as we went from a winning position to scraping a draw.

If the players were tired then why not utilise the squad?

Grayson has let the opposition come at us in more games than last night though. It's the home games and dropping of points by being negative at home that will cost us if we don't get automatic. We have the players to achieve this.
 
This is pretty much how I saw things as well Norks.

The only difference being I would have liked to see KD on earlier as we needed to make the ball stick up top, but as I said, agree with the rest.

Fair point. He could have come on for Garner. Garner had a horrible night, he was getting punished time and time again for nothing. Yet anything on him wasn't given our way. And then when he got booked, he had to curb his physical instincts as the referee would have probably sent him off. Doncaster players were making a meal of any contact from him.
 
Not a good performance was it!

Does anyone think Donny merited any praise. I for one thought it was the first time for ages that we have been "bullied" and they showed great determination, in fact they earned the right to play more than us.

These performances happen now and again but I dont think it was down to us being bad as it was they got tactics spot on.

I don't know who they have got left to play, but I hope its everyone at the top. They would certainly take points. Well played Donny.
 
We kept hoofing the ball up to an isolated Garner so how would having an extra striker not have benefited us? The approach taken was wrong and proved that way as we went from a winning position to scraping a draw.

If the players were tired then why not utilise the squad?

Grayson has let the opposition come at us in more games than last night though. It's the home games and dropping of points by being negative at home that will cost us if we don't get automatic. We have the players to achieve this.
This is exactly how I see it. Time after time opposition's midfield outplays ours and we respond by dropping into 9 man defence and hoof ball hoping it finds Garner. ( usually it doesn't and the cycle resumes )
K
 
I'm not sure I have seen any over reactions from last night. I have seen people say we were rubbish (which we were as has the op) but what over reaction?
 
We kept hoofing the ball up to an isolated Garner so how would having an extra striker not have benefited us? The approach taken was wrong and proved that way as we went from a winning position to scraping a draw.

If the players were tired then why not utilise the squad?

Grayson has let the opposition come at us in more games than last night though. It's the home games and dropping of points by being negative at home that will cost us if we don't get automatic. We have the players to achieve this.

In all fairness, we just hoofed the ball anywhere at times. We couldn't get hold of the ball so panicked. In hindsight, we possibly should have taken Garner off and brought on Davies. A 2nd striker was no good when we didn't have the ball to give to the striker.

We didn't deserve to be in a winning position in the 1st place. We had a bad day, a bad day that we ended up getting a point.

We have the 3rd best home record in the league. Not bad I don't think.

It's hard to make many changes from a side that won 4-0 at the weekend. In hindsight perhaps he should have made a few changes. Perhaps we will do this Saturday.
 
Fair point. He could have come on for Garner. Garner had a horrible night, he was getting punished time and time again for nothing. Yet anything on him wasn't given our way. And then when he got booked, he had to curb his physical instincts as the referee would have probably sent him off. Doncaster players were making a meal of any contact from him.

It wasn't his best evening was it! I think with Garner though he cries wolf a lot, so when something actually happens to him it isn't given!

But back to the game, I personally would have had Robinson off, push Gally to the left and have KD and Garner up top after about 15 mins of the second half. Garner on his own wasn't enough of an outlet for us and I think with those two up top, KD could do the dirty work and leave Garner to feed off him.
 
First of all, let me state that we were dreadful last night. But last night was always going to be a tough game. Doncaster are a side who are in a play off position, and are also in good form, I believe 6th best in the league in the last 6 games.

There are a lot of factors as to why we were poor. Players possibly tired from recent run of games, bobbly pitch, a number of players having an off day, not changing our formation earlier etc.

But some peoples reactions are completely over the top. I genuinely don't believe a manager, at home, instructs his players to allow the opposition to have all the possession in the world, and to sit back and await them to score. Keep things tight yes, but you can do that by getting hold of the ball, and making the opposition work and chase after the ball. Unfortunately we didn't do this at all.

So what Grayson did, was he took a forward player off (who has a slight injury), and brought on Kilkenny, hoping the extra man in midfield would get us on the ball more. It will have been no good whatsoever in bringing on another attacking option, and trying to attack as we just couldn't get hold of the ball. Doncaster had all the momentum as they were chasing the game.

What then happened is Doncaster got 2 quick goals, and a complete change of momentum happened. Doncaster decided to hold onto the lead, we had to chase the game. So we had to take a risk and brought another forward on. And the risk worked. But it would have been wrong to make an attacking change a lot earlier in the half, as we just didn't have any possession of the ball to attack. We would have left ourselves more open.

As I said, last night was awful. There was a number of factors. But we got a point, and moved up into the automatic position. It's not a bad thing that after a poor performance against a top 6 side that you can still scrape a point. Be encouraged that the players are prepared to try until the end. To me, last night was a sign that promotion really is possible for us. The odd 'winning draw' can be the difference between 2nd and 3rd, and last night that was clearly evident.

Roll on Saturday!

Good post, and I agree that getting a point like that can make all the difference.... BUT....(you knew it was coming).......

Regards the bit highlighted, the team have done this in most home games I have watched for the last year or so. This is not a one off. Last night Donny were good enough to capitalise on our sitting back. If it was a one off, or the odd occassion I would agree with you, but its not....... so I won't 😉
 
I'm not sure I have seen any over reactions from last night. I have seen people say we were rubbish (which we were as has the op) but what over reaction?

I have seen a few in my opinion. I completely agree that we were rubbish, but some people's reactions I felt was over the top. Half full/half empty views I guess. I personally was delighted to scrape a point after being so poor. And I think the players will be boosted as well, especially after MK Dons and Swindon results. We got away with it last night, and I hope that's our bad performance out of the system for the rest of the season.
 
In all fairness, we just hoofed the ball anywhere at times. We couldn't get hold of the ball so panicked. In hindsight, we possibly should have taken Garner off and brought on Davies. A 2nd striker was no good when we didn't have the ball to give to the striker.

We didn't deserve to be in a winning position in the 1st place. We had a bad day, a bad day that we ended up getting a point.

We have the 3rd best home record in the league. Not bad I don't think.

It's hard to make many changes from a side that won 4-0 at the weekend. In hindsight perhaps he should have made a few changes. Perhaps we will do this Saturday.

So we hoofed the ball yet didn't have the ball???

It is easier if you have 2 outlets up top rather than 1 and it means their defence is split...

We put the ball in the net, they hadn't so we were deserving of the lead. They had more possession but hardly threatened our goal.

Yes in hindsight we should have made some changes.

Yes but if Grayson wasn't so negative we may have the best.
 
Good post, and I agree that getting a point like that can make all the difference.... BUT....(you knew it was coming).......

Regards the bit highlighted, the team have done this in most home games I have watched for the last year or so. This is not a one off. Last night Donny were good enough to capitalise on our sitting back. If it was a one off, or the odd occassion I would agree with you, but its not....... so I won't 😉

It does happen a lot. But I honestly don't believe the manager tells the players to do it. One thing which we have lacked throughout Grayson's period in charge, is a physical presence in the middle of the park. And also someone who is vocal on the pitch. Players can influence games by their performances, but I also feel someone who is vocal on the field can be an influence as well. We badly lack this.
 
So we hoofed the ball yet didn't have the ball???

It is easier if you have 2 outlets up top rather than 1 and it means their defence is split...

We put the ball in the net, they hadn't so we were deserving of the lead. They had more possession but hardly threatened our goal.

Yes in hindsight we should have made some changes.

Yes but if Grayson wasn't so negative we may have the best.

Having the ball for a second and hoofing it anywhere to me is not having control of the ball.

I'm quite happily seeing someone being 'negative' and being 2nd in the league. I don't care how we get promoted out of the league, I just want promotion.

But last night I don't think we were negative, we were just poor.
 
First of all, let me state that we were dreadful last night. But last night was always going to be a tough game. Doncaster are a side who are in a play off position, and are also in good form, I believe 6th best in the league in the last 6 games.

There are a lot of factors as to why we were poor. Players possibly tired from recent run of games, bobbly pitch, a number of players having an off day, not changing our formation earlier etc.

But some peoples reactions are completely over the top. I genuinely don't believe a manager, at home, instructs his players to allow the opposition to have all the possession in the world, and to sit back and await them to score. Keep things tight yes, but you can do that by getting hold of the ball, and making the opposition work and chase after the ball. Unfortunately we didn't do this at all.

So what Grayson did, was he took a forward player off (who has a slight injury), and brought on Kilkenny, hoping the extra man in midfield would get us on the ball more. It will have been no good whatsoever in bringing on another attacking option, and trying to attack as we just couldn't get hold of the ball. Doncaster had all the momentum as they were chasing the game.

What then happened is Doncaster got 2 quick goals, and a complete change of momentum happened. Doncaster decided to hold onto the lead, we had to chase the game. So we had to take a risk and brought another forward on. And the risk worked. But it would have been wrong to make an attacking change a lot earlier in the half, as we just didn't have any possession of the ball to attack. We would have left ourselves more open.

As I said, last night was awful. There was a number of factors. But we got a point, and moved up into the automatic position. It's not a bad thing that after a poor performance against a top 6 side that you can still scrape a point. Be encouraged that the players are prepared to try until the end. To me, last night was a sign that promotion really is possible for us. The odd 'winning draw' can be the difference between 2nd and 3rd, and last night that was clearly evident.

Roll on Saturday!

Great post. Well done
 
First of all, let me state that we were dreadful last night. But last night was always going to be a tough game. Doncaster are a side who are in a play off position, and are also in good form, I believe 6th best in the league in the last 6 games.

There are a lot of factors as to why we were poor. Players possibly tired from recent run of games, bobbly pitch, a number of players having an off day, not changing our formation earlier etc.

But some peoples reactions are completely over the top. I genuinely don't believe a manager, at home, instructs his players to allow the opposition to have all the possession in the world, and to sit back and await them to score. Keep things tight yes, but you can do that by getting hold of the ball, and making the opposition work and chase after the ball. Unfortunately we didn't do this at all.

So what Grayson did, was he took a forward player off (who has a slight injury), and brought on Kilkenny, hoping the extra man in midfield would get us on the ball more. It will have been no good whatsoever in bringing on another attacking option, and trying to attack as we just couldn't get hold of the ball. Doncaster had all the momentum as they were chasing the game.

Agree with this.

I think Grayson had a dilemma with so many players playing badly of who to bring off without making things worse.

At the end of the season our 90-odd minute equaliser and Chesterfield's 90-odd minute equaliser could be the difference between playoff woe and automatic promotion.
 
Back
Top