I may be wrong but I seem to remember that each of those FA Cup games went to a replay
The results were:
63-64
Bolton 2 PNE 2 (Dawson 2)
PNE 2 (Dawson, Lawton) Bolton 1
64-65
PNE 1 (Dawson) Bolton 2
65-66
Bolton 1 PNE 1 (Dawson)
PNE 3 (Dawson, Godfrey 2 pens) Bolton 2
The last of those games was bizarre. We took the lead but they first equalised and then went in front halfway though the second half through their centre forward Wyn Davies (a player I always disliked who had scored their last minute winner the previous season) and frankly they were heading through to the next round. But then just as a harmless lobbed through ball was dropping into the hands of their keeper Davies presumably still hyped up from scoring ran onto it and caught it like a basketball player to give away a penalty - one of the most perverse though in this instance welcome incidents I have ever seen on a football field. Up stepped Brian Godfrey to score and with a new lease of life we pressed them and before long Ernie Hannigan was chopped down to give us another penalty from which Godfrey duly delivered again.