Skip to main content

Coventry Highlights

Coventry Highlights

Joined
Jan 27, 2012
Messages
4,558
Location
Manchester
Few more minutes than were featured on the FLS.

[video]http://www.coventrytelegraph.net/sport/football/football-news/watch-match-highlights-coventry-citys-7850089?[/video]
 
Pausing the video at 0:35, looks like a dive in my book.

Well Garner might have a reputation, warranted or not, for going to ground easily, but under no circumstances was this a dive. It was plainly obvious to all and sundry in that part of the stadium that it was a clear penalty: the opposition didn't react, the North End players hardly had a "shout" to make, the referee was a mere 10 yards behind the incident looking straight at it, and he gave it instantly. Another incident in the first half was equally worthy of a penalty, which he did not give.

I don't know if you are trying to diminish the validity of the awarding of the penalty, or claiming that it was a lucky decision, but it was certainly a penalty.
 
Pausing the video at 0:35, looks like a dive in my book.

A dive is where a player goes to ground where there is no contact whatsoever or a player simulates what contact there is themselves. Whether Garner went down easily or not it was a stone wall penalty. Garner got in front of the defender who stuck his leg out and got nowhere near the ball but made contact with the player. For me it's bad defending that is to blame, any striker in the modern day would have gone down in that position and 9 out of 10 refs would give it as a pen.
 
Cheers much better than the constantly zoomed in bollox that the BBC and Sky showed.
Also shows the "themed" Garner goal celebration that was mysteriously cut out of the BBC coverage. 😀
 
Few more minutes than were featured on the FLS.

[video]http://www.coventrytelegraph.net/sport/football/football-news/watch-match-highlights-coventry-citys-7850089?[/video]

I thought PNE was taking the Piss with the 1 sided Highlights, but they wasn't, really was one sided.
 
GlisteningRealAmericanbittern.gif
 
Judging from those highlights, and the ones that North End's official YouTube channel have, the penalty we got looks like the softest of them all. Yes, it looked a penalty to me, but there were other appeals waved away that looked more like penalties.
 
Judging from those highlights, and the ones that North End's official YouTube channel have, the penalty we got looks like the softest of them all. Yes, it looked a penalty to me, but there were other appeals waved away that looked more like penalties.

If every foul in the box were given there'd be about 10 penalties a game! Seems that with some refs you have to really earn them and there's no doubt that sometimes things get evened up if there's been a bad decision earlier.

Its all bollocks really - for me, give the fouls when they're fouls and defenders would soon sort themselves out in a few weeks and we'd probably see more goals in open play as a result.

Same with ref backchat. Book/send players off when they give the ref shit and it'd soon stop. The first couple of weeks would be a bloodbath but after that we'd have a better game for it.
 
Back
Top