Skip to main content

Current Squad

Current Squad

Joined
Jul 8, 2010
Messages
12,720
As of 8 May 2017.
Current squad

This is our current squad and what I think about them.

No. Position Player
2 DF Marnick Vermijl.................not good enough IMO
3 DF Greg Cunningham..............consistent performer and first choice left back.
4 MF Ben Pearson.......................automatic choice but needs to curb yellow cards
5 DF Tom Clarke (captain)............will probably miss all next season. A big loss.
7 FW Daryl Horgan.......................really like this lad & expect further improvement.
8 MF Alan Browne........................didn't progress as much as I expected. Needs to improve.
11 MF Daniel Johnson....................please play him in his best position, otherwise ineffective.
12 MF Paul Gallagher......................I expect him to be a squad player next season.
13 FW Eoin Doyle...........................not sure he'll be here next season.
15 DF Calum Woods.......................if fully recovered, could make the right back position his.
16 MF Liam Grimshaw.....................can't see him making a mark at PNE.
17 DF Tommy Spurr........................a decent squad player but not a definite starter.
18 MF Ben Pringle...........................I expect him to move on during the summer.
19 MF John Welsh (vice-captain).......good servant but game time likely to be limited.
20 DF Ben Davies............................excellent loan at Fleetwood and may still have a future at PNE.
21 FW Stevie May............................hoping to see him at his best next season
22 GK Chris Maxwell........................good keeper but needs decent competition.
23 DF Paul Huntington.....................good pro and gives his best at all times.
24 DF Andy Boyle...........................needs a good pre season and hoping for further improvement.
25 FW Jordan Hugill.........................vastly improved, but needs to improve 1 on 1s
29 FW Tom Barkhuizen......................good signing and will probably improve further
37 FW Callum Robinson.....................excellent player, just needs to be more consistant.
40 GK Matthew Hudson.....................would benefit from a season loan


We have players that improved beyond expectation (Hugill, Robinson) but they still lack consistency in order for us to progress to the next level. Cunningham & Pearson (Clarke if not injured) are the only players that are likely to give a consistant performance over 46 games IMO. I don't expect people to agree with me but I'm deliberately trying to be harsh. IMO, we need to start with Maxwell, Cunningham & Pearson, sign 2 permanant players who will become first team regulars and to sign 3 loan signings of the same standard. That gives us 8 guaranteed starters when available. We then need 3 of the better players to improve their consistency levels and then we will be in business. Next season is a big season for us. We need to invest in order to progress. We have strengthened the squad over the past 2 seasons but this season we need to improve the starting 11.

As I say, I don't expect people to agree with the content of this post, but I'll be very interested in other people's opinions on the matter.
 
As of 8 May 2017.
Current squad

This is our current squad and what I think about them.

No. Position Player
2 DF Marnick Vermijl.................not good enough IMO
3 DF Greg Cunningham..............consistent performer and first choice left back.
4 MF Ben Pearson.......................automatic choice but needs to curb yellow cards
5 DF Tom Clarke (captain)............will probably miss all next season. A big loss.
7 FW Daryl Horgan.......................really like this lad & expect further improvement.
8 MF Alan Browne........................didn't progress as much as I expected. Needs to improve.
11 MF Daniel Johnson....................please play him in his best position, otherwise ineffective.
12 MF Paul Gallagher......................I expect him to be a squad player next season.
13 FW Eoin Doyle...........................not sure he'll be here next season.
15 DF Calum Woods.......................if fully recovered, could make the right back position his.
16 MF Liam Grimshaw.....................can't see him making a mark at PNE.
17 DF Tommy Spurr........................a decent squad player but not a definite starter.
18 MF Ben Pringle...........................I expect him to move on during the summer.
19 MF John Welsh (vice-captain).......good servant but game time likely to be limited.
20 DF Ben Davies............................excellent loan at Fleetwood and may still have a future at PNE.
21 FW Stevie May............................hoping to see him at his best next season
22 GK Chris Maxwell........................good keeper but needs decent competition.
23 DF Paul Huntington.....................good pro and gives his best at all times.
24 DF Andy Boyle...........................needs a good pre season and hoping for further improvement.
25 FW Jordan Hugill.........................vastly improved, but needs to improve 1 on 1s
29 FW Tom Barkhuizen......................good signing and will probably improve further
37 FW Callum Robinson.....................excellent player, just needs to be more consistant.
40 GK Matthew Hudson.....................would benefit from a season loan


We have players that improved beyond expectation (Hugill, Robinson) but they still lack consistency in order for us to progress to the next level. Cunningham & Pearson (Clarke if not injured) are the only players that are likely to give a consistant performance over 46 games IMO. I don't expect people to agree with me but I'm deliberately trying to be harsh. IMO, we need to start with Maxwell, Cunningham & Pearson, sign 2 permanant players who will become first team regulars and to sign 3 loan signings of the same standard. That gives us 8 guaranteed starters when available. We then need 3 of the better players to improve their consistency levels and then we will be in business. Next season is a big season for us. We need to invest in order to progress. We have strengthened the squad over the past 2 seasons but this season we need to improve the starting 11.

As I say, I don't expect people to agree with the content of this post, but I'll be very interested in other people's opinions on the matter.

What a load of crap.
 
I can't disagree, you nailed it for me, picked out those who deserve praise and put the spotlight on those who have either not progressed or do not contribute /add value. For me a good well constructed and thought out post, any narky comments to this that are not constructive just ignore em pal, no excuse for ignorance.
 
I can't disagree, you nailed it for me, picked out those who deserve praise and put the spotlight on those who have either not progressed or do not contribute /add value. For me a good well constructed and thought out post, any narky comments to this that are not constructive just ignore em pal, no excuse for ignorance.

Cheers mate. I was hoping there was enough content/controversy to inspire a debate/exchange of views on our current squad. As I say, I don't expect people to agree with me, but I'm interested in other people's views.
 
Agree with most you say there. Vermijl for me definitely worth keeping though, even if as a good squad player.

Welsh again, i think youve got it right but will be more than useful in a role when we go away with the attitude not to lose. for me thats something weve been missing this season.
 
Seems like a safe assessment with nothing controversial.

That said . . . . 🙂 . . would like to see Vermijl have a full pre season and be injury free before writing him off. I know you haven't included loan players but would say the same about Browning.
 
Cheers mate. I was hoping there was enough content/controversy to inspire a debate/exchange of views on our current squad. As I say, I don't expect people to agree with me, but I'm interested in other people's views.

On your player list I agree with every single one.

As for your assessment of what we need, I think the key thing we need next season is a settled back line.
 
Seems like a safe assessment with nothing controversial.

That said . . . . 🙂 . . would like to see Vermijl have a full pre season and be injury free before writing him off. I know you haven't included loan players but would say the same about Browning.

Yeah, I didn't mention loan players because we've no idea if any of them will return.

I'm still hopeful of Vermaijl & Grimshaw but I'm not as optimistic about them as I once was.

I think what prompted my OP was if you can ignore the first 6 & last 6 games of the season, we had an excellent season and were capable of beating any team in the Championship. We have good players who did well for some of the season. The only thing that seemed to be lacking was consistancy. I'm hoping that with another season's experience under their belts the likes of Hugill, Robinson and others will improve further and to manage to do it over more games.
 
On your player list I agree with every single one.

As for your assessment of what we need, I think the key thing we need next season is a settled back line.

I think that was the main reason for our last 6 games! The likes of Boyle & Spurr are both capable of slotting in if 1 player is missing but it was a big ask for 3 defenders to come in and be expected to do as well as our regular back four. I think we need a 'real' right back and a big CH. We lack height at the back apart from Huntington, but if any defender is left out it always seems to be Hunts. I think Grayson has his favourites and Hunts doesn't seem to be one of them.
 
Agree with the OPs assessments.

my worry is there is no obvious spine to the team.

Lets just say I have some reservations about Maxwell's overall game.
We've lost our defensive rock.
We don't know our best centre midfield combination. We need someone else in there. I like Pearson and think he's a great prospect but he's got work to do. Can't be a midfield enforcer while banned more than once.
up top Hugill has done great and let's hope he can improve his finishing further. 1 V 1 for example.

We have to operate within a budget. We have a few too many ordinary players signed up for far too long.
Every summer we have a big recruitment job to do. We partially get there but we are a long long way off a too 6 side ATM. Not sure (still) on our best 11 / combination.
 
I think we need a 'real' right back

Agree and that is why I hope we recruit there over the summer. In order to have a settled backline, ideally you're wanting a defensively reliable right back who plays 35+ games per season.

The return of Woods will be a welcome one, but coming off the back of this serious knee injury, and taking into account that he has been a bit injury prone in the past too with knocks, muscle injuries etc. I think we may have to be slightly realistic about the amount of games he plays, particularly in busy periods.

Vermijl seems to split opinion. Personally I don't feel he's the man we need to step in and play games at right back if there is an injury to Woods for example. Imho he's not good enough defensively.

I'm also not keen on us relying on centre backs like Baptiste and Browning to play right back for long spells. I'd rather have an out and out full back who's a bit more capable of getting up and down rather than primarily central defenders who carry quite big builds like the two I've just mentioned.

Basically we need a right-sided clone of Cunningham ! It's certainly been a problem position for us and it will be interesting to see what happens with regards to this position.

As for centre back it's obvious the numbers are lacking as it stands and significant recruitment will have to happen in that position. Leadership in that area is what needs adding in the absence of Clarke.
 
Does anyone know Davies' position? I thought he was a left back and I'm sure that's what he's played for us, but at Fleetwood he's a centre half. Which do you think he's more suited for?
He did seem a bit slow at left back but most full backs are compared to Cunningham and Vermijl so I think he'll end up playing most of his career in the left of a defensive 3.
 
Does anyone know Davies' position? I thought he was a left back and I'm sure that's what he's played for us, but at Fleetwood he's a centre half. Which do you think he's more suited for?
He did seem a bit slow at left back but most full backs are compared to Cunningham and Vermijl so I think he'll end up playing most of his career in the left of a defensive 3.

His natural position is a left sided centre back. Fleetwood predominantly played a back three with him on the left.
 
That said . . . . 🙂 . . would like to see Vermijl have a full pre season and be injury free before writing him off. I know you haven't included loan players but would say the same about Browning.

The problem with him his history shows he can't stay injury free. We all know if he gets in within 6 or 7 games he'll suddenly be missing with a groin strain or a tiht hamstring.

Does anyone know Davies' position? I thought he was a left back and I'm sure that's what he's played for us, but at Fleetwood he's a centre half. Which do you think he's more suited for?
He did seem a bit slow at left back but most full backs are compared to Cunningham and Vermijl so I think he'll end up playing most of his career in the left of a defensive 3.

He was always a CB, played at LB by Westley and then again by Grayson but was playing LCB in a 3 at Fleetwood. Could be a good option to have around being able to play CB, LCB and LB. However I wouldn't be surprised to see another loan for him and then come into it maybe next season as Spurrs deal approaches the end, well goes into its final year.
 
Midfield

Midfield

my worry is there is no obvious spine to the team.

We don't know our best centre midfield combination. We need someone else in there. I like Pearson and think he's a great prospect but he's got work to do. Can't be a midfield enforcer while banned more than once.

When I read through these posts I start to worry about midfield.

We don't seem to have a single midfielder that most of us have full confidence in!
 
Just posted about this on the recruitment thread.

erhun oztumer at walsall, certainly worth more than just a glance.

25 year old, good tackler, great passer / creative. Scored 15 goals this season.
 
Back
Top