Skip to main content

Daniel Johnson

Daniel Johnson

Joined
Dec 12, 2010
Messages
754
Location
Grimsargh
i know there's talk of us signing this lad, but would he actually be eligible to play for us? He's already played for Oldham and Chesterfield, so would he be allowed to play for a 3rd team. Hatem Ben Arfa was recently refused to sign for Nice as he'd played for Hull and Newcastle already? Him and Robinson would be great additions imo
 
i know there's talk of us signing this lad, but would he actually be eligible to play for us? He's already played for Oldham and Chesterfield, so would he be allowed to play for a 3rd team. Hatem Ben Arfa was recently refused to sign for Nice as he'd played for Hull and Newcastle already? Him and Robinson would be great additions imo

I think that with it being loan deals then yes he can it counts regarding perminate transfers? ( I believe & understand, but could be wrong?)
 
FIFA rule

Players may be registered for a maximum of three clubs during the period from 1 July until 30 June of the following year. During this period, the player is only eligible to play in Official Matches for two clubs.

It seems you are right on this one. Hes been registered by villa, chesterfield and Oldham already.
 
We're definitely in for him, same with Robinson - just waiting on a decision from Lambert now.

Can't answer your original question though mate.
 
We're definitely in for him, same with Robinson - just waiting on a decision from Lambert now.

Can't answer your original question though mate.

Have you heard anything on what the chances of Lambert letting these 2 players come to us on loan yet?
 
i know there's talk of us signing this lad, but would he actually be eligible to play for us? He's already played for Oldham and Chesterfield, so would he be allowed to play for a 3rd team. Hatem Ben Arfa was recently refused to sign for Nice as he'd played for Hull and Newcastle already? Him and Robinson would be great additions imo
don't think you can play for 3 loan clubs in the same season
 
Daniel Johnson

Your posts are getting more pessimistic by the day.... Almost given up?

We have tried every combo of defence and every combo in midfield and even when I see a time picked that I deem our best XI we still don't dominate....

Even our key players are hit and miss and I was a critic of Wiseman but he appeared to have come good and now he looks a liability. I was adamant Buchanan was our best left back but he was awful last night. The kids are shit and although I think Beckford will come good we have no creativity in our team. I thought Reid was quicker than Humphrey be he hardly seems quicker than Hayhurst was.

I just feel like we are going through the motions at the moment and can predict the outcome of the season already. Been here before several times.

I can't put my finger on it as SG is a better manager than Cotterill, Robinson and Cooper in pedigree and we should be able to match their resources and we have an equal amount of talent. It just seems to be a PNE issue as it's happened for decade upon decade.

I don't see, with what we have, that we will turn the corner and get closer to the top 2 even with a relatively easy run of games including last night.
 
Last edited:
It was an emergency loan at oldham, so that doesn't count apparently.
Correct.

FIFA want the emergency loan system to be scrapped because it bypasses their precious 2-team-per-season rule.

But it hasn't been scrapped yet, so the Oldham loan (a 93 day emergency loan) doesn't count.
 
We have tried every combo of defence and every combo in midfield and even when I see a time picked that I deem our best XI we still don't dominate....

Even our key players are hit and miss and I was a critic of Wiseman but he appeared to have come good and now he looks a liability. I was adamant Buchanan was our best left back but he was awful last night. The kids are shit and although I think Beckford will come good we have no creativity in our team. I thought Reid was quicker than Humphrey be he hardly seems quicker than Hayhurst was.

I just feel like we are going through the motions at the moment and can predict the outcome of the season already. Been here before several times.

I can't put my finger on it as SG is a better manager than Cotterill, Robinson and Cooper in pedigree and we should be able to match their resources and we have an equal amount of talent. It just seems to be a PNE issue as it's happened for decade upon decade.

I don't see, with what we have, that we will turn the corner and get closer to the top 2 even with a relatively easy run of games including last night.


Unfortunately there's hardly a word of that I'd disagree with.... Apart from perhaps " the PNE issue " which is just superstition ..Although I'd even have to agree that it does "seem" that way.
 
We're definitely in for him, same with Robinson - just waiting on a decision from Lambert now.

Can't answer your original question though mate.

Callum Robinson doesn't seem to think he's coming back to Preston any time soon, on Instagram he's telling Kingy they need to try and catch up soon in Birmingham.
 
Callum Robinson doesn't seem to think he's coming back to Preston any time soon, on Instagram he's telling Kingy they need to try and catch up soon in Birmingham.

Yes saw that aswell,but Callum only got told on the Tuesday morning that he was coming to PNE & then he was in our subs bench for the evening game v Chesterfield?
 
Robinson isn't in the Aston Villa squad again today.
 
Back
Top