Skip to main content

David Moyes

David Moyes

Joined
Nov 4, 2010
Messages
1,022
Apologies if this has been discussed somewhere else today. It seems strange that the club should announce last night/this morning that they were not considering any ex managers. This is a very important appointment for the club. Moyes ticks a lot of boxes for North End, including experience, contacts, his connection with the club and not least that he's been most successful when managing smaller teams with tight budgets. To rule out a candidate with these kind of positives and goodwill with the fans, before you've even started the recruitment process, seems illogical.
A possible explanation is that the club, having known that Grayson was likely to be leaving for a few days, had already sounded him out and been told that he doesn't want it.
Which if true, is a shame.
 
Apologies if this has been discussed somewhere else today. It seems strange that the club should announce last night/this morning that they were not considering any ex managers. This is a very important appointment for the club. Moyes ticks a lot of boxes for North End, including experience, contacts, his connection with the club and not least that he's been most successful when managing smaller teams with tight budgets. To rule out a candidate with these kind of positives and goodwill with the fans, before you've even started the recruitment process, seems illogical.
A possible explanation is that the club, having known that Grayson was likely to be leaving for a few days, had already sounded him out and been told that he doesn't want it.
Which if true, is a shame.

I honestly think Moyes would be a gamble. He obviously can't have lost his touch as a manager but there's a bit of a stink following him around at the moment. In any interviews I watched when he was at Sunderland, he seemed deflated and a little apathetic to it all (granted they were fighting relegation, he's hardly going to be bouncing off the walls). I think it might be best for him to just take a break for a bit and maybe rediscover the hunger and fire in himself that probably pushed him into management in the first place.

I also feel like people are romanticising the notion of him "coming home" a bit too much. Success and fond memories from yesteryear will not guarantee a majestic romp to the top of the Championship. It's not quite in the same vein but look what happened when Dalglish went back to Liverpool. Sometimes legends are best left to glow in our collective consciousness.
 
Apologies if this has been discussed somewhere else today. It seems strange that the club should announce last night/this morning that they were not considering any ex managers. This is a very important appointment for the club. Moyes ticks a lot of boxes for North End, including experience, contacts, his connection with the club and not least that he's been most successful when managing smaller teams with tight budgets. To rule out a candidate with these kind of positives and goodwill with the fans, before you've even started the recruitment process, seems illogical.
A possible explanation is that the club, having known that Grayson was likely to be leaving for a few days, had already sounded him out and been told that he doesn't want it.
Which if true, is a shame.
busted flush
 
If we haven't sounded Moyes out, then I don't understand why we wouldn't. Won the LMA Manager of the season award a record 3 times, available and lives in the town. There could be lots of reasons why he doesn't want the job, fine, simply announce that informal discussions have taken place and he has politely declined for personal reasons. Then move onto the next prefered candidate. SG has been on a rolling 12 months contract for over 4 years so surely we must have a "rolling" succession plan? I think we might be over complicating the process based on desperate Agents inundating us with the CVs of losers and wannabees?
 
It's over 15 years since Moyes was at Deepdale and he looked a broken man last season. If Hemmings and Ridsdale sit down with him and see a fire still burning then maybe, but can anyone think of a manager who went back and it was the same?

Kendall to Everton and Dalglish to Liverpool later in their careers was not that good - anyone buck the trend?
 
It's over 15 years since Moyes was at Deepdale and he looked a broken man last season. If Hemmings and Ridsdale sit down with him and see a fire still burning then maybe, but can anyone think of a manager who went back and it was the same?

Kendall to Everton and Dalglish to Liverpool later in their careers was not that good - anyone buck the trend?

Clough back to forest
 
The game has moved on, Moyes hasn't. That's why he's been unsuccessful at his last 3 clubs. It's a no from me

When Moyes started his managerial career with us, he was hungry for success and hated to lose.

Now, he is used to losing on a regular basis and seems to accept it. I'm not sure he can regain his passion and to regain a winning mentality.
 
We're looking at this from our perspective. DM may well consider himself a Prem manager and already said thanks but no thanks. I doubt he'll be starving any time soon so can sit back, do a bit of punditry to keep the wolf from the door and wait for the phone to ring or not as the case may be.
 
If Moyes doesn't want the job, and want it badly enough to be successful, no point in wasting time on that route.

We need someone who is desperate to succeed and improve us.
 
If we haven't sounded Moyes out, then I don't understand why we wouldn't. Won the LMA Manager of the season award a record 3 times, available and lives in the town. There could be lots of reasons why he doesn't want the job, fine, simply announce that informal discussions have taken place and he has politely declined for personal reasons. Then move onto the next prefered candidate. SG has been on a rolling 12 months contract for over 4 years so surely we must have a "rolling" succession plan? I think we might be over complicating the process based on desperate Agents inundating us with the CVs of losers and wannabees?
Maybe he has been sounded out in private and turned it down.
Why would you then announce that this has happened for the new manager to come in knowing he wasnt first choice.

Sent from my SM-G920F using Tapatalk
 
No surprise the club announced this. TH despises Billy Davies and I don't think Moyes would be right for us any more.

The rest are all shocking
 
Maybe he has been sounded out in private and turned it down.
Why would you then announce that this has happened for the new manager to come in knowing he wasnt first choice.

Sent from my SM-G920F using Tapatalk

I remember big John McGrath saying he was about 10th choice, but was just pleased to be given the chance. That appointment didn't turn out too bad. If we appoint another manager who isn't Moyes, with todays social media etc I reckon it would only be a matter of time before the new guy hears about moyes or others having been approached before them, which is not the way to find out. At the end of the day do we really want somebody is sucn a smacked arse that they would be bothered that we at least sounded out other applicants, before they got the job. SG only got the job afater others said they didn't want it.
 
Back
Top