Skip to main content

Dead Wood

Dead Wood

05simpsonm

Registered
Joined
Dec 28, 2010
Messages
1,640
We have got to get rid of the dead wood in this team. I really do think fans look at these players through rose coloured spectacles.

Dead Wood:

Beardo
Cummins
Garner
Moose
Byrom
Monakana
King
Foster
Procter

All these players are not up to this standard. Today highlighted to me that Westley has done well forming the defensive part to our team.

Rudd, Buchanan/Laird, Huntington, Wright, Keane

This defence is probably up there at the top of this league. However, going forward is just a shambles.

Holmes was the only player going forward that looked as if was going to score or create a chance today.

Hayhurst and Monakana are both young and can be slightly forgiven, but the rest of them possess very little quality.

Next season we need 4 or 5 quality attacking players and if this means getting rid of all these 'potentially good if match fit' players, so be it.

If we do not invest in some quality, we will not go up with this crop of players, simple as. It's either bring the likes of Hume back to play or settle for another mid table finish in League 1.

Some fans may strongly disagree, some may agree, it is just the way I see it

UTW!
 
I'd keep Monokana, and perhaps King, but ditch the rest. I get the sense that once King puts one away he'll not stop
 
I'd keep Garner. Has a decent goalscoring record at this level and has hardly had a chance here yet. King would be okay as a backup option.
 
Beardo agree
Cummins 4th choice back up striker perhaps
Garner too early to discard
Moose still think he could make it in our squad but more likely as back up
Byrom agree
Monakana another for the squad
King agree I just don't get what people see in him
Foster agree just taking up a squad place
Procter agree behind mousinho even for the squad

It is always easier to sort outs defence than an attack. You can get all 10 outfield players to play to a plan that is defensive overall. You cannot create chances and finish them off regularly without some genuine quality.

At this level we have Holmes welsh beavon and garner that I think can do this. Neither manager wanted/wants to put garner and beavon together so a striker that can bring the best out of either/both of them is a must. A creative midfielder alongside welsh with wroe as back up is another must and a midfielder who can play either flank leaving Hayhurst and monakana.

Three such players on free transfers/ season loans and within our wage budget seem unlikely.
 
From that list I would keep Monakana and Garner, agree the rest are not up to it and can go asap.
 
Why don't we just get rid of everyone and start again?

That sounds like a really good plan.

No it sounds shit. We have some very good players. Why have people got such an issue with saying we need to offload some of the poorer players in the summer? I even think Man Utd and Barcelona will get rid and refresh with better
 
The only one I would maybe keep is Monakana with the hope he might gain a bit of experience and improve next season, I mean he is still young. Although the others can go, don't think they offer us anything.
 
I'd keep Monokana, and perhaps King, but ditch the rest. I get the sense that once King puts one away he'll not stop

King offers plenty of options an excellent squad player at this level. But as a striker no chance whatever, how many ones does he have to get before not stopping ! A consistent finisher at any level will always have the knack of getting in the right place at the right time more often than not and then getting the ball on target more often than not. Ask any good consistent finisher where they like to play they would all tell you striker.
Jack King does find himself in finishing positions, he never looks or never will look like a striker (not his fault by the way). He could play striker for ten seasons on a run and would never be a consistent finisher and i bet if you asked him where he liked to play it would not be striker.
 
We have got to get rid of the dead wood in this team. I really do think fans look at these players through rose coloured spectacles.

Dead Wood:

Beardo
Cummins
Garner
Moose
Byrom
Monakana
King
Foster
Procter

All these players are not up to this standard. Today highlighted to me that Westley has done well forming the defensive part to our team.

Rudd, Buchanan/Laird, Huntington, Wright, Keane

This defence is probably up there at the top of this league. However, going forward is just a shambles.

Holmes was the only player going forward that looked as if was going to score or create a chance today.

Hayhurst and Monakana are both young and can be slightly forgiven, but the rest of them possess very little quality.

Next season we need 4 or 5 quality attacking players and if this means getting rid of all these 'potentially good if match fit' players, so be it.

If we do not invest in some quality, we will not go up with this crop of players, simple as. It's either bring the likes of Hume back to play or settle for another mid table finish in League 1.

Some fans may strongly disagree, some may agree, it is just the way I see it

UTW!


Garner and Monokana? Really?
 
Back
Top