With a fully fit squad who would be are best defence?
Defence?
- Joined
- Sep 30, 2012
- Messages
- 1,151
OUR best defence would depend on formation. For me the following:
4-4-2: Wiseman Clarke Wright Buchanan
5-3-2 Wiseman Clarke King Wright Laird
4-4-2: Wiseman Clarke Wright Buchanan
5-3-2 Wiseman Clarke King Wright Laird
Is Wiseman likely to be back any time soon?
I Spoke to Scott yesterday & he has said that he's just started training again so maybe after a full weeks training he might be back for Saturdays game. He also said that they aren't rushing him back either so that he is fully fit for the play offs which is more important now.
I Spoke to Scott yesterday & he has said that he's just started training again so maybe after a full weeks training he might be back for Saturdays game. He also said that they aren't rushing him back either so that he is fully fit for the play offs which is more important now.
Good news!
I Spoke to Scott yesterday & he has said that he's just started training again so maybe after a full weeks training he might be back for Saturdays game. He also said that they aren't rushing him back either so that he is fully fit for the play offs which is more important now.
Cheers, hopefully he is back for the semi's.
Been a great signing so far.
- Joined
- Dec 18, 2004
- Messages
- 19,671
I wasn't his biggest fan but I don't see how you can leave King out at the moment, and Clarke will be in there somewhere so that depends if he's in at RB or CB, and Laird for LB.
Wright has been poor recently, especially with his passing but leaving him out will be tough. So after all that I guess I'd go for:
Clarke - King - Wright - Laird.
Wright has been poor recently, especially with his passing but leaving him out will be tough. So after all that I guess I'd go for:
Clarke - King - Wright - Laird.
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2004
- Messages
- 1,222
I wasn't his biggest fan but I don't see how you can leave King out at the moment, and Clarke will be in there somewhere so that depends if he's in at RB or CB, and Laird for LB.
Wright has been poor recently, especially with his passing but leaving him out will be tough. So after all that I guess I'd go for:
Clarke - King - Wright - Laird.
The biggest problem for wright re his passing is that he is forced onto his weaker foot playing left sided centre half. Of the others none of then have a left foot that is for anything but standing on.
A left footed centre half would provide balance.
- Joined
- Jul 21, 2010
- Messages
- 39,383
Wiseman Clarke King Laird, whatever the formation. King is just a far better footballer than Wright.
King looks like he thinks he's a good footballer! And to be fair, he's nearly there. But his passing needs to be far more consistent.
And what he was doing for the first goal yesterday?... OK he was played into trouble, but he had an age to kick it anywhere... into the car park maybe... but he thought he was good enough to do something a bit clever.
Bailey Wright for me... but King is definitely looking good.
- Joined
- Jul 14, 2008
- Messages
- 1,834
In a 4 then Wiseman-Clarke-King-Laird or Buchanan (I feel they're very evenly matched)
For a 5 then just stick Wright in there as well
For a 5 then just stick Wright in there as well
- Joined
- Aug 22, 2005
- Messages
- 362
King looks like he thinks he's a good footballer! And to be fair, he's nearly there. But his passing needs to be far more consistent.
And what he was doing for the first goal yesterday?... OK he was played into trouble, but he had an age to kick it anywhere... into the car park maybe... but he thought he was good enough to do something a bit clever.
Bailey Wright for me... but King is definitely looking good.
Don't get me wrong , Wright has done very well this season , I just feel he's limited when it comes to passing the ball. You mention that King needs to improve his passing, he generally finds a white shirt while Wright quite often finds row ten in the Finney.
- Joined
- Dec 4, 2005
- Messages
- 22,726
Don't get me wrong , Wright has done very well this season , I just feel he's limited when it comes to passing the ball. You mention that King needs to improve his passing, he generally finds a white shirt while Wright quite often finds row ten in the Finney.
Which is what King should have done for their first goal instead of fucking around with it.
Don't get me wrong , Wright has done very well this season , I just feel he's limited when it comes to passing the ball. You mention that King needs to improve his passing, he generally finds a white shirt while Wright quite often finds row ten in the Finney.
I know what you're saying but surely no nonsense defending like that is quite often a good thing, if it gets us out of trouble? I suppose if he's got plenty of time to pick out a pass and can't then that's a bit of an issue. But realistically speaking, we are in league 1 and I doubt there's many ball playing centre halves knocking about!
- Joined
- Dec 18, 2004
- Messages
- 19,671
I know what you're saying but surely no nonsense defending like that is quite often a good thing, if it gets us out of trouble? I suppose if he's got plenty of time to pick out a pass and can't then that's a bit of an issue. But realistically speaking, we are in league 1 and I doubt there's many ball playing centre halves knocking about!
I'm ok with clearances hitting row 10 of the Finney, but not forward passes when he has a bit of time. His other favourite is the lob over everyone to the opposition keeper.
I'm ok with clearances hitting row 10 of the Finney, but not forward passes when he has a bit of time. His other favourite is the lob over everyone to the opposition keeper.
Agreed. From the games I've seen, he's been solid for us though. Not sure if his performances have dipped of late? Clarke has been the best defender I've seen this season though.
Wright in front of King for me
WISEMAN CLARKE WRIGHT BUCHANAN
PLAYING 3-5-2
WISEMAN CLARKE KING WRIGHT LAIRD
WISEMAN CLARKE WRIGHT BUCHANAN
PLAYING 3-5-2
WISEMAN CLARKE KING WRIGHT LAIRD
Last edited:
- Joined
- May 7, 2009
- Messages
- 918
Would be interesting to see how a 4-3-3 would work
Would be interesting to see how a 4-3-3 would work
.......................Rudd
.....Wiseman Clarke Wright Laird
.......................King
................Welsh Browne/Brownhill
............Beavon ......Gallagher
.....................Garner
I would be interested to see how we would fair using this system. Granted there are other options for positions to what I have put above but that looks like a decent team that could be dangerous. Would love to see Jack King given the kind of role that Gerrard has been doing for Liverpool all season. Sat in front of the back 4 spraying balls left and right. His range of passing is the best in the team and he could comfortably play this position and be highly effective there imho.
Would be interesting to see how a 4-3-3 would work
.......................Rudd
.....Wiseman Clarke Wright Laird
.......................King
................Welsh Browne/Brownhill
............Beavon ......Gallagher
.....................Garner
I would be interested to see how we would fair using this system. Granted there are other options for positions to what I have put above but that looks like a decent team that could be dangerous. Would love to see Jack King given the kind of role that Gerrard has been doing for Liverpool all season. Sat in front of the back 4 spraying balls left and right. His range of passing is the best in the team and he could comfortably play this position and be highly effective there imho.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Aug 28, 2006
- Messages
- 690
Two mistakes only by King and Brown during the whole of yesterdays game,goals resulting from both.