Skip to main content

Defensive Midfielder

Defensive Midfielder

Joined
Aug 29, 2004
Messages
551
One thing I've noticed from recent games is that we are losing a lot of possesion from the midfield, be it getting caught in possession or giving the ball away with sloppy passing.

We desperately need a quality defensive midfielder. Someone in the Brian O'neil mould who can just sit infront of the back four and disrupt the opposing teams play and who can distribute the ball well to get attacking moves started.
 
One thing I've noticed from recent games is that we are losing a lot of possesion from the midfield, be it getting caught in possession or giving the ball away with sloppy passing.

We desperately need a quality defensive midfielder. Someone in the Brian O'neil mould who can just sit infront of the back four and disrupt the opposing teams play and who can distribute the ball well to get attacking moves started.

Certainly apparent that today, I agree.

Loss of possession cost us once with Callum, but could have been punished on many more occasions. Thought we played pretty well last 40 mins of second half, but cruel sucker punches did for us today.
 
The midfield needs a total revamp.

Todays midfield was woefully bereft of craft, guile, imagination, pace and presence.

Davidson is not a midfielder, nor is he match fit it seems.

Sedgwick/Lewis Neal not good enough at this level.

Pugh is ok and the best of a bad bunch.

Miller was utterly anonymous again- thanks but no thanks, tell roy we said hi.

Whaley is a lazy git, and has been utter cack for the last few weeks.


We need an attacking mid more than anything, someone who can get on the scoresheet as well.
 
I agree in a way but with PA=L but the way i see it is that when O'neil was in the team consistently, it gave Mckenna more freedom to advance up the pitch to attack, but since the departure of O'neil Mckenna is having to spend more time tracking back and defending. How many times would you see Mckenna playing square balls in front of the back four when BON was in the team. So i think a quality defensive midfielder will allow Mckenna to get back to what he's best at.
 
What about that player...........Jarrett?

Good point i tend to forget about Jarrett with him being out of the picture for a while, that being said he wasn't farmed out on loan for no reason, there's obviously an attitude problem that needs addressing, if it could be dealt with i think he could still play a big part in our season.
 
Mckennas a scrapper, not a creator and he doesnt have remotely enough quality to run a team and in attacking.

Jarrett really could be that player, but he wont be because of his attitude, and inability to impose himself on games
 
i think mckenna is best at what he is doing at the moment, scrapping for every ball, he is brilliant at it.

jarrett i think could be a good player for us, someone with a bit of presence in there.
 
The fact is we need some real quality in midfield and i expect to see a couple of new midfielders bought during this transfer window.
 
I have to disagree about the point about Mckenna being a scrapper, i honestly think that with a quality player providing the defensive cover Mckenna can be very dangerous going forward.
 
One thing kenna does do well is dictate our tempo- we were sadly lacking this today. His perpetial motion keeps is ticking. Hes good in possession in and around the box. I just doubt his ability to actually create or execute anything from this.

He should be the defensive one to his attacking colleague, not the other way round IMO
 
Your location = Legend. In fact, me and my housemates have dubbed our uni house the very same. Our shed is called the cinammons. How cool are we 🙄
 
Couple of points I'd like to make

- Callum Davidson was outstanding against Sunderland, he did OK today but did give the ball away which led to their 1st goal. What we must realise though, is that this is not his preferred position.

- Chris Sedgwick has hit some poor form, he had 5-6 games were he was superb but at the moment he cannot do anything right, his fitness level today was awful, I spotted him with his hands on knees blowing like mad after 20mins.

- Lewis Neal is simply not good enough at this level, needs shipping off to Rochdale ASAP. Joe Ayinsah deserves a chance ahead of him.

- Jason Jarrett maybe deserves another chance, but I'd hate to see him reproduce form from early on this season cos he tended to go missing a lot, which we cannot afford to let happen.

- Tommy Miller played OK today, did really well against Sunderland (probably well up for it though). Hasn't shown any signs that he could be a goalscoring midfielder though (thought that was his strength?)

- Simon Whaley & Paul McKenna are doing OK, our game changed when they came on today, nice to have on the bench.

Overall I agree that we need a new centre midfielder, attacking/defensive whatever really just someone to allow others to create/score cos we aren't scoring that many from midfield.
 
We desperately need a quality defensive midfielder. Someone in the Brian O'neil mould who can just sit infront of the back four and disrupt the opposing teams play and who can distribute the ball well to get attacking moves started.

I'm convinced that Alexander can fulfil that role - these days he lacks pace and we need to get a quick right back during the window.

This doesn't neccessarily have to be a big money buy - we could always play the loan market as several of our close rivals have already done. Surely our scouting system can unearth a suitable player - I can think of one who isn't featuring much at West Ham at the moment.😉
 
if we are talking quality midfielders,we saw one today and billy davis went out and got him..david jones absolute class.
 
Back
Top