Skip to main content

Despite win, I'm unhappy

Despite win, I'm unhappy

Joined
Jul 10, 2011
Messages
278
Location
Ashton
Okay so title says it all but I'll elaborate anyway just so people don't think I'm a moaning git.

I went on against Rochdale and didn't expect us to steam roll them but didn't expect to get shown up in the 1st half like we were. It was embarrassing. We didn't once get the ball on the deck in the 1st half. They seemed to dictate the tempo and did all the short nice crisp passing that I'd have liked to have seen from Preston. They had the best chances and they definitely would have gone in at half time feeling unlucky not to have been in the lead. We had little and Gallagher on either wing which in my opinion doesn't work. The new lad woods and Davies were not supporting like they should and kev was flicking his headers on to no one. Kilkenny seems to be in the game more than the two young lads in midfield.

Little, from what I've seen of him seems a little short of fitness for some reason. He doesn't track back and I'm sure he's not but he comes across as lazy.
Fair enough he ran a long way from the wing to inside the box and did extremely well to stay on his feet and some how turn it in, but that one piece of brilliance doesn't show a realistic reflection.

My next point won't be taken well on here as many people love the idea of the young playing. Don't get me wrong, brownhill, browne and b Davies look like they have tremendous potential, they all have bulked out and gained muscle; they look fit, powerful, strong and above all else eager! However, they are making mistakes... Not obvious ones... Sonetimes it's being out of position or other times it's not fully committing themselves into a 50:50. All I'm saying is perhaps we should look at welsh again to play instead of either brownhill or Browne.

Just so I don't come across like one of the horrible negative nancies , Big plus points tonight were:

We looked dangerous from corners (for the first time since billy Davies)
Highill showed that he can be a good striker that can flick on, control, stick his body where it hurts and he's more mobile than people think.
Clarke and Bailey have got CB tied up !!! Big time! Both quick, both talk, both good in the air etc etc etc .... Great CB partnership at this level!
 
Having seen us stumble and trip over 'easy' games in the past like this I didn't think we were that bad in appalling conditions, okay the first half wasn't great but we were never under the cosh and got the goals when we needed to, away from home that's all you want
 
I was pleasantly surprised myself. Although I notice a lot of 'big' clubs went out last night. Tactical, I presume. Or just shitness, not sure.
 
I wasn't there but it didn't sound pretty on the radio. That said, 2 goals and a clean sheet for a team playing in a new system with a new keeper, new full backs, three 18/19yr olds and without our best striker isn't bad going.

Hopefully things will click at the weekend, although i'd take another scrappy, unimpressive win.
 
It seems to be a slightly stop-go start to the season but at least we are sticking with a consistent formation and not chopping and changing it from game to game. Given our current resources this 4.3.3 that we are playing is the right one - we are awash with central midfielders and strikers so it makes the best use of the players we have. But there seem to be some question marks - the fullbacks are perhaps not getting up in support of the attack as much as they need to, the midfield though skillfull is maybe a bit lightweight and perhaps lacks a bit of grit and the forward line is also maybe a bit disjointed.

Well of those three the fullback situation can be changed easily enough if we want - Wiseman and Laird are there if we need them. As for the midfield again there are alternatives - any of King, Keane or Welsh could be slotted in to provide a bit more aggression or muscle if need be though two and certainly all three of them might then tilt the balance too far in the other direction. Hayhurst could also, I suspect, be effective in a three-man midfield.

But upfront I am not convinced by what seems to be SG's tactic of playing one central striker with two others running wider on either side - a three-man strikeforce really needs to consist of a proper strike partnership and one other who can run a bit wider. That means we have to find a reliable foil for Garner and another who can complement that partnership. On that latter count Little is showing promise, Hayhurst again can be effective, Reid when he is fit may also fit the bill. But who can that partner for Garner be - Kevin Davies does seem to have the required disruptive effect but can he play enough games?

The player who just does not seem to fit anywhere in this is Gallagher. Yes he can be skillfull but he lacks he pace and drive to play wide and he does not seem to like being a centre forward. At some point SG will need to address this issue and find a way to resolve it. The reports indicate that Kevin Davies did well last night - well if Garner is fit again for Saturday someone will have to make way for him and that presumably will be either Gallagher or Davies. So let's see what SG decides.
 
Okay so title says it all but I'll elaborate anyway just so people don't think I'm a moaning git.

I went on against Rochdale and didn't expect us to steam roll them but didn't expect to get shown up in the 1st half like we were. It was embarrassing. We didn't once get the ball on the deck in the 1st half. They seemed to dictate the tempo and did all the short nice crisp passing that I'd have liked to have seen from Preston. They had the best chances and they definitely would have gone in at half time feeling unlucky not to have been in the lead. We had little and Gallagher on either wing which in my opinion doesn't work. The new lad woods and Davies were not supporting like they should and kev was flicking his headers on to no one. Kilkenny seems to be in the game more than the two young lads in midfield.

Little, from what I've seen of him seems a little short of fitness for some reason. He doesn't track back and I'm sure he's not but he comes across as lazy.
Fair enough he ran a long way from the wing to inside the box and did extremely well to stay on his feet and some how turn it in, but that one piece of brilliance doesn't show a realistic reflection.

My next point won't be taken well on here as many people love the idea of the young playing. Don't get me wrong, brownhill, browne and b Davies look like they have tremendous potential, they all have bulked out and gained muscle; they look fit, powerful, strong and above all else eager! However, they are making mistakes... Not obvious ones... Sonetimes it's being out of position or other times it's not fully committing themselves into a 50:50. All I'm saying is perhaps we should look at welsh again to play instead of either brownhill or Browne.

Just so I don't come across like one of the horrible negative nancies , Big plus points tonight were:

We looked dangerous from corners (for the first time since billy Davies)
Highill showed that he can be a good striker that can flick on, control, stick his body where it hurts and he's more mobile than people think.
Clarke and Bailey have got CB tied up !!! Big time! Both quick, both talk, both good in the air etc etc etc .... Great CB partnership at this level!


Some good points here. Really glad to hear Hugill looked decent. I totally agree that Brown and Brownhill shouldn't be our midfield. Let them both fight for a spot with Welsh (who I'm not a massive fan of but his experience is invaluable).
 
Last night we were very average first half, but lets not forget Rochdale are in the same division as us. Second half we were better but when they went down to 10 we kind of just sat back I thought.

Woods, Ben Davies and Gallagher looked well below what's required, the midfield had a tough night and maybe playing Browne and Brownhill together isn't a great plan.

All in all a game that in past seasons we may have lost, so here's to an exciting tie in the next round.
 
It's okay saying Woods and Davies should be replaced with Wiseman and Laird but they'd still only play how Grayson tells them which at the moment seems to be to sit in and give it to one of the midfielders or knock it long
 
But upfront I am not convinced by what seems to be SG's tactic of playing one central striker with two others running wider on either side - a three-man strikeforce really needs to consist of a proper strike partnership and one other who can run a bit wider. That means we have to find a reliable foil for Garner and another who can complement that partnership. On that latter count Little is showing promise, Hayhurst again can be effective, Reid when he is fit may also fit the bill. But who can that partner for Garner be - Kevin Davies does seem to have the required disruptive effect but can he play enough games?

The player who just does not seem to fit anywhere in this is Gallagher. Yes he can be skillfull but he lacks he pace and drive to play wide and he does not seem to like being a centre forward. At some point SG will need to address this issue and find a way to resolve it. The reports indicate that Kevin Davies did well last night - well if Garner is fit again for Saturday someone will have to make way for him and that presumably will be either Gallagher or Davies. So let's see what SG decides.

I agree with this. Garner needs another striker upfront. Too much ineffective long ball to the lone striker.

Little is wasted on the wing and can't defend back. As you say Gallagher is an enigma. He can be brilliant but he is anonymous for large parts of the game.
 
It's okay saying Woods and Davies should be replaced with Wiseman and Laird but they'd still only play how Grayson tells them which at the moment seems to be to sit in and give it to one of the midfielders or knock it long

Irrespective of how they are asked to play, both defended poorly last night.
 
Last night we were very average first half, but lets not forget Rochdale are in the same division as us. Second half we were better but when they went down to 10 we kind of just sat back I thought.

Woods, Ben Davies and Gallagher looked well below what's required, the midfield had a tough night and maybe playing Browne and Brownhill together isn't a great plan.

All in all a game that in past seasons we may have lost, so here's to an exciting tie in the next round.

When did rochdale go down to 10 men?
 
It seems to be a slightly stop-go start to the season but at least we are sticking with a consistent formation and not chopping and changing it from game to game. Given our current resources this 4.3.3 that we are playing is the right one - we are awash with central midfielders and strikers so it makes the best use of the players we have.

The player who just does not seem to fit anywhere in this is Gallagher. Yes he can be skillfull but he lacks he pace and drive to play wide and he does not seem to like being a centre forward. At some point SG will need to address this issue and find a way to resolve it. The reports indicate that Kevin Davies did well last night - well if Garner is fit again for Saturday someone will have to make way for him and that presumably will be either Gallagher or Davies. So let's see what SG decides.

A stop-go start to the season? We're 2 games in, thats a statement for 6-10 games in at best once the squads are finalised and we've played a mixture of sides.

You seem to want to drop Gallagher all the time. Regardless of his pace of lack of, or his natural tendency to play wide he was a key part of the attacking side last season with a number of assists and goals and he will continue to be so again this.

Not sure how anyone can be that unhappy really, the season has just started, we have a fair few new players so it's bound to take time to gel the players together. I'll stand by what I said at the start of the season though, I wouldn't be starting with Browne and Brownhill just yet. We have enough changes in the back line to contend with never mind right in front of them in midfield. I can see Welsh coming in for one of them for Saturday's game.
 
We started brightly enough and took the game to Rochdale without really creating too many clear opportunities. I thought we then lost momentum as we gave the ball away too cheaply in midfield and looked a bit off the pace when they had midfield possession. They distributed the ball well to their wide men who put in some decent crosses which I felt Jones, Wright and Clarke dealt with well. Little broke from deep down the right and outpaced and outmuscled his defender to get into the box at the byline and score off the keeper from a tight angle. Very good individual goal although the pace of the team had dropped alarmingly over the half.

SG obviously pepped them up and I thought we came out sharper, both with and without the ball. It was a good finish from Kilkenny and we pressed well and had them on the back foot. Although they broke at pace from time to time, I never thought they would get back into the game. When they went down to 10 men, we took our foot off the gas apart from a couple of pacy runs by Humphrey who came on as sub.

overall a brave decision by Grayson to stick to his guns with team and formation. I still feel Wiseman and Laird would give us more going forward. Little I like the look of when he gets in the game but for a 433 to work, the midfield need to get into the box more (which they did more in the second half) and the wide two need to play off the front man.
Davies does a decent job in winning the balls in but you need people to read this.

I also felt King would have strengthened the midfield defensively in place of either Kilkenny or Brownhill. But clearly Grayson wants to bed down a team and build some momentum. Bookies have stopped taking bets on it being the same team on Saturday but with Garner back for Davies.
 
A stop-go start to the season?

I said 'slightly' - we have played two games and in each we have apparently played well in one half and disappointingly in the other. Hopefully we will start to play consistently well from this Saturday onwards.


You seem to want to drop Gallagher all the time.

No I don't 'want' to drop anybody I am just pointing out that Gallagher doesn't quite fit at the moment. He is at his best with freedom to roam in support of an upfront strikeforce of two other players and the way we are playing at the moment doesn't doesn't give him that opportunity.


Not sure how anyone can be that unhappy really, the season has just started

I am not unhappy with the way the season has started but against the tougher opposition that will come I think we will need to be more consistent and organised that we seem to have been so far.

*
 
Okay so title says it all but I'll elaborate anyway just so people don't think I'm a moaning git.

You shouldn't have bothered you still sound like a moaning git. We draw, people moan. We win, people moan. What do you want us to do loose? Or play pretty 1 touch football? Not going to happen in this league.

I genuinely believe people would rather us loose on this forum to be 'proved' right, than see us be successful. Pathetic really.

When I post on here I'm normally quite reserved but recently, people are starting to get right on my nerves 2 games in to the bloody season.
 
It's okay saying Woods and Davies should be replaced with Wiseman and Laird but they'd still only play how Grayson tells them which at the moment seems to be to sit in and give it to one of the midfielders or knock it long

How does Grayson do this?

Absolute rubbish. In the second part of the interview on the BBC last night Grayson said in the second half he was unhappy because the full backs wasn't getting forward.

But no I'm sure you're right, he tells them to sit back and knock it long.
 
You shouldn't have bothered you still sound like a moaning git. We draw, people moan. We win, people moan. What do you want us to do loose? Or play pretty 1 touch football? Not going to happen in this league.

I genuinely believe people would rather us loose on this forum to be 'proved' right, than see us be successful. Pathetic really.

When I post on here I'm normally quite reserved but recently, people are starting to get right on my nerves 2 games in to the bloody season.

A lot of people would rather see us lose to be proven right than see us win. Its sad really and a way to fuel there ego as being know it all football fans, its a cop out sometimes as they are scared to support a team and manager because of the risk of losing.

Going onto Saturday though this is the team I would like to see.

Jones

Woods - Clarke - Wright - Davies

Humphrey - Kilkenny - Browne/Brownhill - Gallagher

Little - Garner​

Lets give Garner a striker partner who can run in behind and challenge for the knockdowns.
 
A lot of people would rather see us lose to be proven right than see us win. Its sad really and a way to fuel there ego as being know it all football fans, its a cop out sometimes as they are scared to support a team and manager because of the risk of losing.

Going onto Saturday though this is the team I would like to see.

Jones

Woods - Clarke - Wright - Davies

Humphrey - Kilkenny - Browne/Brownhill - Gallagher

Little - Garner​

Lets give Garner a striker partner who can run in behind and challenge for the knockdowns.

Unfortunately Humphrey is a liability at the moment and his appearances will be restricted once Reid is fit.

Grayson doesn't like only 2 players in central midfield, especially away, as we have seen them outnumbered only too often.
 
Back
Top