As the thread title....we have nothing in midfield when Kilkenny doesn't play. Anybody who says Browne should start over Kilkenny is deluded in my opinion :-/
Different team without Kilkenny
Speaking to my brother during the game and he would be the first name on the team sheet for me. You notice his worth when he doesn't play.
- Joined
- Jul 17, 2012
- Messages
- 1,527
Couldn't agree more. He is the paul mckenna, brian o'neil kind of player that takes the ball from the defenders, gets the ball moving, makes the opponents come for the ball, and keeps it on the deck. Fantastic player and very badly missed today. Hope he is back for thursday
Agreed but think Keane and Welsh will start with Gallagher infront of them
Been saying this about Kilkenny and his worth to the team on here for months.
- Joined
- Jul 17, 2012
- Messages
- 1,527
Got to revert back to our most successful away formation with wing backs for me
Rudd
Clarke
King
Wright
Humphrey
Laird
Welsh
Kilkenny
Gallagher
Garner
Beavon
That would do for me 🙂
Rudd
Clarke
King
Wright
Humphrey
Laird
Welsh
Kilkenny
Gallagher
Garner
Beavon
That would do for me 🙂
Got to revert back to our most successful away formation with wing backs for me
Rudd
Clarke
King
Wright
Humphrey
Laird
Welsh
Kilkenny
Gallagher
Garner
Beavon
That would do for me 🙂
Totally agree, that'd be my 11 Carts ;-)
- Joined
- Sep 1, 2009
- Messages
- 1,508
Totally agree, that'd be my 11 Carts ;-)
This.
Killa has ankle injury but not sure if fit for Thursday. Brownhill was in squad but not picked.
Not sure why he wasn't on bench as he is for me a class act. Game was too big and too soon for Browne.
Not sure why he wasn't on bench as he is for me a class act. Game was too big and too soon for Browne.
Game was too big and too soon for Browne.
Said exactly the same walking home from the game.
Got to play with wing backs and 3 center backs on thurs with Kilkenny,Welsh and Keane in midfield. Their strength was through the middle and not on the flanks, so we have to flood this area imo. Beavon behind Garner or Gallagher[who had his worst game today].
Things would have been no different if Kilkenny had played.
Agreed. Don't know why some people wax lyrical about him. He's been woeful of late and cost us on a few occasions. He's not exactly a flair player or someone who can create something from nothing so to suggest the score would have been different had he played is quite ludicrous. The people on here would have said the same about Alan Browne had he not played and we had the same outcome.
Don't get me wrong I do rate Kilkenny. He's just not a game changer.
Agreed. Don't know why some people wax lyrical about him. He's been woeful of late and cost us on a few occasions. He's not exactly a flair player or someone who can create something from nothing so to suggest the score would have been different had he played is quite ludicrous. The people on here would have said the same about Alan Browne had he not played and we had the same outcome.
Don't get me wrong I do rate Kilkenny. He's just not a game changer.
Not a game changer??? Are you joking me??? Why do you think the ball was continuously being lumped forward to nobody?
How ppl do not see what a player like Kilkenny brings to the table is absolutely beyond me???
Things would have been no different if Kilkenny had played.
Well theres a chance me may have passed the ball instead of hoofing it . Dreadful performance apart from THAT goal
Not a game changer??? Are you joking me??? Why do you think the ball was continuously being lumped forward to nobody?
How ppl do not see what a player like Kilkenny brings to the table is absolutely beyond me???
Exactly. The way to beat teams that put so much pressure on the ball is to pick them off with simple pass and move, just what Kilkenny excels at. Welsh was chasing shadows, Browne seemed overawed and I was dismayed by the number of times players gave a pass and just stood still, especially Holmes.
- Joined
- Jun 4, 2004
- Messages
- 6,611
Brownhill was in squad but not picked.
Not sure why he wasn't on bench as he is for me a class act. Game was too big and too soon for Browne.
+1