Skip to main content

Disciplinary record

Disciplinary record

Kilkenny has been a poor signing so far, to miss 6 of his games after this ban since we signed him will be a poor return. If he gets another red in the latter part of the season then he will have been a bad signing.

His performances when playing have been good, but we need players on the pitch not in the stand.
 
Yes.. he has. That's fair enough. And I'm not saying he's not playing decent. But another way of presenting the facts is this:

In the 5 games up to/including Port Vale away - he scored in all 5 games (6 goals).... on fire!

In the 13 games since, he's scored in 2 of them (the great cup hatrick and the brace against Vale).


I wouldn't have expected Garner to keep scoring every match, and I'm not belittling him... but there's surely no doubt that the stupid red card has derailed that streak.

He was banned for 3 of those though?
 
Kilkenny has been a poor signing so far, to miss 6 of his games after this ban since we signed him will be a poor return. If he gets another red in the latter part of the season then he will have been a bad signing.

His performances when playing have been good, but we need players on the pitch not in the stand.

6 games? Other than last night, when was he sent off? The Port Vale red was rescinded.
 
OK... Joe Garner's contribution to North End's promotion push was NOT disrupted by his ill-disciplined suspensions.

If that's what everyone wants to hear. 🙄

Well, it disrupted it to the extent that he didn't score in any of the games he didn't play in. All goal streaks come to an end, that's what "form" is all about.

But saying "in the 13 games since, he's scored in 2 of them" seems a bit OTT, that's all. 🙂
 
I wouldn't call getting 2 red cards wrong as having a good game. Average at best I thought.

Disagree. Kilkenny was the architect of his own downfall, with possibly one of the most embarrasing attempts at feigning injury i've ever seen!

Other than that, the ref let the game flow and did a pretty decent job.
 
Disagree. Kilkenny was the architect of his own downfall, with possibly one of the most embarrasing attempts at feigning injury i've ever seen!

Other than that, the ref let the game flow and did a pretty decent job.

The red cards were wrong no matter what Kilkenny's reaction was. Which was out of order from him by the way.
 
We won't be appealing it according to Grayson's post match comments tonight. He thinks both players should have had a yellow but I think the FA might be a bit sick of us coming to them with appeals.

Just as well, after seeing Budgie`s post.
 
Last edited:
Well that's first time I've seen the incident(had a shite view last night) but Kilkenny does himself no favours. Had he not tried to get their lad sent off in that pathetic tumble & feigning injury, then the ref could well have given both a yellow. I think NK's actions wound all their lads up and suddenly a bit of shoving has led to a great melee with everybody getting involved. When you get this, 9 times out of 10, the ref will flash his red card, usually to one from each team.

You idiot Brydon!
 
No sympathy whatever, if we appealed we'd have the ban increased, rightly so. Kilkennys reaction was pathetic. Got what he deserved.
 
Actually. appealing might be a good idea. We've had cast iron ones thrown out in the past ( Williamson sticks in the craw) by the corrupt committee that decides these things, so maybe if we put in a dumbfuck submission then they might uphold it ! ( that was sarcasm btw ) 🙂
 
Actually. appealing might be a good idea. We've had cast iron ones thrown out in the past ( Williamson sticks in the craw) by the corrupt committee that decides these things, so maybe if we put in a dumbfuck submission then they might uphold it ! ( that was sarcasm btw ) 🙂

Want a job as a football club secretary?
 
Back
Top