Skip to main content

Disposable players?

Disposable players?

Joined
Jul 6, 2010
Messages
114
Eh up,

I was thinking about how many players have been 'paid up' and have had their contracts terminated over the last 2/3 seasons.

Is this just us or are other clubs doing the same things?

It seems at the moment that if you arent doing it you are out very quickly. SCS/Amoo/All the squad last season 😛

Is this a good or a bad thing?

Having bad players on big contracts is obviously not a good thing but should we be trying to make these players better and grow with us and not just sending them on their way if they arent perfect straight away.

Is westley taking the same route as the board have with managers recently....No good after 6-9 months...out on yer 'tharse.
 
Putting my negativity towards Westley to one side:

The project seemed to be A) Clear the decks, total sweep out even if it meant clearing the good with the bad. B) Rebuild the squad on short term contracts and thus being able to get rid of the ones he feels are not stepping up to the mark.

Projecting to the future is C) A settled squad of hard working Westleyite players who would be good enough to gain promotion from Lge 1 and hold their own in the championship.


All theories? Of course they are but one things for sure that PNE is no longer a comfort zone for players in the twilight of their careers to pick up a nice healthy unearned wedge.
 
Putting my negativity towards Westley to one side:

The project seemed to be A) Clear the decks, total sweep out even if it meant clearing the good with the bad. B) Rebuild the squad on short term contracts and thus being able to get rid of the ones he feels are not stepping up to the mark.

Projecting to the future is C) A settled squad of hard working Westleyite players who would be good enough to gain promotion from Lge 1 and hold their own in the championship.


All theories? Of course they are but one things for sure that PNE is no longer a comfort zone for players in the twilight of their careers to pick up a nice healthy unearned wedge.

Good post and I agree. It isn't great now and our player turnover is unsustainable but hopefully the club will benefit long term from the decisions being made now. Provided of course we don't go down the trapdoor to league 2.
 
Statistically I read somewhere that I in 3 signings are not succesful. If he has signed say 24 players permanently in the last year, statistically 8 won't work out. So far, excluding loans and players inherited, Holroyd, Amoo, Simonssen have gone = 3. I suspect that SCS (on loan currently), Trundle, Huntington and Beardsley also won't survive a year's employment.
 
Westley and Ridsdale seem to be operating a "trial and error" transfer policy with a hint of Stevenageism about it, I think we will be playing in red and white next season if this pair are still here.
 
Westley and Ridsdale seem to be operating a "trial and error" transfer policy with a hint of Stevenageism about it, I think we will be playing in red and white next season if this pair are still here.

You say in jest Billy, but look what he did to Farnborough.
 
All good stuff.

Totally understand and agree about off season player movement but players being shifted out this season suggests a total shift from the long contract, sick note, older players policy under deadly derek.

My worry is that players might not want to come to us for two reasons:

Rightly or wrongly Westley is as popular as a turd in a swimming pool with fellow managers and fans.

OR

If the players do come if they get an injury or lack a bit of form they will be looking for a new club in 6 months time.

Hardly condusive to 'settled' and 'happy'.

Will these policy create a feeling of fear in the squad?

Soooooooooooooo......In a perfect world we want a balance.
 
All good stuff.

Totally understand and agree about off season player movement but players being shifted out this season suggests a total shift from the long contract, sick note, older players policy under deadly derek.

My worry is that players might not want to come to us for two reasons:

Rightly or wrongly Westley is as popular as a turd in a swimming pool with fellow managers and fans.

OR

If the players do come if they get an injury or lack a bit of form they will be looking for a new club in 6 months time.

Hardly condusive to 'settled' and 'happy'.

Will these policy create a feeling of fear in the squad?

Soooooooooooooo......In a perfect world we want a balance.

Dozens of players at dozens of clubs have had contracts terminated this January. What we have done is not unusual. Only Daley, Holroyd and Simonssen have been released really. Tranmere came in for Amoo and we had to compensate him for the salary difference. Loaning players out like SCS has occurred at virtually every club.
 
Craig Brown started this trend at PNE with Carts and Ranks, plus, no doubt, many more from his vast array of shite and wasteful signings.
 
Dozens of players at dozens of clubs have had contracts terminated this January. What we have done is not unusual. Only Daley, Holroyd and Simonssen have been released really. Tranmere came in for Amoo and we had to compensate him for the salary difference. Loaning players out like SCS has occurred at virtually every club.

ask dino about amoo!
 
OP makes a good point IMO. We have a manager who keeps telling us he needs time, yet hes completely unwilling to give a lot of the players he signs time.

The man needs reigning in in my opinion, but with Ridsdale in charge it isnt going to happen.
 
Putting my negativity towards Westley to one side:

The project seemed to be A) Clear the decks, total sweep out even if it meant clearing the good with the bad. B) Rebuild the squad on short term contracts and thus being able to get rid of the ones he feels are not stepping up to the mark.

Projecting to the future is C) A settled squad of hard working Westleyite players who would be good enough to gain promotion from Lge 1 and hold their own in the championship.


All theories? Of course they are but one things for sure that PNE is no longer a comfort zone for players in the twilight of their careers to pick up a nice healthy unearned wedge.

Problem for me is that plan C is moving away from us rather than looking likely anytime soon.
At the begining of the season I thought there seemed to be a real togetherness about the squad,some of that seems to have gone and that is bound to happen with plan B,and in turn this makes plan C all the harder to achieve.
Lastly good managers improve their players,I do not see that with GW.
 
Just occured to me, surely all of these players should have been scouted!!

Surely when westley knew he was going to over haul the scouts should have been all over games like white on rice scouting them. Scouting wont guarentee success but it may have helped...if this didnt happen of course.

Hmmm, its strange. I think back to moyes saying that he would never sign anyone who wouldnt improve the team. And again with the turn around of players some werent going to work out.

I hope this doesnt keep on happening. I hope that players going now are going to be replaced by more shrewd replacements who are going to improve us. Not some sort of lottery club where it is down to chance.
 
Good post and I agree. It isn't great now and our player turnover is unsustainable but hopefully the club will benefit long term from the decisions being made now. Provided of course we don't go down the trapdoor to league 2.

And that's the crux of it for me. Its a very, very thin line between making sure the club has a sustainable future and the risk of dropping the league. There's no doubt what had to be done, but I do fear sometimes it has been done a little too fast perhaps? Although you could then put that down to Maurice being completely incompetent at the job TH wanted him to do?

Its a tough one, but I've no doubt in my mind that TH's main priority is to make us self sufficient so that he can sell. However, is he prepared to see us drop a league to ensure this happens. Heart would say no, surely not, as we would be worth much more where we are. Head, however, doesn't think it is that clean cut.
 
And that's the crux of it for me. Its a very, very thin line between making sure the club has a sustainable future and the risk of dropping the league. There's no doubt what had to be done, but I do fear sometimes it has been done a little too fast perhaps? Although you could then put that down to Maurice being completely incompetent at the job TH wanted him to do?

Its a tough one, but I've no doubt in my mind that TH's main priority is to make us self sufficient so that he can sell. However, is he prepared to see us drop a league to ensure this happens. Heart would say no, surely not, as we would be worth much more where we are. Head, however, doesn't think it is that clean cut.

I've thought about the points you make in your last paragraph before. Hemmings does want us to be self sufficient, he said it himself last year I believe. Is league 1 a division where the money from the support can pay for all of the outgoings? I doubt it but as you go down the leagues this gap between incomings and outgoings narrows as players earn considerably less.

Does Hemmings want us relegated? It is an intersting thought because I am sure it would be more attractive to him in a business sense (he is a business man after all, not a football man) although I don't think he would ever risk going down that route. Although things are difficult for us fans now after a trio of disappointing seasons, hopefully this cost cutting approach that has been undertaken will benefit the club in the future.
 
Back
Top