Skip to main content

Do we need a striker?

Do we need a striker?

Joined
Oct 4, 2008
Messages
2,563
Location
New Deer
A dumb question, perhaps. All teams need a striker.
I have just watched C5 Championship show and I see no one, bar none, that we should worry about as far as getting promotion.
Hugill is a great worker and holds the ball up well but the goals seem to be coming from all over the park and not from the players you would expect.
So far, this season has far exceeded my expectations. Long may it last.
I still feel that I would like a player who is in the right position, at the right time.
A regular goal scorer; a poacher.
I know that I am going to get slated, but I have been a supporter longer than most of you have had birthdays.
If we had a talisman that could put the ball in the net on a regular basis, this league is ours for the taking.
So there we are. Tin hat time.
 
A dumb question, perhaps. All teams need a striker.
I have just watched C5 Championship show and I see no one, bar none, that we should worry about as far as getting promotion.
Hugill is a great worker and holds the ball up well but the goals seem to be coming from all over the park and not from the players you would expect.
So far, this season has far exceeded my expectations. Long may it last.
I still feel that I would like a player who is in the right position, at the right time.
A regular goal scorer; a poacher.
I know that I am going to get slated, but I have been a supporter longer than most of you have had birthdays.
If we had a talisman that could put the ball in the net on a regular basis, this league is ours for the taking.
So there we are. Tin hat time.

The man for this job is Sean Maguire. Instead Neill prefers Hugill as the battering ram which helps the players behind him pick up more space.
 
The problem I see is the lack of quality on the wings. Neil's possession game can't be done as effectively without the midfield triangle. To play two out and out strikers we'd need to play a 4-4-2, which is not suited as well for Neil's philosophy.

The other option is to play Maguire as the sole striker effectively would require more quality on the wings to work the ball up to him, which we don't have.

Our other option is to use Hugill as the battering ram to create space for Maguire, but that means Maguire is limited in effectiveness by his extra defensive responsibilities.

In my opinion the latter is the best option really, as it's proven to work more often than not, but we will be frustrated a few times against teams like Millwall and Barnsley.
 
I don't think we need a new striker as we have many forwards already, I think we should focus more on getting those we already have to start converting the chances we get. We had a lack of creativity for the most part against Millwall. If Harrop had tucked away his sitter we'd all be cheerful. The best option isn't always to bring in more players (especially with our limited budget), it can often be to improve what you have at your disposal. If we can get our front '4' (whoever that may be) to convert more chances than we did against Millwall, then we'll be play-off contenders for sure.
 
There isn't an obvious alternative to Hugill in his mould as a big striker, not sure that sort of lack of competition is healthy really. He'd be more consistent if he had serious competition, and at the moment it doesn't seem like Neil sees Maguire as a no.9.

We'll have to see how it goes then reassess in January which is a while off yet.
 
I feel we do. Hugill doesn't really have any competition, unless Maguire replaces him as the lone striker instead of playing behind him.
 
Do we need a striker?

I feel that we are lack some extra quality players in the squad as a whole especially in the forward areas if our current players aren’t at it. I was looking at our bench yesterday before any subs being made thinking they weren’t any one really on the beach who I could guarantee or put my money on being a real game changer in those types of games etc. Was thinking to myself that I wouldn’t of minded seeing Horgan conning on before Robinson or SM to see if his direct running might of helped us to break Millwall defence down , but also Knowing that It was unlikely that he would come on to play. I would also like to see him starting on Tuesday just to see if he can make a difference to our side, instead of the odd 10min here & there where he can’t really influence the game?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
Play Maguire up top. Did well vs Sheff W there so don't know why people all of a sudden think he shouldn't play there.
 
Play Maguire up top. Did well vs Sheff W there so don't know why people all of a sudden think he shouldn't play there.


There are occasions eg Millwall and Barnsley where our plan A is frustrated by a solid defensive display by the opposition and I feel that there's a case then to give the opposition defence something completely different to try to handle.

When Hugill is struggling to have an impact I'd like to see us switch things for the last half hour and play Maguire as the no 9 with the emphasis on giving him the best possible support in terms of the quality of passes and extra bodies around him. In other words switching from the tactic of using Hugill as the battering ram and others picking up the pieces to a very quick passing and movement style to create space and opportunities.

I'm confident though in the abilities of AN and the coaches to tackle this problem and come up with an effective solution.

Very happy with our progress so far.
 
Barks, Hugill, Harrop, Maguire that not enough in one starting 11 like?

Granted they are forward players, but 3 of them are playing behind Hugill and not as the lone striker. If Hugil gets injured, do we have a player who can be effective as the lone striker who can hold the ball up, win free kicks, bring other players into play etc. The answer is no. Playing up front on your own all season is a big ask, so hopefully we can bring in another striker in the transfer window to compete with Hugil and come into the side when he is out of form/injured.

And this is nothing against Maguire or Barks as they are class players for us, but I think they will be better playing off a Hugil type players rather then trying to play up front on their own.
 
The man for this job is Sean Maguire. Instead Neill prefers Hugill as the battering ram which helps the players behind him pick up more space.

Regardless of were Maguire plays my concern is that he will physically not last the whole season.
He's had no off season and to play a full Irish league and championship back to back is a big ask.
 
Well we signed Mavididi but he hasn't been played up front, so based on that then yes we do.

Maguire, who will at some stage need a bit of time off, and Hugill who wants away and might well go in January just isn't enough.

And neither is saying "Barkhuizen and Robinson can play up front".
 
A dumb question, perhaps. All teams need a striker.
I have just watched C5 Championship show and I see no one, bar none, that we should worry about as far as getting promotion.
Hugill is a great worker and holds the ball up well but the goals seem to be coming from all over the park and not from the players you would expect.
So far, this season has far exceeded my expectations. Long may it last.
I still feel that I would like a player who is in the right position, at the right time.
A regular goal scorer; a poacher.
I know that I am going to get slated, but I have been a supporter longer than most of you have had birthdays.
If we had a talisman that could put the ball in the net on a regular basis, this league is ours for the taking.
So there we are. Tin hat time.


transfer window is shut mate, ask again in january
 
As I've already said we have enough striking options at the moment, let's just give Neil a bit of time to organise it and find the best options.
 
Back
Top