Skip to main content

Doyle.

Doyle.

Hughill is still learning the game and yes has stepped up to the mark. Personally I think he learnt a lot from Garner. Doyle, however, is supposed to be the finished article. He's been tried and he failed. Next.

Garner was tried and tested with us after 6 months and most would have been happy to see him leave with a strike force of Beavon, Hume and Davies.
 
Garner was tried and tested with us after 6 months and most would have been happy to see him leave with a strike force of Beavon, Hume and Davies.

But Garner had a previous track record at L1 level. Doyle has no track record at this level. And it's been longer than 6 months, Doyle's been here well over 12 months now, and been injury free, and still not been able to nail down a place which says it all about his performances.
 
But Garner had a previous track record at L1 level. Doyle has no track record at this level. And it's been longer than 6 months, Doyle's been here well over 12 months now, and been injury free, and still not been able to nail down a place which says it all about his performances.

So 20 goals in half a season and then 7 for Cardiff in the step up isn't enough to take a punt on at 200k?

Doyle seems a failed experiment, but Grayson knows how crazy the market is and how we could have been left short if we didn't get another striker on the books.

Could you imagine the prices we would have been quoted if we were in desperate need of a striker and everyone knew it? That's when you end up paying 1-2 million for a player like Doyle instead of 200k.

Failed low risk experiment, that could still come good.
 
So 20 goals in half a season and then 7 for Cardiff in the step up isn't enough to take a punt on at 200k?

Doyle seems a failed experiment, but Grayson knows how crazy the market is and how we could have been left short if we didn't get another striker on the books.

Could you imagine the prices we would have been quoted if we were in desperate need of a striker and everyone knew it? That's when you end up paying 1-2 million for a player like Doyle instead of 200k.

Failed low risk experiment, that could still come good.

He wasn't worth a punt regardless of his Chesterfield goals because we'd already seen he wasn't up to it at PNE. It was also very foolish, considering it was a "punt", to give him a 3 year contract because it will be more difficult now to offload which I think we will in January if we sign a striker, because factoring in the return of May he could be 6th or 7th choice very soon.

I know we can't afford the best, proven strikers at this level, that's why I've maintained many times on here that I'd have looked at young Premier League strikers on loan instead of taking a punt on proven rubbish like Doyle. It's by no means a long term option but it's probably our best bet of finding a quality forward at a relatively low cost.
 
I know we can't afford the best, proven strikers at this level, that's why I've maintained many times on here that I'd have looked at young Premier League strikers on loan instead of taking a punt on proven rubbish like Doyle. It's by no means a long term option but it's probably our best bet of finding a quality forward at a relatively low cost.

Out of order. SG knows a whole lot more about football than you and me combined.
 
Out of order. SG knows a whole lot more about football than you and me combined.

Yeah he knows more than every single poster on this forum. Might as well not bother with the forum if you can't hold an opinion on a player just because you aren't a manager.

And I disagree that "rubbish" is out of order. Worse words than that have been used to describe his performances on here by many other posters.
 
Last edited:
He wasn't worth a punt regardless of his Chesterfield goals because we'd already seen he wasn't up to it at PNE. It was also very foolish, considering it was a "punt", to give him a 3 year contract because it will be more difficult now to offload which I think we will in January if we sign a striker, because factoring in the return of May he could be 6th or 7th choice very soon.

I know we can't afford the best, proven strikers at this level, that's why I've maintained many times on here that I'd have looked at young Premier League strikers on loan instead of taking a punt on proven rubbish like Doyle. It's by no means a long term option but it's probably our best bet of finding a quality forward at a relatively low cost.

We saw him in and out of the team in a team that was discovering it's identity in the division and not creating many clear cut chances/goals and he still managed to score as many from open play as Garner and I think he setup more as well.

He for me still has something to offer, he just needs his chance under the right circumstances which he may never get because of the form of the other strikers therefore he will be a failed experiment as he isn't given his chance.
 
He wasn't worth a punt regardless of his Chesterfield goals because we'd already seen he wasn't up to it at PNE. It was also very foolish, considering it was a "punt", to give him a 3 year contract because it will be more difficult now to offload which I think we will in January if we sign a striker, because factoring in the return of May he could be 6th or 7th choice very soon.

I know we can't afford the best, proven strikers at this level, that's why I've maintained many times on here that I'd have looked at young Premier League strikers on loan instead of taking a punt on proven rubbish like Doyle. It's by no means a long term option but it's probably our best bet of finding a quality forward at a relatively low cost.

Spot on buddy but despite knowing he's wrong Burgundy wont admit it. |So prepare yourself for a long ride of repetitive posts which reak of desperation not to be seen as getting it TOTALLY WRONG.

A calculated risk my arse, it was lunacy.
 
We saw him in and out of the team in a team that was discovering it's identity in the division and not creating many clear cut chances/goals and he still managed to score as many from open play as Garner and I think he setup more as well.

He for me still has something to offer, he just needs his chance under the right circumstances which he may never get because of the form of the other strikers therefore he will be a failed experiment as he isn't given his chance.

In response to the first paragraph, unfortunately the fact that he got as many as Garner just shows that they both weren't good enough.

As for the second part, even though I've seen a lot of him, I'm not sure what he has to offer as I don't know what type of striker he even is. What's he good at? I know what all the other strikers offer to the team and what their strengths are but Doyle I just see very little. His build up play is quite tidy sometimes, to be fair to him, but it's still nowhere near enough. IMO the guy needs to drop down a league to get games and goals again.
 
In response to the first paragraph, unfortunately the fact that he got as many as Garner just shows that they both weren't good enough.

As for the second part, even though I've seen a lot of him, I'm not sure what he has to offer as I don't know what type of striker he even is. What's he good at? I know what all the other strikers offer to the team and what their strengths are but Doyle I just see very little. His build up play is quite tidy sometimes, to be fair to him, but it's still nowhere near enough. IMO the guy needs to drop down a league to get games and goals again.

Completely agree with the last part KBD.

Doyle didn't have as much as a chance as Garner did, that was the point I was making.

Ignore Marsbar, I've never actually said Doyle would come good or be a world beater I just saw it as a low risk signing and football is all about risk. I prefer to take the approach of supporting PNE players in a shirt unless they are completely useless which Doyle isn't or show a lack of effort which I don't think Doyle does.

I think Doyles strengths are tidy link up play and fox in the box, but he is suffering from low confidence and being 4th/5th choice and when that usually happens a loan is sometimes needed.
 
Spot on buddy but despite knowing he's wrong Burgundy wont admit it. |So prepare yourself for a long ride of repetitive posts which reak of desperation not to be seen as getting it TOTALLY WRONG.

A calculated risk my arse, it was lunacy.

You have me on ignore yet can't stop talking about me, obsessed much? I would use some of your apparent professional training on yourself you mental case.
 
Doyle is shite.

At his age, I simply cannot see how he can improve to the level we want him to be at.

Get rid.
 
Back
Top