Skip to main content

Ebanks Blake

Ebanks Blake

ok so he may get fitter - but he may get injured. He may score goals - but he may not. Is he worth a chance? I'd rather take my chance with someone who is already fit, doesn't have a terrible injury record and who would hit the ground running (not wobbling). If we had two strikers already firing on all cyclinders then yes he may be worth a chance. At the moment he is wasting a squad place for me. Like others I hope he proves me wrong.

Weirdly enough teams don't tend to sell strikers firing on all cylinders. The number of times I read on here about how we need to sign a "proven goalscorer". Well we have recently signed two. Why don't the "experts" give them a chance?
 
Weirdly enough teams don't tend to sell strikers firing on all cylinders. The number of times I read on here about how we need to sign a "proven goalscorer". Well we have recently signed two. Why don't the "experts" give them a chance?
Probably for the reason you put expert in inverted commas 😉
 
Which L1 club has brought in a proven goal scorer? And I mean that has scored regularly much more recently than the two we have bought in.

Stuart Beavon was a proven goalscorer from the season before.... look how that panned out. Garner was a proven goalscorer at Carlisle and it took him a year to come good.

It's a gamble not am exact science. Revell scored goals last season and took Rotherham up via the playoffs in this league yet we say he isn't good enough.

No one has actually named a proven goalscorer we should sign. Jordan Rhodes and Diego Costa are out of our price range.
 
Which L1 club has brought in a proven goal scorer? And I mean that has scored regularly much more recently than the two we have bought in.

Stuart Beavon was a proven goalscorer from the season before.... look how that panned out. Garner was a proven goalscorer at Carlisle and it took him a year to come good.

It's a gamble not am exact science. Revell scored goals last season and took Rotherham up via the playoffs in this league yet we say he isn't good enough.

No one has actually named a proven goalscorer we should sign. Jordan Rhodes and Diego Costa are out of our price range.

Exactly, people need to realise that there are not a plethora of proven goal scorers out there not playing football or waiting to come to PNE.

SEB was probably the best least risky option when it comes to the free agent market.

Any proven league 1 goal scorers from the previous seasons are probably out of our price range.

If I was to sign a striker I would go for Walsall's Bradshaw for the simple fact that he puts his chances away. Both games against us this season he was bullied and barely got a sniff, but when he got his chance and it was only one chance in both games he took them and took them very well. Therefore considering the amount of chances we create that are not put in the onion bag I think that Bradshaw would be a very good signing, he is young as well and not out of our price range.
 
Exactly, people need to realise that there are not a plethora of proven goal scorers out there not playing football or waiting to come to PNE.

SEB was probably the best least risky option when it comes to the free agent market.

Any proven league 1 goal scorers from the previous seasons are probably out of our price range.

If I was to sign a striker I would go for Walsall's Bradshaw for the simple fact that he puts his chances away. Both games against us this season he was bullied and barely got a sniff, but when he got his chance and it was only one chance in both games he took them and took them very well. Therefore considering the amount of chances we create that are not put in the onion bag I think that Bradshaw would be a very good signing, he is young as well and not out of our price range.

I was impressed with Bradshaw he was very tricky with the ball at his feet. But he'd be no good with our long balls.
 
Weirdly enough teams don't tend to sell strikers firing on all cylinders. The number of times I read on here about how we need to sign a "proven goalscorer". Well we have recently signed two. Why don't the "experts" give them a chance?

I never said buy a striker already firing. I said if WE already had a couple then the time it will likely take for SEB to get up to speed isn't a problem. But we have Davies, Little, Hugill - none of whom will pitch in with very many goals. We seem to be largely reliant on Galli for goals at the moment. I think Beckford is a proven goalscorer and will definitely score goals - given time - and it was clear from Weds that he is getting sharper and into good positions. But how many players can we 'give time' to come good before it's March and we're behind the leading pack. SEB looks way of the pace and like i said i'd rather have that squad place given to someone who can contribute NOW not in 3 months time.
 
I never said buy a striker already firing. I said if WE already had a couple then the time it will likely take for SEB to get up to speed isn't a problem. But we have Davies, Little, Hugill - none of whom will pitch in with very many goals. We seem to be largely reliant on Galli for goals at the moment. I think Beckford is a proven goalscorer and will definitely score goals - given time - and it was clear from Weds that he is getting sharper and into good positions. But how many players can we 'give time' to come good before it's March and we're behind the leading pack. SEB looks way of the pace and like i said i'd rather have that squad place given to someone who can contribute NOW not in 3 months time.

Unfortunately because of the position we are in, our best player/leading goalscorer being injured, we have to afford players to come in and be given time.

If Garner hadn't been injured we wouldn't be having this conversation, but that's football.

You can't say the others won't pitch in with many goals because they could do from now until the end of the season.
 
If Garner hadn't been injured we wouldn't be having this conversation, but that's football.QUOTE]

If Garner hadn't been injured we would have continued with the one upfront policy that would ultimately have led us into a brick wall. As it is we have subsequently lost one in ten or eleven games and even then in a competition that is ultimately a sideshow - which doesn't mean I wouldn't enjoy a day out a Wembley as much as anyone.

Davies and Beckford looked good together on Wednesday and Gallagher showed last Saturday that if he is pushed forward into a striking position he can deliver. Yes that isn't enough though it's better than we have had at other times and with neither Ebanks-Blake nor Hugill looking like they will be ready within the next month and the return of Garner probably two months away a short-term loan of another striker would make sense.

Such a signing plus a combatitive central midfielder would set us up for the rest of the season. SG has indicated that he wants to make signings and hopefully those are the type of players he has in mind and can bring in. The important thing now is to ensure that there is no hangover from Wednesday - if we can get something from the game tomorrow then we will be back on track, though frankly in terms of our league campaign we haven't actually been knocked off it.
 
If Garner hadn't been injured we would have continued with the one upfront policy that would ultimately have led us into a brick wall. As it is we have subsequently lost one in ten or eleven games and even then in a competition that is ultimately a sideshow - which doesn't mean I wouldn't enjoy a day out a Wembley as much as anyone.

Davies and Beckford looked good together on Wednesday and Gallagher showed last Saturday that if he is pushed forward into a striking position he can deliver. Yes that isn't enough though it's better than we have had at other times and with neither Ebanks-Blake nor Hugill looking like they will be ready within the next month and the return of Garner probably two months away a short-term loan of another striker would make sense.

Such a signing plus a combatitive central midfielder would set us up for the rest of the season. SG has indicated that he wants to make signings and hopefully those are the type of players he has in mind and can bring in. The important thing now is to ensure that there is no hangover from Wednesday - if we can get something from the game tomorrow then we will be back on track, though frankly in terms of our league campaign we haven't actually been knocked off it.

Gallagher didn't play upfront against Norwich, he played in midfield behind the frontman.

The 1 upfront policy would not have led us into a brick wall because it got us to where we were before Garner got injured, it was a policy that WAS working as the league position and cup runs proved.

We have changed to 2 upfront and there hasn't been a huge upturn in goals scored as was predicted.

Cue the manager saying there is nobody better out there and we will make do with what we have!!!

What if that is the case?
 
Gallagher didn't play upfront against Norwich, he played in midfield behind the frontman.

The 1 upfront policy would not have led us into a brick wall because it got us to where we were before Garner got injured, it was a policy that WAS working as the league position and cup runs proved.

We have changed to 2 upfront and there hasn't been a huge upturn in goals scored as was predicted.



What if that is the case?

Then I think we will struggle to get promotion.
 
Gallagher didn't play upfront against Norwich, he played in midfield behind the frontman.

The 1 upfront policy would not have led us into a brick wall because it got us to where we were before Garner got injured, it was a policy that WAS working as the league position and cup runs proved.

We have changed to 2 upfront and there hasn't been a huge upturn in goals scored as was predicted.

What if that is the case?

Then I think we will struggle to get promotion.

Last 6 league games (all without Garner). W4 D2 L0.

What's with all the negativity?
 
OK let's just carry on as we are then! Not scoring many goals and scraping results along the way, end up in the playoffs and get beaten by one of the 3 teams currently above us shall we??
 
OK let's just carry on as we are then! Not scoring many goals and scraping results along the way, end up in the playoffs and get beaten by one of the 3 teams currently above us shall we??

Just because we don't score many goals doesn't mean we are scraping results.

MK Dons at home we battered them and should have walked away with 3 points.

Stuckmann has hardly had saves to make because our defence has been that good, we may be winning games by a goal or two but we are definitely not struggling to hold onto our winning position.
 
Back
Top