Skip to main content

Eoin Doyle

Eoin Doyle

Joined
Aug 22, 2004
Messages
3,052
A number on here don't rate him and think he should be sent back etc. Personally I don't think he's done a lot wrong plus think theres more to come from him and worth keeping hold of. Scored 25 in half a season in League 1 plus scored 5 in 11 starts in the Championship. Watching a couple of highlights of Cardiff games on YouTube this morning (yes i'm that bored) he looks a good all round player, good feet and more mobile than what I've seen so far with us. Hearing from Cardiff fans on twitter he only left because he had a fall out with Slade during pre season and they would happily have him back.
Think his longest run of starts this season was 7 games. Is that long enough to judge him? Now Keane has left I hope he gets and more importantly takes his chance
 
He was brilliant in league one and really stood out in our first game against Chesterfield last season.
Like you I was really pleased when we signed him, especially as he would be linking up with Johnson again who assisted in many of his goals.
However he has disappointed. He does not seem to be able to get into the game and he certainly does not receive the same service from Johnson. I still hope that he will come good as the determination and effort are there but he needs to learn how to get the better of the better defenders in the championship.
 
A number on here don't rate him and think he should be sent back etc. Personally I don't think he's done a lot wrong plus think theres more to come from him and worth keeping hold of. Scored 25 in half a season in League 1 plus scored 5 in 11 starts in the Championship. Watching a couple of highlights of Cardiff games on YouTube this morning (yes i'm that bored) he looks a good all round player, good feet and more mobile than what I've seen so far with us. Hearing from Cardiff fans on twitter he only left because he had a fall out with Slade during pre season and they would happily have him back.
Think his longest run of starts this season was 7 games. Is that long enough to judge him? Now Keane has left I hope he gets and more importantly takes his chance

I think you are maybe kidding yourself here Graham. Get ready to put your tin hat on, mate.
 
I think you are maybe kidding yourself here Graham. Get ready to put your tin hat on, mate.
He's a player SG tried to sign permantly twice last year. Was reported we bid £800k for him in August that Cardiff turned down. Just watched a couple of Cardiff match highlights to see how he looked at this level. Not saying he's defo gonna do the business for us but theres been plenty of players down the years that have slow starts and turned out to be good players. Thinking Garner, Beckford and Vermijl as recent examples
 
He should be given an extended run, surely his goal return cant be any worse than keane given the chance and if he gets on a run and knocks in a few, could be all shouting his name by march !!!!
 
Vermaji was written off now hes very important to the team. Somewhere along the line we need to solve our goalscoring problem. Why not Doyle?
 
I bet Doyle is absolutely delighted that Keane has departed. With the resurgence of a more rounded, smarter Garner, Doyle's eye for goal might be better served. Like most strikers, they need time to get used to the movements of their team mates. Let's hope Grayson and his team can inspire another forward to improve and maximise their impact.
 
Just what are his strengths ? He's been anonymous in a lot of the games that he has played. I'm glad it turned out as just a loan and we didn't spend close to a million quid on him. Wouldn't be bothered if he went back.

Hope I'm proven wrong about him but as it stands he seems to be a bit of a half a season wonder, in the division below.
 
Just what are his strengths ? He's been anonymous in a lot of the games that he has played. I'm glad it turned out as just a loan and we didn't spend close to a million quid on him. Wouldn't be bothered if he went back.

Hope I'm proven wrong about him but as it stands he seems to be a bit of a half a season wonder, in the division below.

All managers see something good in a player but all managers make poor signings on occasion. Except for Stevie May who I reckon was a mistake that Grayson must surely be privately admitting, Grayson's scouting is usually on the mark and he is a good coach in that he brings out the best in players.
Let's hope Doyle finds his feet. He just looks pedestrian to me, and no great threat to defenders. Stuart Beavon looked better than him.
 
I am in the camp of thinking he isn't good enough but until we can bring someone in I think we should give him a run of games, what have we got to lose at this point? We have 4 games before we hit the halfway point of January, start him and see if he can turn it around.
 
Difficult one. Doyle has basically proved a misfire so far - he tries but to little effect and it may be that he is one of those players who looks like Championship material providing he is not actually in the Championship. Is there an option to return him halfway through his loan and if so do we exercise it even though that might temporarily at least leave us with just two strikers or do we give him another chance and risk being left with a passenger using up a wage for the rest of the season? These are the decisions SG is paid to make. The first option would presumably give us more leeway to bring in someone else, the second would help maintain some consistency in the squad. Either way presuming Keane goes back to Man Utd I think I would give Hugill the nod tomorrow - he at least deserves the chance that both Doyle and Keane have been given this season.
 
People were calling Vermijl and Reach not to long ago, both seem to have settled in now.

You can't dismiss a player on a handful of games. Let's hope he takes the opportunity.
 
I've always believed that football is played as much in the head as with the feet. Look how poor Garner was before Grayson got in his head and showed that he believed in him. Probably our 4th choice striker.

Think what has been going on in Doyle's head in the past 3 months, lucky to get a place on the subs bench. He has ability, his prior record shows that. Grayson needs to get inside his head now and get his self belief back up. A run of 4 or 5 games and he could start firing.
 
I'm not his biggest fan and have said so in the past, but here's one thing.....If we have to go with Doyle over the next few games, all I will say is that the fans need to support him. I am just as guilty as anyone of this, but I have noticed that as soon as Doyle gets on, the fans are at him. At Huddersfield all he had to do was try to win a high ball or fail to reach a pass that was nowhere near him and many PNE fans (and I said many, not all) were at him like a pack of baying wolves. Did anyone else notice this? This surely can't help his game.
 
I'd prefer Doyle over Hugill all day long, though whenever I saw Doyle during his last run in the team (Brighton, QPR, Bolton on Sky, maybe another one) the main problem for me was he "played his own game", and was very isolated from Garner rather than being a strike partner, running into dead-ends a lot as a result - and of course, we didn't score in those games either (though Doyle did get the winner v Forest during that run).

I hope Doyle can play closer to Garner this time, and look to link play up more, rather than plough his own furrow.
 
I'd prefer Doyle over Hugill all day long, though whenever I saw Doyle during his last run in the team (Brighton, QPR, Bolton on Sky, maybe another one) the main problem for me was he "played his own game", and was very isolated from Garner rather than being a strike partner, running into dead-ends a lot as a result - and of course, we didn't score in those games either (though Doyle did get the winner v Forest during that run).

I hope Doyle can play closer to Garner this time, and look to link play up more, rather than plough his own furrow.
You are so right with these comments. No, matter how good a player has been with previous club, if he dose not fit the system he will look bad. That's were time and good management come in.
 
If any of our other strikers (besides Garner) are given the same chance that was afforded to Garner, then there's a high probability that all of them could find their feet and start scoring. Garner has been played game in, game out this season, even when he hasn't been playing well. That has given him the opportunity to get match fit and up to speed.

One or two games, or 30 minutes here and there is never going to be enough for any player to get going properly, or show what they can do, especially a striker. And dare I say it, we shouldn't be judging or dismissing any player until they have had an extend run in the team and a chance to get match fit and up to speed.

To expect a striker to go from training and warming the bench to almost immediately start scoring and impacting the game is a tad unfair. Even your world class strikers like Aguero struggle to do that without a run of games.

They need a run of games and a fair chance to get match fit and prove themselves.
 
Best finisher in our squad. Give him a solid run of games with good service to his feet and he will score goals.
 
Back
Top