Obviously he's no Beckford and this is at a higher level, but Beckford was pish for 3/4 months, Garner was toilet for a lot longer than that in his first year. hopefully he can use the goal as a confidence boost going forward
Eoin Doyle
- Joined
- May 8, 2004
- Messages
- 19,187
I
In answer to your question I'd return Doyle and try to sign highly rated Uruguayian Leandro Rodriguez on a deal until Beckford is fit. Everton signed him recently after he scored tons in South America. He's not featured for them but is meant to be pretty big time. I think he's 21 too rather than a teeny bopper so he needs to be playing.
Doyle might be all we can afford but it would be rude not to try and make an assault for the top 6 now we are 10 points away from that and 10 points away from the drop. Time for trev to reward Grayson's hard work.
I think the likes of Doyle are the best we can afford at the moment, unless we can unearth a real gem from the lower leagues, which given our previous scouting history is very unlikely, or Trev dips his hand in his pocket and spends a couple of million, which given our previous buying history, is very unlikely. Who would you suggest we go in for, Durutti?
Doyle hasn't set the world alight since arriving here, of course, but his confidence looks to be restoring and he seems to be finding his feet. Him and Johnson absolutely tore us apart for Chesterfield last season, both of whom have struggled at different points this season though I'm sure both will play their part in keeping us up come the end of the season. I'd rather encourage a player like Doyle than slate him.
In answer to your question I'd return Doyle and try to sign highly rated Uruguayian Leandro Rodriguez on a deal until Beckford is fit. Everton signed him recently after he scored tons in South America. He's not featured for them but is meant to be pretty big time. I think he's 21 too rather than a teeny bopper so he needs to be playing.
Doyle might be all we can afford but it would be rude not to try and make an assault for the top 6 now we are 10 points away from that and 10 points away from the drop. Time for trev to reward Grayson's hard work.
I
In answer to your question I'd return Doyle and try to sign highly rated Uruguayian Leandro Rodriguez on a deal until Beckford is fit. Everton signed him recently after he scored tons in South America. He's not featured for them but is meant to be pretty big time. I think he's 21 too rather than a teeny bopper so he needs to be playing.
Doyle might be all we can afford but it would be rude not to try and make an assault for the top 6 now we are 10 points away from that and 10 points away from the drop. Time for trev to reward Grayson's hard work.
He scored about 20 goals in 75 games. Not a bad record, granted, but what makes you think he'd be the answer to our problems?
- Joined
- May 8, 2004
- Messages
- 19,187
He scored about 20 goals in 75 games. Not a bad record, granted, but what makes you think he'd be the answer to our problems?
Experience. Most of the prem loanees have ability but are too raw for this level. This boy has been a proper player back home rather than a big club reserve.. I said Andy Carroll would be a top flight player when he was here after getting game time whereas everyone else thought he was gash. he also looks like Maradonna on YouTube. ;-)
- Joined
- May 8, 2004
- Messages
- 19,187
Lets get it understood.
WE CANNOT RETURN ANY PLAYER THAT WEVE COMMITED OURSELVES TO A SEASON LONG DEAL WITH!!!
Fair enough, there's no obligation to play him though.
- Joined
- Jan 11, 2005
- Messages
- 111,058
aye, I suppose it makes sense not to play a striker who has actually scored, a striker whos wages we are paying. Definitely sensible is that one!Fair enough, there's no obligation to play him though.
Lets get it understood.
WE CANNOT RETURN ANY PLAYER THAT WEVE COMMITED OURSELVES TO A SEASON LONG DEAL WITH!!!
Bristol City signed Callum Robinson on a season long loan, and they just have cancelled the loan. How does that work?
- Joined
- Jan 11, 2005
- Messages
- 111,058
Might I suggest that could be for disciplinary reasons?Bristol City signed Callum Robinson on a season long loan, and they just have cancelled the loan. How does that work?
http://www.bristolpost.co.uk/BRISTO...inson-filmed/story-28231047-detail/story.html
Might I suggest that could be for disciplinary reasons?
http://www.bristolpost.co.uk/BRISTO...inson-filmed/story-28231047-detail/story.html
Who knows. He hasn't started many games, that's for sure. Wouldn't be surprised if he ended up back here.
- Joined
- Aug 23, 2015
- Messages
- 4,634
I
In answer to your question I'd return Doyle and try to sign highly rated Uruguayian Leandro Rodriguez on a deal until Beckford is fit. Everton signed him recently after he scored tons in South America. He's not featured for them but is meant to be pretty big time. I think he's 21 too rather than a teeny bopper so he needs to be playing.
Doyle might be all we can afford but it would be rude not to try and make an assault for the top 6 now we are 10 points away from that and 10 points away from the drop. Time for trev to reward Grayson's hard work.
A good suggestion, and as Nishtar36 points out above, he has a decent if not immaculate scoring record. I haven't seen him play and don't know what the standard of football is like in the Uruguayan Primera Division in comparison to the Championship and given he's never played in England it would be a gamble.
Conversely, I have a lot more time for Doyle than say, Hugill as Doyle has proved he can do the business in English professional football (albeit in League One- 25 goals in 33) and looks to be a nice footballer. I don't think Doyle is far away from recapturing his form. Having said that I think the forward line does need adding to in January. Maybe loan Hugill out to free up some space.
- Joined
- Aug 23, 2015
- Messages
- 4,634
Lets get it understood.
WE CANNOT RETURN ANY PLAYER THAT WEVE COMMITED OURSELVES TO A SEASON LONG DEAL WITH!!!
In that case, play him and back him. Doyle has proved he can do the business in professional football before and is the same nimble player who put 3 past us last season, even if he's short of confidence at the moment.
aye, I suppose it makes sense not to play a striker who has actually scored, a striker whos wages we are paying. Definitely sensible is that one!
Absolutely. Baring any quality new signings to partner Garner he's the best we've got.
We were equal leading scorers in the Championship today, we scored 2 goals.
Doyle was one of very few players who scored today, no one scored more than one.
It's a very tight low scoring league.
Get a Fukin life some of you bozzos, you live in cloud cuckoo land.
Doyle was one of very few players who scored today, no one scored more than one.
It's a very tight low scoring league.
Get a Fukin life some of you bozzos, you live in cloud cuckoo land.
Was unlucky to not score the diving header. Cannot remember a home game in the last two years where we have scored like that in front of the AK and am struggling to remember any of our strikers getting into that position on the edge of the six yard box recently. The early cross from Cunningham was excellent.
Garners and djs reaction to Doyles goal says a lot about how he fits with the squad compared to those who would rather be elsewhere.
Garners and djs reaction to Doyles goal says a lot about how he fits with the squad compared to those who would rather be elsewhere.
In that case, play him and back him. Doyle has proved he can do the business in professional football before and is the same nimble player who put 3 past us last season, even if he's short of confidence at the moment.
Absolutely. Baring any quality new signings to partner Garner he's the best we've got.
We were saying this yesterday. He needs a run in the team to get his confidence up. At the moment we don't have a great deal of choice though SG surely will be bringing someone in.
an inference every time he's slagged off for being no good. Give him time.Who said he should be 'scoring for fun?'
Back in the side, scored a goal and could have had a second but for a good save.
Looked to be lacking sharpness but that should come with games.
Whether he can cut the mustard at this level , time will tell, to early to judge at the moment.
Patience required.
Looked to be lacking sharpness but that should come with games.
Whether he can cut the mustard at this level , time will tell, to early to judge at the moment.
Patience required.
Doyle has looked feeble a lot of the time but has occasionally shown flashes of quality. What seems evident is that he is a penalty box player who is more or less useless when asked to play wide or drop back. He would probably be ineffective as a partner for Beckford but does seem to have the knack of finding a bit of space in an otherwise crowded goalmouth. He would play well with a big centre forward.
Doyle has looked feeble a lot of the time but has occasionally shown flashes of quality. What seems evident is that he is a penalty box player who is more or less useless when asked to play wide or drop back. He would probably be ineffective as a partner for Beckford but does seem to have the knack of finding a bit of space in an otherwise crowded goalmouth. He would play well with a big centre forward.
I do think he could forge a very good partnership with Garner who runs all over the place up front to win the ball and playing Doyle purely as an out and out striker will definitely be his best position. Garner works his socks off every single game whether he is playing well or not and would definitely be the perfect partner for Doyle as was Garner with Beckford 2nd half of last season. This is why in my mind a right winger is absolutely imperative to play a more adventurous 4-4-2 at home which would fit the Doyle/Garner partnership.
an inference every time he's slagged off for being no good. Give him time.
I made my comment based on how he performed yesterday. But he scored so hopefully will push on.