Skip to main content

Eoin doyle

Eoin doyle

Doyle was at his best when at Chesterfield when he was played as a striker, in the box, poaching and feeding off scraps.

He will always do a job for the team, even on the right as per yesterday but until we play the lad up front for a concentrated period of time will we know if he is up to the mark.

It would be like playing DJ as a holding midfielder, we wouldnt be playing to his strengths.

Give the lad a break, I was much more impressed with his reaction to the Sheff Wed debarcle than Beckfords
 
What does this guy even offer ,he lacks everything to be a championship striker ,he is league . Lone at best I just think Grayson made a big mistake signing him but won't admit it

He won't admit it? Firstly, he may well disagree with you.

Secondly, what do you expect him to do? Call a press conference to announce to the world he's made a mistake?
Or would you prefer him to give you a call, or perhaps drive round to your house with a bunch of flowers and beg forgiveness?
Please engage brain before posting?
 
Last edited:
Hopefully Barkhuizen and Horgan joining means we won't see Doyle on the right hand side again.

Another part of Doyle's problem is that we often play just 1 out and out striker, and he isn't the type of striker to play the lone role as that role requires more of a 'focal point', 'physical presence' striker such as Hugill or, my preferred choice, Makienok.

If we add another striker or two in the upcoming window he may have to move on in order to play games and good luck to him if that's the case, I just don't see it working out for him at this club and/or this level for numerous reasons.

In the Wednesday game Doyle might have been able to get on the end of Makienoks flick ons which tended to fall into no mans land or Sheffield defenders. Worth a try.
 
Doyle was at his best when at Chesterfield when he was played as a striker, in the box, poaching and feeding off scraps.

He will always do a job for the team, even on the right as per yesterday but until we play the lad up front for a concentrated period of time will we know if he is up to the mark.

It would be like playing DJ as a holding midfielder, we wouldnt be playing to his strengths.

Give the lad a break, I was much more impressed with his reaction to the Sheff Wed debarcle than Beckfords


What was Doyles response? I didn't really see anything come out from him when it happened.
 
What was Doyles response? I didn't really see anything come out from him when it happened.

I think he means his 'on pitch' response...
Which I agree was remarkably better than Beckford's childish response.
Beckford wrote a cheesy instagram post with a quote - whoopie doo! And then preceeded to get sent off a few minutes into his return from suspension.

The likely case is that Doyle hasn't given a social media response after the Sheff Weds game because he'll have felt he stood his ground & didn't do too much wrong.
From the highlights, I don't really know how you could send Doyle off for his part in it.
 
The start up of this thread & the OP is really pathetic & it's what does my head in with forums/message boards.
Any tithead can just start spouting bollocks about a player, on a game he most likely didn't attend.
To those that did attend, it seems pretty obvious that Doyle put a shift in, playing in an unsuited position.
He should be getting credit for this, not abuse.

I believe Doyle will score goals if he is played as an out & out striker who feeds of knock downs & scraps (similar sort of striker to Danny Graham).
 
Our forward line today would've been more suited to a League 1 fixture.

Doyle's not good enough and shouldn't have been signed permanently but playing him on the wing doesn't help.

A strikeforce of Doyle and Hugill would never have taken us out of League One. Ridiculous either are leading the line for us a division higher.
 
Yeah I agree about the on pitch response it was a bit ridiculous wasn't it. The cheesy instagram I thought was an alright response but to then go and do the same thing again was just a real kick in the teeth to all the fans who bought it. I don't believe he did much wrong at all it seems Beckford has some underlying anger issues he needs to deal with.

But I think Doyle needs to be given a run in the team in the correct position to get his confidence back he played well for Cardiff on his step up so there's no reason he can't score in this league he just needs time in the correct position with someone like Mak he can poach goals from.
 
I believe Doyle will score goals if he is played as an out & out striker who feeds of knock downs & scraps.

Which is what I have been saying for months now.

In practice though that would mean that when we play that 4.3.3 with, say, Robinson and McGeady wide of a single central striker Doyle would not be of any use because he lacks the physical presence to play that role. In that case Makienok, Hugill or just maybe Beckford would fit the bill.

Using Doyle with Makienok or Hugill as a conventional strike partnership would, though, be an option but in that case someone else would have to give way.

I suspect once he is fit the same will be the case with May.
 
A strikeforce of Doyle and Hugill would never have taken us out of League One. Ridiculous either are leading the line for us a division higher.

Whilst Garner wasn't amazing in this division, I'd have him and Beckford up top again over Doyle and Hugill every time. It's just a shame that one was sold, one is crocked/lost his head and we've been left with 2nd rate strikers getting a lot of game time because we haven't replaced either JG or JB.

I do like Makienok though and feel he would be even better with a proper partner.
 
Whilst Garner wasn't amazing in this division, I'd have him and Beckford up top again over Doyle and Hugill every time. It's just a shame that one was sold, one is crocked/lost his head and we've been left with 2nd rate strikers getting a lot of game time because we haven't replaced either JG or JB.

I do like Makienok though and feel he would be even better with a proper partner.
agreed it seems a few on here think Doyle is a good player lol maybe at league one level ,there was a reason Cardiff got rid and it was Doyle is shite and we took him on loan and he did not do much to impress but we still signed him on a 3 year deal ,we to get rid of both hugill and Doyle but we won't .its a shame stevie may is not fully fit
 
Does anybody honestly believe that a strike force of Doyle, Hugill or Doyle and Hugill is of the ability to get us into the Top 6?

Be honest with your answers lads and lasses.

You know my opinions on Doyle.

Hugill impressed me at the tail end of last season and he carried it over into the first 3 months of this season but since November, he has been way way off the pace. I actually think a loan move to L1 for the rest of the season would be of benefit to both himself and PNE.

That would leave us with the following...

Big Mak
Beckford
May (when fully fit)
Horgan (I believe his pace centrally could be used ala Vardy off the last defender)
Doyle
Robinson (emergencies)

We still require one decent striker. Be it a Prem Loan or from a cheap foreign league in Europe, as 2 examples, we urgently need one to put the multitude of missed chances away. We are 6 points away from the POs which HAVE to be our aim as we most certainly are not going down. We keep having 6th spot within our grasp the past 6 weeks and we keep missing out due to this ongoing issue.

We are at a crossroads with the striking dept.
 
Doyle has shown flashes of ability at this level just enough times to give the impression that he might be able to deliver with some consistency but not enough times to be convincing. If we did bring another striker in on loan then it would probably be best to send Doyle out to get some regular game time elsewhere since his opportunities here then would probably be minimal. I still think that if he gets his head together Beckford could give us what we need over the rest of this season.
 
A strikeforce of Doyle and Hugill would never have taken us out of League One. Ridiculous either are leading the line for us a division higher.

It's an odd one and I don't disagree really but Doyle got 21 goals in 26 league one games the season we got promoted so even if he slowed down his rate he'd have been on for 35 goals in a season. Some going.

That same season Garner got 26 and I'd back Hugill to have beaten Davies 1.
 
Amongst all our strikers each of them has their own unique strength, but no we dont have a clinial 15+ goal a season striker currently on our books.

Having said that, we have 3-4 strikers who can chip in with goals. Added to our attacking midfield options I dont think a striker is a neccessity, unless we can offload one of the current average ones.

When Bailey Wright leaves, I'd deem a centre half more important as our defence hasnt been of the same quality as last year. Boyle may be good, but it'll take him probably the rest of the season to adapt (provided he can get on the team in the first place)
 
But what sort? One who can play off a targetman or one who can lead the line in that semi lone striker role that Makienok and Hugill often get asked to play?

To play off the target man for me.

I've seen enough from Makienok to think he can do a decent enough job in the lone striker / target man role. Hugill divides opinion, for me he's a back up and lets face it if Beckford had been fit and Doyle hadn't been pretty useless so far that's all he would have been this season.
 
It's an odd one and I don't disagree really but Doyle got 21 goals in 26 league one games the season we got promoted so even if he slowed down his rate he'd have been on for 35 goals in a season. Some going.

That same season Garner got 26 and I'd back Hugill to have beaten Davies 1.

It was the same with Beavon though, some teams are just suited to some players I think.

He clearly has ability, whether it's enough for a Championship team I'm not sure. It'd be typical of North End to loan/sell Doyle and he'd score bucket loads!
 
Back
Top