Skip to main content

Eoin doyle

Eoin doyle

Doyle would certainly have converted several of the chances missed by Hugill
My general impression is that Doyle often needs 2 or 3 bites at the cherry before a chance goes in. If he's in position to score, his first effort is often scuffed or blocked or saved, then (if the chance hasn't gone) he might follow up but that's also often scuffed or blocked or saved, then (if the chance still hasn't gone) he might finally put it away - or he might not.

His goals always seem a bit chatty, and I certainly wouldn't call him a clinical finisher.

When Doyle was given a 3-year deal, Garner was our first-choice striker with Beckford (when fit) our second choice.

Doyle was signed as an upgrade to the outgoing Andy Little, and I think he was expected to fulfil the same squad role, providing cover for Garner, and as such, a 3-year deal wasn't a bad idea.

But then Garner was sold and now that Beckford is rarely available, we suddenly face the prospect of Doyle being almost first-choice.

I don't think this was envisioned when he was signed, but it's where we are.
 
My general impression is that Doyle often needs 2 or 3 bites at the cherry before a chance goes in. If he's in position to score, his first effort is often scuffed or blocked or saved, then (if the chance hasn't gone) he might follow up but that's also often scuffed or blocked or saved, then (if the chance still hasn't gone) he might finally put it away - or he might not.

His goals always seem a bit chatty, and I certainly wouldn't call him a clinical finisher.

When Doyle was given a 3-year deal, Garner was our first-choice striker with Beckford (when fit) our second choice.

Doyle was signed as an upgrade to the outgoing Andy Little, and I think he was expected to fulfil the same squad role, providing cover for Garner, and as such, a 3-year deal wasn't a bad idea.

But then Garner was sold and now that Beckford is rarely available, we suddenly face the prospect of Doyle being almost first-choice.

I don't think this was envisioned when he was signed, but it's where we are.

Agree with all of this. It's a myth that he's a good finisher at this level.

As others and yourself have alluded to in this thread, the problem is we haven't replaced Garner and Beckford. Garner was sold without a replacement, and Beckford probably does need replacing as he is hardly ever available and will most likely be off in the summer.

So without those two, we've ended up seeing players like Doyle and Hugill, strikers who are no more than squad player calibre, very close to the first team, even though they probably wouldn't have got into our league 1 side.

Makienok has looked quite good in recent weeks. He is a handful of a player with good hold up play who shows an eye for goal every now and then. Being the type of player he is, however, he is unlikely to ever be prolific. I think he is the type of striker who could make the striker next to him prolific though with all his dirty work and flick ons etc. He needs a proper partner though. Not a wide player like Callum Robinson or squad players i.e. Doyle.

As I said on another thread recently, our recruitment of strikers in the coming windows will define our top 6 chances in the next few seasons.
 
Last edited:
Agree with all of this. It's a myth that he's a good finisher at this level.

As others and yourself have alluded to in this thread, the problem is we haven't replaced Garner and Beckford. Garner was sold without a replacement, and Beckford probably does need replacing as he is hardly ever available and will most likely be off in the summer.

So without those two, we've ended up seeing players like Doyle and Hugill, strikers who are no more than squad player calibre, very close to the first team, even though they probably wouldn't have got into our league 1 side.

Makienok has looked quite good in recent weeks. He is a handful of a player with good hold up play who shows an eye for goal every now and then. Being the type of player he is, however, he is unlikely to ever be prolific. I think he is the type of striker who could make the striker next to him prolific though with all his dirty work and flick ons etc. He needs a proper partner though. Not a wide player like Callum Robinson or squad players i.e. Doyle.

As I said on another thread recently, our recruitment of strikers in the coming windows will define our top 6 chances in the next few seasons.

A good finisher is a good finisher, regardless of level. Being in a different division doesn't affect someone's ability to finish.
 
A good finisher is a good finisher, regardless of level. Being in a different division doesn't affect someone's ability to finish.

Absolutely.

The defending at this level is better so creating the openings is not quite so easy but, as Doyle showed with his clinical strike at Hillsborough, a player's ability to finish isn't affected.

I'm sure he'll come good just given a fair chance.

Watched highlights of the Burton match which just confirmed what I saw at the match itself that he worked his socks off, covered so much ground, defended excellently, found good space and made some superb passes. All while playing out of his favoured position. A great asset to us I'd say.
 
A good finisher is a good finisher, regardless of level. Being in a different division doesn't affect someone's ability to finish.

Disagree. You can appear to be a good finisher at the level below as there is more time and space and more chances, but when you step up a league and there are less chances you have to be more clinical and Doyle most certainly hasn't been.
 
Disagree. You can appear to be a good finisher at the level below as there is more time and space and more chances, but when you step up a league and there are less chances you have to be more clinical and Doyle most certainly hasn't been.
I agree with that.

A good finisher is a good finisher regardless of level, only when they're dropping down a level - not if they're stepping up a level.

Otherwise, every team in our league would just sign proven 20-goal strikers from League 2 and sit back and enjoy the goalfest.
 
I agree with that.

A good finisher is a good finisher regardless of level, only when they're dropping down a level - not if they're stepping up a level.

Otherwise, every team in our league would just sign proven 20-goal strikers from League 2 and sit back and enjoy the goalfest.


Either way, if you want the best out of a striker then you play to his strengths..... Doyles a sniffer so you play him up front in a twosome.....If you don't do that ( and he fails ) then it was utterly pointless signing him.
 
Either way, if you want the best out of a striker then you play to his strengths..... Doyles a sniffer so you play him up front in a twosome.....If you don't do that ( and he fails ) then it was utterly pointless signing him.

And he cannot be faulted for a low goal tally if he's not played in that role but utilised in deeper and wider positions. In which case, as on Monday, he should be judged on his effectiveness in that role rather than criticised for not scoring often enough.

He might not be good enough for a team challenging for promotion from the Championship but he might be. None of us know that really though because he hasn't had a long enough run in the team in his favoured position with the creative players we now have as well as an effective target man (Makienok)

If our modest budget prevents us splashing out on an expensive proven striker in the January window then maybe sooner or later that scenario might occur.
 
doyle is the best striker we have, silly that he isnt being used correctly. hoping with beckford imploding and hugil missing everything he gets more of a chance.

and if grayson isn't going to give him that chance then he needs to clear house and ship all 4 of them out and get better in
 
And he cannot be faulted for a low goal tally if he's not played in that role but utilised in deeper and wider positions. In which case, as on Monday, he should be judged on his effectiveness in that role rather than criticised for not scoring often enough.

He might not be good enough for a team challenging for promotion from the Championship but he might be. None of us know that really though because he hasn't had a long enough run in the team in his favoured position with the creative players we now have as well as an effective target man (Makienok)

If our modest budget prevents us splashing out on an expensive proven striker in the January window then maybe sooner or later that scenario might occur.
Maybe it wasn't a long enough run, but he did start up front early in the season, when we had our terrible start, losing 6 out of 8 league games.

He started 5 of those 8 games, 4 were defeats. He played 40 minutes as a sub in one other (Ipswich away), also a defeat. He didn't score in any of them, but he did miss one or two sitters. I didn't see any evidence of clinical finishing - and he obviously hasn't played much since Brentford away.

On the plus side, he did score a couple in the early league cup games against L1/L2 opposition - which perhaps illustrates the point.
 
Maybe it wasn't a long enough run, but he did start up front early in the season, when we had our terrible start, losing 6 out of 8 league games.

He started 5 of those 8 games, 4 were defeats. He played 40 minutes as a sub in one other (Ipswich away), also a defeat. He didn't score in any of them, but he did miss one or two sitters. I didn't see any evidence of clinical finishing - and he obviously hasn't played much since Brentford away.

On the plus side, he did score a couple in the early league cup games against L1/L2 opposition - which perhaps illustrates the point.

Struggling in a team full of players who are pretty much all under-performing and lacking cohesion and confidence isn't very surprising.

considering our current options in the striking department I'd like to see him given a chance in his preferred goal poacher role alongside Makienok. With the confidence and creativity we now have in the team I'm sure he'd do well given a decent run. And it would at least give everyone a fair chance to judge him properly.
 
Apologies if this has already been mentioned, but looking at the Burton highlights Doyle was involved in most of the good stuff we played. Sign of an effective player?
 
Struggling in a team full of players who are pretty much all under-performing and lacking cohesion and confidence isn't very surprising.

considering our current options in the striking department I'd like to see him given a chance in his preferred goal poacher role alongside Makienok. With the confidence and creativity we now have in the team I'm sure he'd do well given a decent run. And it would at least give everyone a fair chance to judge him properly.

Apologies if this has already been mentioned, but looking at the Burton highlights Doyle was involved in most of the good stuff we played. Sign of an effective player?

Well said lads.

Don't let that get in the way of giving him a right slagging.

Made me laugh.
 
He's not been a regular starter like he was at Chesterfield for 2 years now, being in and out of a team and shipped out on loan can do a lot to a players confidence that was probably Graysons thinking when he decided to sign him.

I wouldn't have spent the extra on Bradshaw even if he was 4 years younger because I don't see him as having the traits to be a regular goal scorer in this division, for me he would be a younger and more expensive buy as Doyle is.

Our level in the Championship is still dictated by our finances and club attractiveness when it comes to transfers, once our income hopefully starts to increase or TH releases the purse strings a little bit and we are firmly seen as an established hopefully play off challenging side then signings like Doyle and Bradshaw will not be our level.

I'd still have rather have signed Bradshaw then Doyle. Not saying Bradshaw is the quality goalscorer we need, but think he's a better player and has time to improve. He's scored the same as Doyle did in whole of last season already. Long term I think Bradshaw would be better value for money. Higher fee, but lower wage and also likely to have a sell on fee at a later date.
 
I don't like Doyle as a player but then I don't particularly like any of our strikers with the exception of Robinson who in turn frustrates me. Maybe I'm a bad judge of goalscorer- I much preferred Stuart Beavon to Joe Garner ! I enjoy watching our midfield and defence but somehow it all seems to fall apart in the striking department.
 
I'd still have rather have signed Bradshaw then Doyle. Not saying Bradshaw is the quality goalscorer we need, but think he's a better player and has time to improve. He's scored the same as Doyle did in whole of last season already. Long term I think Bradshaw would be better value for money. Higher fee, but lower wage and also likely to have a sell on fee at a later date.

You make a very good point to be fair Norky.
 
Back
Top