Skip to main content

Experience

Experience

Bobbage

It's off, isn't it.
Joined
Apr 6, 2012
Messages
31,279
Lots of threads on here recently about us needing a creative midfielder (or slating the ones we have) or needing a second goalscorer (or slating the ones we have....) or criticising Grayson's tactical sitting back on a lead. Not sure how you can avoid sitting back when the opposition have a free kick on the halfway line being taken by the goalkeeper though.

The issues we have at the moment don't lie in any of these areas in my opinion. I'll get my tin hat on here, but I feel the problems lie with the defence and goalkeeper. Yes, I did just say that!!! Allow me to explain though! Our oldest centre half is 28 and in the first year of ever playing centre half and only his second year as a professional. The next oldest is 26 and out of the team, then 25 having spent a year in the reserves, then we have Bailey and it's easy to forget how young he actually is because of his ability. Also, consider that Rudd is still only just in to his twenties as well.

I'm not questioning the overall abilities of any of these lads (even Huntington) but what they do lack is real seen-it/done it experience. I think we need an old head that can guide some of our talented youngsters through the last 15mins of games. An old warhorse of a centre half in the Lucketti mould that you wouldn't necessarily expect to play 90mins but would come on to organise and co-ordinate things from the back and be a calming influence.

I don't play Champ Manager but I'm sure there must be a 32/33yr old centre half with a good knowledge of the game lying in a Championship reserve side desperate for a few games on loan somewhere?

When fully fit we have a good experience in Welsh and K.Davies further up the all important spine of the team but we lack a real leader at the back. I don't think it's tactics that are costing us late goals, I think it's the inexperience of seeing a result out. We get nervous, we panic and we concede. It's not a lack of ability or a lack of heart, quite the opposite; we're probably trying too hard! We need someone for our younger lads to look up to who can steady the ship and guide us home to 3 points.
 
Very interesting read. I don think it excuses the 'sitting back tactic' completely but it's something but I think you're on to something there!
 
Lots of threads on here recently about us needing a creative midfielder (or slating the ones we have) or needing a second goalscorer (or slating the ones we have....) or criticising Grayson's tactical sitting back on a lead. Not sure how you can avoid sitting back when the opposition have a free kick on the halfway line being taken by the goalkeeper though.

The issues we have at the moment don't lie in any of these areas in my opinion. I'll get my tin hat on here, but I feel the problems lie with the defence and goalkeeper. Yes, I did just say that!!! Allow me to explain though! Our oldest centre half is 28 and in the first year of ever playing centre half and only his second year as a professional. The next oldest is 26 and out of the team, then 25 having spent a year in the reserves, then we have Bailey and it's easy to forget how young he actually is because of his ability. Also, consider that Rudd is still only just in to his twenties as well.

I'm not questioning the overall abilities of any of these lads (even Huntington) but what they do lack is real seen-it/done it experience. I think we need an old head that can guide some of our talented youngsters through the last 15mins of games. An old warhorse of a centre half in the Lucketti mould that you wouldn't necessarily expect to play 90mins but would come on to organise and co-ordinate things from the back and be a calming influence.

I don't play Champ Manager but I'm sure there must be a 32/33yr old centre half with a good knowledge of the game lying in a Championship reserve side desperate for a few games on loan somewhere?

When fully fit we have a good experience in Welsh and K.Davies further up the all important spine of the team but we lack a real leader at the back. I don't think it's tactics that are costing us late goals, I think it's the inexperience of seeing a result out. We get nervous, we panic and we concede. It's not a lack of ability or a lack of heart, quite the opposite; we're probably trying too hard! We need someone for our younger lads to look up to who can steady the ship and guide us home to 3 points.
a very good post but I also agree with some fans we do need a one or two new faces
 
I can certainly see an argument for the lack of an old experienced head in the back 5 could be a significant issue.

It could also explain why we appear to be defending too deep later on in games... which may not be Grayson's masterplan. At an ordinary amateur I've played in teams where it just seems to happen. Probably that bit of panic. Chasing every ball and every runner, sometimes unnecessarily, at the cost of losing your shape. I think that similar issues can arise in the professional game.
 
I can certainly see an argument for the lack of an old experienced head in the back 5 could be a significant issue.

It could also explain why we appear to be defending too deep later on in games... which may not be Grayson's masterplan. At an ordinary amateur I've played in teams where it just seems to happen. Probably that bit of panic. Chasing every ball and every runner, sometimes unnecessarily, at the cost of losing your shape. I think that similar issues can arise in the professional game.

In my view the team does probably lack a decisive leader, especially down the spine of the team. A Luckitti, O'Neill, Gregan or Alexander character isn't available - Welsh is probably the nearest we've got but he's a doer rather than a talker and a bollocker. Players like Wright and Rudd are likely to go far in the game but at present are still finsing their way and will hopefully become more influential.

Huntington is probably the most "natural" captain, and did that for Yeovil I think, but he's out of favour for whatever reason.

That all being said, I think theres a difference between sitting back and being forced back and when you're up against 6 strikers or whatever theres a natural tendency to play safe. Its a very difficult situation and something the team is evidently not dealing with well.
 
That all being said, I think theres a difference between sitting back and being forced back and when you're up against 6 strikers or whatever theres a natural tendency to play safe. Its a very difficult situation and something the team is evidently not dealing with well.

A very good point. This weekend, going into the last 5 minutes of games, I guarantee that there won't be one team losing by a goal who don't throw extra forwards on, go going ho or throw a centre half upfield. If that happens against Walsall and they end up with 5 big forwards, how do we handle it - keep pouring forward or deal with the situation? There are things like holding a high line that can mitigate what we need to do but essentially if a 6 and a half foot player plonks himself at the edge of your box you need to assign someone to him.
 
A very good point. This weekend, going into the last 5 minutes of games, I guarantee that there won't be one team losing by a goal who don't throw extra forwards on, go going ho or throw a centre half upfield. If that happens against Walsall and they end up with 5 big forwards, how do we handle it - keep pouring forward or deal with the situation? There are things like holding a high line that can mitigate what we need to do but essentially if a 6 and a half foot player plonks himself at the edge of your box you need to assign someone to him.

And from set pieces the only option is to go towards you're own goal. This is why I was going mad at Davies not getting back onside in the 2nd half because he was giving away needless free kicks and free opportunities but Rotherham to knock it long. And also how do all these teams find someone with a long throw once their getting beat?
 
I don't necessary think experience is needed, but more of a leader on the pitch. Someone who communicates to the team loudly, organizing and motivating the players. John Welsh does this to an extent, and he was badly missed on Tuesday.
 
A very good point. This weekend, going into the last 5 minutes of games, I guarantee that there won't be one team losing by a goal who don't throw extra forwards on, go going ho or throw a centre half upfield. If that happens against Walsall and they end up with 5 big forwards, how do we handle it - keep pouring forward or deal with the situation? There are things like holding a high line that can mitigate what we need to do but essentially if a 6 and a half foot player plonks himself at the edge of your box you need to assign someone to him.

I remember when Davies was manager he'd sometimes leave two or three up when we were defending corners. You need the nuts to do it though.
 
I remember when Davies was manager he'd sometimes leave two or three up when we were defending corners. You need the nuts to do it though.

When Beck was at Cambridge I remember him leaving 4 up when defending corners. His thinking was that the opposition would always have to have 5 back to cover his 4 thus leaving the area relatively clear for his goalkeeper, Vaughan. The reasoning seemed sound but the fact nobody else does it suggests to me it's not too sound, maybe because it leaves more space for the forwards to work with?
 
The gentleman the o.p. describes was on the pitch tuesday night, experienced, still quick,class act,Claud Davis didnt stop em conceding three and being under the cosh for long periods !
Still agree though we need a big character LEADER on the pitch.
 
Very interesting read and a point that hasn't been brought up.

Is this issue only regarding our conceding of late goals?

Because we do have the 2nd lowest conceding defence in the league.

Maybe you have to look at the manner of goals we have conceded in the last 10 minutes, would a cool headed centre half been able to stop Moosa's worldie strike or the goal mouth scramble that Rudd initially saved, but rebounded in off Laird?
 
It isn't a knee-jerk rection to recent results, just an area where I see we could strengthen relatively cheaply but definitely gain from. Wright, Clarke and King have desire in bucketloads but I think they could benefit from old old head to train alongside daily, share experiences with and guide them through the last 10mins of matches. It would be a useful player to bring on in such situations and surely wouldn't break the bank to bring in on loan. If we aren't going to score many, why not hold on to a lead better?

I take your point Ron but if we are seen to be sitting back and inviting pressure on us which then results in the "worldie" strike or scrambled goal, would a calming influence and better organisation at the back prevent the defensive panic which left men free for the shot?

It wouldn't disrupt the balance of the team as Wright and Clarke have formed an excellent partnership in a back four, he could gain match sharpness as part of a three man defence rotating with King and allow us cover for injuries in addition to the late substitute role I envisage. We already have lots of midfielders and lots of strikers so adding to the ranks there would be a waste of money IMO and whenever we lose a defender to injury we don't have any real cover (although King is improving, he's still not ready for a regular spot in a back four) I can't see cost being too much of an issue either as aging defenders would be a fraction of the price of a flair midfielder or 20 goals-per-season striker. We don't score many, we don't concede many but when we do concede in does invariable cost us points because we aren't prolific.

Oh, and while I mention a lack of goals, a big old commanding centre have would surely have a presence in the opposing box too. We don't score half as many goals from corners or indirect free kicks as you would expect, hopefully that would improve too!

(Cue Billymac with a witty "goalscoring defender" quip....)

Finally, SSL. No! He's got the intelligence and tactical knowledge of 05Simpson.
 
Last edited:
I couldn't get on the game on Tuesday but I've watched the extended highlights and I have to say that at times Bailey Wright's defending was shocking. I do think that we would benefit from a quality experienced centre half alongside Clarke and Wright or King if we play a back three. I had high hopes for Huntington but he's not particularly impressed me. Clarke, Wright and King all have good qualities but in my opinion not one of them is a true centre half.
 
Agreed BML. Bailey appears to be tiring now, both mentally and physically, and is due a rest for a few games. The way 35yr old Kevin Lisbie out-thought him against Orient and constantly caused confusion about whether he or Laird should be marking him and ensuring he always had a run on Bailey to win every arial ball really highlighted our lack of experience for me.

Wright has been a rock for most of the season but we do need to start thinking about keeping our best players fresh for the play-offs, plus towards the end of the season we'll start picking up niggly fatigue based injuries and suspensions so we'll need a touch more strength in depth.

Experience could prove decisive in play-off games, as IF we hold a slender lead it's fair to say we'll come under MORE pressure than we saw against Coventry or Rotherham (indeed it may yet even be Rotherham again!) Imagine our younger lads at Wembley. No question to their passion or motivation but surely for big games we need someone to guide the lads through?
 
Back
Top