Skip to main content

First Impressions

First Impressions

Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
14,205
Location
San Diego (A Whales Vagina)
I know that it was the first game of Pre-Season and that we were playing a very talented opposition with most players being worth what all our squad are put together but there were some noticeable moments and performances to make me feel optimistic.

Rudd - Should have done better with the second goal but nothing worth mentioning.

Stuckmann - Same as Rudd, should have done better with 1 of his goals conceded.

Clarke - Awful I thought, up against a Youngster but at times didn't seem interested.

Wright - Good Performance, played well against some quality opposition.

Huntington - Nothing worth mentioning.

Buchanan - Nothing worth mentioning.

Laird - Good shot and tried to get us playing, can see he is a bit rusty.

Mousinho - He played ok, broke up a bit of there play but outclassed in the middle.

Welsh - Apart from the penalty thought he was steady.

Beavon - Nothing worth mentioning.

Hume - His usual firecracker self if it was for a few short minutes.

Garner - Nothing worth mentioning apart from the header.

Humphrey - Showed what he is capable of with that blistering run.

Holmes - Had to defend Johnson basically the whole second half, did it well.

Byrom - I thought he was MOM, came on passed well and made some good challenges.

Wroe - Nothing worth mentioning.

Cummins - Anonymous.

Cansdell-Sheriff - Thought he played better than Huntington.

Beardsley - Crap.

Anybody take anything else from the game?
 
I know that it was the first game of Pre-Season and that we were playing a very talented opposition with most players being worth what all our squad are put together but there were some noticeable moments and performances to make me feel optimistic.

Rudd - Should have done better with the second goal but nothing worth mentioning.

Stuckmann - Same as Rudd, should have done better with 1 of his goals conceded.

Clarke - Awful I thought, up against a Youngster but at times didn't seem interested.

Wright - Good Performance, played well against some quality opposition.

Huntington - Nothing worth mentioning.

Buchanan - Nothing worth mentioning.

Laird - Good shot and tried to get us playing, can see he is a bit rusty.

Mousinho - He played ok, broke up a bit of there play but outclassed in the middle.

Welsh - Apart from the penalty thought he was steady.

Beavon - Nothing worth mentioning.

Hume - His usual firecracker self if it was for a few short minutes.

Garner - Nothing worth mentioning apart from the header.

Humphrey - Showed what he is capable of with that blistering run.

Holmes - Had to defend Johnson basically the whole second half, did it well.

Byrom - I thought he was MOM, came on passed well and made some good challenges.

Wroe - Nothing worth mentioning.

Cummins - Anonymous.

Cansdell-Sheriff - Thought he played better than Huntington.

Beardsley - Crap.

Anybody take anything else from the game?

I don't think first impressions are meaningful at this stage and after playing a premier league side but, for what it's worth, I think you are being generous to Welsh, Hume and SCS.
 
Obviously a few allowances given the nature of the game, but I was also impressed by Byrom. We didn't see much that was good from him last year and obviously he's tarred with the W-brush, but I was pleasantly surprised and feel he could be competition for Wroe for the midfield berth alongside Welsh.

Humphrey looked promising, a bit like Monakana but with more end product.

Clarke started off ok but was struggling in the second half.

Not much else to write home about really.
 
Humphrey looks a player who can get people off their seat, he's rapid and strong, I think he'll be an exciting player for us.

You can't judge Clarke on that, up against two lightning quick players and I thought Ibe looked more of a threat than Sterling. He won't be up against quality like that again this season.
 
Bit harsh on Clarke I think. Up against 2 of the quickest players on the pitch and put in some good tackles.

Mousinho still looks very nervous but hopefully he'll show us what he can do this season. Grayson obviously rates him so that's good enough for me.
 
IMO, your assessment of our new right back Clarke is rather harsh, he tackled well and tracked his man (who was a very quick and good dribbler if the ball). Overall I can see why Grayson wanted his former player from Huddersfield.
 
Rudd - His speed off his line is very impressive. I'm not sure why our defence was playing such a high line. You can bet your bottom dollar they wouldn't play like that against Liverpool in a competitive game - however Rudd swept up time and time again. I can't blame a keeper for not saving a penalty.

Stuckmann - I thought he did rather well bar the fourth goal - saying that, it had obviously wrong-footed him.

Clarke - Very impressed with Clarke, in the first half at least. Got a vital glance at the back post to stop a certain goal and likewise made a vital sliding challenge inside the penalty area. On his first performance it looks as if we've acquired a good utility player to say the least.

Wright – He was probably my man of the match. He should be playing at a higher level. He has great presence despite not being overly tall. His awareness is top class and he has good ability to go along with his tenacity.

Huntington - An average Huntsy performance. A few poor hoofs up field and needless passes but his all-round game was pretty solid, if not a bit rusty.

Buchanan - Very impressed that Buchs was able to continue his good form, especially against high-class opposition.

Laird - I didn't feel given the limited game time Laird got last season, it was enough to merit all his plaudits. I thought he played very well and looks to be coming back strong.

Mousinho – A decent performance from Moose. A couple of vital interceptions and he kept things ticking over with simple passes. The problem is that John Welsh does this just as well and probably better.

Welsh - He showed what he was about and he oozes class at our level. He was a bit sluggish and probably wasn't expected to be caught in possession as much as he was. He and Wroe are two sides of the same coin; they miss each other when not in the same team.

Beavon - As usual, his ability was there to be seen. I don't think we were ever going to go about our job effectively enough for Beavon to make any impact.

Hume - He looked very off the boil for the first twenty minutes and didn't complete a pass until thereafter. However once he got into his stride a bit more, he started showing what we have been missing.

Garner - Still much undecided on Gardner.

Humphrey - This lad looks good. First impressions are that he is like Jeff but with less flash and more substance.

Holmes - Much like Hume he was completely off the boil to begin with but looked better towards the end.

Byrom - I didn't notice all the much of him. I do remember a great challenge and a few good passes though - so thumbs up I guess.

Wroe - His ability (and willingness) to turn instantly every time he gets the ball opens up all sorts of options inside the opponents half. I love this lad, and I think he is as essential as John Welsh.

Cummins - I've been really championing Cummings for a while now. When called upon last season, he did a job for us and it looked like he was starting to gain in confidence. However he looked really poor at the weekend, uninterested and played with no confidence.

Cansdell-Sheriff - He seemed to do okay.

Beardsley - Not enough time to play a part really.

Davies - I was very impressed with this lad when he made a few appearances last season. He looked very good again. I think we've got three great left backs at the club!
 
Didnt go.

cba with pre season friendlies, totally meaningless.

However I am really pleased Hume is back, and the winger Humphrey sounds interesting.

Kevin Davies at 36 is a real gamble, if he can stay match fit and free from injury then wonderful, we shall see, if he doesnt it could be a big wage wasted.

However I think we are woefully short in central midfield, the only one that gets my vote is Welsh, possibly Wroe, but we need ideally 2 new players here, and a good central defender also to give us a balanced squad with a real chance of promotion.
 
Didnt go.

cba with pre season friendlies, totally meaningless.

However I am really pleased Hume is back, and the winger Humphrey sounds interesting.

Kevin Davies at 36 is a real gamble, if he can stay match fit and free from injury then wonderful, we shall see, if he doesnt it could be a big wage wasted.

However I think we are woefully short in central midfield, the only one that gets my vote is Welsh, possibly Wroe, but we need ideally 2 new players here, and a good central defender also to give us a balanced squad with a real chance of promotion.

Byrom did play well on Saturday and may benefit from new management.
 
For me, none of the players got the ball enough to be judged on in Saturdays game. When they've been in training for a few weeks and have had some more time to play as a team is when it is in my opinion time to start judging the performances of the players.
 
Last edited:
Didnt go.

cba with pre season friendlies, totally meaningless.

However I am really pleased Hume is back, and the winger Humphrey sounds interesting.

Kevin Davies at 36 is a real gamble, if he can stay match fit and free from injury then wonderful, we shall see, if he doesnt it could be a big wage wasted.

However I think we are woefully short in central midfield, the only one that gets my vote is Welsh, possibly Wroe, but we need ideally 2 new players here, and a good central defender also to give us a balanced squad with a real chance of promotion.

Been to all three so far and in my opinion the best midfielder has been young Ryan Croasdale,he is more creative and with a good eye for the right pass.This lad will go a long way.I would also like to mention young Ben Davis who with playing time will develop into an absolute cracker.If these two are a sample of what is coming through,we will have good time,s ahead
 
My first impression of Tom Clarke is very good. Seems a good defender. Think he'll play at right back.

Some idiots on here were writing him off after the Liverpool game - now people are saying what a great player he is after half a match against a bunch of Sunday league cloggers.

When will people realise that friendlies mean squat? And why they actually pay money to attend nothing more than training sessions baffles me in the extreme.
 
Some idiots on here were writing him off after the Liverpool game - now people are saying what a great player he is after half a match against a bunch of Sunday league cloggers.

When will people realise that friendlies mean squat? And why they actually pay money to attend nothing more than training sessions baffles me in the extreme.

You don't pay money to attend competitive games either though, to be fair.
 
Some idiots on here were writing him off after the Liverpool game - now people are saying what a great player he is after half a match against a bunch of Sunday league cloggers.

When will people realise that friendlies mean squat? And why they actually pay money to attend nothing more than training sessions baffles me in the extreme.

Possibly because they love watching football and there's been none to watch for the past couple of months? Just a thought ;-)
 
A few thoughts. As I've said before it was a bit disappointing that the team wasn't a bit more energetic for the Liverpool game given the size of the crowd but it is already largely forgotten. SG experimented with Laird at left midfield for that game but has played him at left-back since - that is good. Laird is arguably the best attacking left-back in this division - at left-midfield he is nothing but an unremarkable mediocrity. At some point, you never know, he might have it in him to be a halfway useful central midfielder, but right now there is only place he should be played. As for left midfield itself we have plenty of options - Holmes, Hayhurst and as a purely attacking throw of the dice Monakana, who can be as effective there as he can be on the right. If we ever need an emergency option for that position then Buchanan is at least left-footed, but there is just no need to improvise there at the moment.

As far as the right-back position is concerned we don't have a specialist at all - just two 'utility' players in the form of Keane and Clarke. Of the two the former is the more agressive and the latter the more composed. I think we would all like to see Keane resume where he left off at right-back before his injury not least because he was beginning to learn how to get forward more effectively.

The central midfield has not yet clicked into place for this season. I would like to see King played there in one of the friendlies, but if the supposed 'first choice' pairing of Welsh and Wroe is to be the one we start the season with it needs to show what it can do in one of the friendlies otherwise we may start with Mousinho and Byrom. We are not short of attacking options for the right midfield with Humphrey and Monakana, but I would like to see us have a reliable more defensive option there as well. Holmes can be effective at holding the ball up there but I still think it is a role that Mousinho could fulfil.

Upfront the Garner-Beavon duo looks no more convincing this season than last - both need a different sort of partner. But if the Hume-Davies duo works then with the likes of Garner, Beavon and even Cummins in reserve we should be OK.

We have yet to see Hayhurst. This lad is good, very good - he brings energy, application and skill to the left midfield - and could become a key player for us. Let's see how we look with Keane, Hayhurst, Davies and Hume in a starting line-up.
 
Back
Top