Skip to main content

Formation Stifling Creativity

Formation Stifling Creativity

stf4ever

Ridsdale's Retirement Party
Joined
Dec 29, 2009
Messages
8,504
Location
with the 'rents
First of all I've got to start by saying last night was the most uninspiring 90 minutes of football I've witnessed for a long time. Two poor sides struggling to create chances putting on an awful advertisement for The Championship.

In typical Grayson fashion we've adopted a familiar formation to try and combat the undoubtably higher quality of teams in the division. It's a retaliation to our obvious struggles earlier in the season. And whilst this formation makes us more resolute at the back it also creates us problems going forward.

I will accept that we've struggled to score all season but we have had our midfield lynchpin (Gallagher) out for the whole time we played an alternate formation. However a switch to 3-5-2 or 5-3-2 depending on which way you view it has caused us problems.

In League 1 we could play this formation and win game after game because of the lower quality of opposition strike forces. In the division above we've had to accommodate for the pace, the clever runs, and the clinical finishing by pushing our defensive line back 20 or so yards. In turn, this has dragged the whole team back with it by 20 yards.

Our wide men aren't picking up the ball on the corner of the opposition box but instead closer to the halfway line. In League 1 our wide men would have to beat or tease a full back before delivering whereas now they have to have a 20 yard dribble, take on a midfielder and a full back and deliver the ball.

In the division below our strikers were constantly 20 yards from goal with support. Now they're often tracking back into their own half. They're receiving long balls from Pickford with only their strike partner to find. When our wide men invariably get something into the box they are so far from goal that they just take up a position in the box rather than making threatening runs to the front or back post.

In my opinion we should try to push our team up the pitch by a good 10-15 yards. We can't do this with one wide player each side as this causes us to be too predictable and play predominantly through the middle. I would suggest a 4-5-1 at home, and I wouldn't whinge about reverting to the 5-3-2 away from home.

We had every chance of picking up the 3 points last night and if we want to stay up we need to take every point on offer to us. Last night we recycled possession on the half way line instead of 30-35 yards from goal where you can build concerted pressure.

My team for the next home game would be:

GK: Pickford
RB: Woods
CB: Huntington
CB: Wright
LB: Cunningham
RM: Reach
CM: Browne
CM: Kilkenny
LM: Gallagher
AM: Johnson
ST: Hugill

What does that team say to everybody? To me it says we have an obvious lack of pace. We are going to struggle to be a threat to teams without it. So instead I would play to our advantages. In Johnson we have a wand of a left foot but also somebody not on top form. He's slowed down his game in this formation currently. Instead of taking a touch, releasing and building up pressure he has to take several touches to allow the wide players to get infront of him. I'd invite him to run off Hugill and to be our main threat/player as he is our obvious talent in a team devoid of pace and dribblers.

Anyway, what do I know? In Grayson we trust.
 
First of all I've got to start by saying last night was the most uninspiring 90 minutes of football I've witnessed for a long time. Two poor sides struggling to create chances putting on an awful advertisement for The Championship.

In typical Grayson fashion we've adopted a familiar formation to try and combat the undoubtably higher quality of teams in the division. It's a retaliation to our obvious struggles earlier in the season. And whilst this formation makes us more resolute at the back it also creates us problems going forward.

I will accept that we've struggled to score all season but we have had our midfield lynchpin (Gallagher) out for the whole time we played an alternate formation. However a switch to 3-5-2 or 5-3-2 depending on which way you view it has caused us problems.

In League 1 we could play this formation and win game after game because of the lower quality of opposition strike forces. In the division above we've had to accommodate for the pace, the clever runs, and the clinical finishing by pushing our defensive line back 20 or so yards. In turn, this has dragged the whole team back with it by 20 yards.

Our wide men aren't picking up the ball on the corner of the opposition box but instead closer to the halfway line. In League 1 our wide men would have to beat or tease a full back before delivering whereas now they have to have a 20 yard dribble, take on a midfielder and a full back and deliver the ball.

In the division below our strikers were constantly 20 yards from goal with support. Now they're often tracking back into their own half. They're receiving long balls from Pickford with only their strike partner to find. When our wide men invariably get something into the box they are so far from goal that they just take up a position in the box rather than making threatening runs to the front or back post.

In my opinion we should try to push our team up the pitch by a good 10-15 yards. We can't do this with one wide player each side as this causes us to be too predictable and play predominantly through the middle. I would suggest a 4-5-1 at home, and I wouldn't whinge about reverting to the 5-3-2 away from home.

We had every chance of picking up the 3 points last night and if we want to stay up we need to take every point on offer to us. Last night we recycled possession on the half way line instead of 30-35 yards from goal where you can build concerted pressure.

My team for the next home game would be:

GK: Pickford
RB: Woods
CB: Huntington
CB: Wright
LB: Cunningham
RM: Reach
CM: Browne
CM: Kilkenny
LM: Gallagher
AM: Johnson
ST: Hugill

What does that team say to everybody? To me it says we have an obvious lack of pace. We are going to struggle to be a threat to teams without it. So instead I would play to our advantages. In Johnson we have a wand of a left foot but also somebody not on top form. He's slowed down his game in this formation currently. Instead of taking a touch, releasing and building up pressure he has to take several touches to allow the wide players to get infront of him. I'd invite him to run off Hugill and to be our main threat/player as he is our obvious talent in a team devoid of pace and dribblers.

Anyway, what do I know? In Grayson we trust.

Having a laugh if you are playing Hugil as loan striker - he's the worst striker we have had since Habib sissoko.
 
I couldn't argue with it!

It's a dilemma... I think most of us as supporters would choose to be more adventurous in our play... to take more risks. But then we'd also be up in arms if we were bottom of the league.

I'm happy that we've built a solid enough start. Just hope we can kick on.
 
Last night was just a repetition of what happened so often on Div 1 - great away performances using the wing-back formation followed by boring home performance using the same approach. There is nothing surprising about it.
 
Last night was just a repetition of what happened so often on Div 1 - great away performances using the wing-back formation followed by boring home performance using the same approach. There is nothing surprising about it.

It's alarming that Grayson can't change his tactics accordingly. He made a substitution with ten mins to go to go back to a back 4..... that's how he should have started at home.

The team in the OP with one up front..... Nooooooo
 
It's alarming that Grayson can't change his tactics accordingly. He made a substitution with ten mins to go to go back to a back 4..... that's how he should have started at home.

The team in the OP with one up front..... Nooooooo

He probably would have played 442 if Huntington was fully fit or if Clarke or McCarthy were fit. Unfortunately his hand has been forced. Keeping 3 clean sheets with Cunningham and Woods as part of a back 3 has been remarkable.
 
It's alarming that Grayson can't change his tactics accordingly. He made a substitution with ten mins to go to go back to a back 4..... that's how he should have started at home.

The team in the OP with one up front..... Nooooooo

Maybe playing a back 4 wasn't possible because Hunts wasn't up to playing a full 90 minutes? Just speculating...
 
He probably would have played 442 if Huntington was fully fit or if Clarke or McCarthy were fit. Unfortunately his hand has been forced. Keeping 3 clean sheets with Cunningham and Woods as part of a back 3 has been remarkable.

Two of the games were from the shit teams at the bottom though.... Brighton was a good point.

I believe Grayson picked the team due to tactics and not Huntingtons fitness
 
Last night was just a repetition of what happened so often on Div 1 - great away performances using the wing-back formation followed by boring home performance using the same approach. There is nothing surprising about it.

Absolutely ernest. The formation rarely worked at home, even in League 1 but we did sometimes get away with it by Garner or Beckford conjouring up a goal from nothing. That was a lot easier to do against League 1 defences; Beckford may still be able to do it but Garner is finding life a lot harder at this level where defenders are generally stronger, quicker, and crucially, less likely to be wound up by his antics.
 
Absolutely ernest. The formation rarely worked at home, even in League 1 but we did sometimes get away with it by Garner or Beckford conjouring up a goal from nothing. That was a lot easier to do against League 1 defences; Beckford may still be able to do it but Garner is finding life a lot harder at this level where defenders are generally stronger, quicker, and crucially, less likely to be wound up by his antics.


Thanks - so the question is what we can we do about it. With present resources then for home games I would keep the Browne, Gallagher and Johnson trio as the core of our midfield - we simply don't have anything better - but push Reach further forward alongside the strikers. The evidence of the Charlton and Brighton games - and last night - is that way out wide Reach is OK at keeping possession but not much more, frankly he lacks the pace to get past a fullback on the outside. But when Reach is closer the penalty area and runs at the defenders then he can cause trouble. As I said elsewhere a player who might bring a bit of a spark to things is Brownhill - surely he should at least be on the bench.

Longer term we need another quality midfielder to give us more strength in depth there - Kilkenny can be a tidy player but he is not going to bring any match-changing abilities onto the field. I don't share the criticism of Garner - I think he is doing everything he can but lacks any sort of decent service and apart from odd moments from Hugill any support. At some point we need to see if Garner and May can hit it off together.
 
Two of the games were from the shit teams at the bottom though.... Brighton was a good point.

I believe Grayson picked the team due to tactics and not Huntingtons fitness

You only play whats put in front of you, if we get 4 points and 2 clean sheets against our relegation rivals with a patched up back line then that can only be a good thing can it?
 
You only play whats put in front of you, if we get 4 points and 2 clean sheets against our relegation rivals with a patched up back line then that can only be a good thing can it?

Charlton got beat 3-0 in their next two games and they are shit at the moment. We did well there.

I feel last night was 2 points dropped against a poor Bolton.

Scored in one of the last four games is poor
 
Maybe playing a back 4 wasn't possible because Hunts wasn't up to playing a full 90 minutes? Just speculating...

I am clinging onto that thought Essex and I want 4-4-2 or a stronger midfield in 4-5-1 but ensuring we support the lone striker very quickly with the 5 midfielders. Do not change anything away though as that is working a treat and current tactics should be employed at Loftus Road but Tuesday come on SG let's have it and actually look to go for 3 points and put the Florists under pressure.
 
Two of the games were from the shit teams at the bottom though.... Brighton was a good point.
I don't want to burst your bubble, but we are also one of the shit teams at the bottom. And we will be all season, so suck it up.

It doesn't mean any less if we keep clean sheets against them.

I believe Grayson picked the team due to tactics and not Huntingtons fitness
I haven't been able to see Huntington's medical diagnosis online - presumably you've seen it though, how does it look?

I notice a few on here suggesting he's fit to start, so I assume they must be basing that opinion on more than just making-shit-up.
 
I don't want to burst your bubble, but we are also one of the shit teams at the bottom. And we will be all season, so suck it up.

It doesn't mean any less if we keep clean sheets against them.

I haven't been able to see Huntington's medical diagnosis online - presumably you've seen it though, how does it look?

I notice a few on here suggesting he's fit to start, so I assume they must be basing that opinion on more than just making-shit-up.

Yes so when in a dogfight against others around you then surely it's key to try and win your home games...

If he isn't fit and his hamstring is still causing him hip then surely he shouldn't be on the bench as a hamstring can go at any time
 
Yes so when in a dogfight against others around you then surely it's key to try and win your home games...
And clean sheets help in that aim, you do see that now?

If he isn't fit and his hamstring is still causing him hip then surely he shouldn't be on the bench as a hamstring can go at any time
So you actually don't know anything about Huntington's injury or current condition.

OK, thanks for sharing.
 
Look if Grayson went for a formation which looked like it was geared up for chasing 3 points I am sure all us fans would be right behind him even if we lost on Tuesday. However in my opinion Forest like Bolton don't appear to have the goals in um so let's change the formation to suit. We have the players that I am absolutely sure of so come on SG please please please go at Forest.
 
Back
Top