Skip to main content

Formations

Formations

Joined
Dec 12, 2010
Messages
754
Location
Grimsargh
What are people's opinions on formations for this season? We all know that Grayson likes to chop and change formation regularly, depending upon the opponent and how the game is going. But I thought on a few occasions last season that when we changed formations during a game we looked disjointed. Successful teams last season like Brentford stuck to one formation regularly, so should we look to nail down a formation and starting X1?

I think that a 4-2-3-1 would work well at the moment, with the players available.

Jones

Woods
Clarke
Wright
Buchanan

Kilkenny
Browne

Little
Brownhill
Gallagher

Garner
 
My opinion is............

ah forget it, the managers better qualified than me, I`ll leave it to him. 🙂
 
What are people's opinions on formations for this season? We all know that Grayson likes to chop and change formation regularly, depending upon the opponent and how the game is going. But I thought on a few occasions last season that when we changed formations during a game we looked disjointed. Successful teams last season like Brentford stuck to one formation regularly, so should we look to nail down a formation and starting X1?

I think that a 4-2-3-1 would work well at the moment, with the players available.

Jones

Woods
Clarke
Wright
Buchanan

Kilkenny
Browne

Little
Brownhill
Gallagher

Garner

We don't need 2 holding midfield players in this league! Even if we did Browne is not that type of player.

4-3-3 for me.

Jones

Woods Clarke Wright Laird

Brownhill Killkenny Browne

Little Garner Gallagher

With Reid to challenge when fit
 
Last edited:
My opinion is............

ah forget it, the managers better qualified than me, I`ll leave it to him. 🙂

Kinda defeats the point of having a fans discussion forum.

Grayson may have an excellent record in getting teams out of League 1, but with us he failed when it mattered most and is definitely not beyond criticism.
 
Because I'm better than the manager, obviously:

Jones

Woods Clarke Wright Buchanan

Wiseman Kilkenny Brownhill Hayhurst/Reid

Little Garner​

I like the traditional 4-4-2 with the best crossers of the ball on the wings, a midfield pair who are the best passers of the ball and a good solid team of workers who defend with a tight, narrow shape rather than lunging in to tackles and two real grafters up front to keep the opposition on their toes.

At home teams sit back to stifle us, so we need to put pressure on from the front with both wide midfielders and attackers pushing up and closing down to leave space for the two creative players in the middle of the park and overlapping attacking fullbacks. I don't think we can risk two out-and-out wingers with just Kilkenny and Brownhill in the centre of midfield though. Hayhurst tracks back and puts in far more effort than Holmes ever will so he gets the nod until Reid proves his fitness.

Also, as this thread is about formations rather than the XI, the lineup gives the option of going to a back 3 at home of Woods, Clarke and Wright.
 
Last edited:
Because I'm better than the manager, obviously:

Jones

Woods Clarke Wright Buchanan

Wiseman Kilkenny Brownhill Hayhurst/Reid

Little Garner​

Your suggestion of Wiseman on the wing has got to be one of the most fucking stupid suggestions I've read on here. Why don't we put Stuckmann on the left as well just to really be shit? He's average at right back, saved by the fact he's reasonably competent going forward on occasion. He's not a winger though by any stretch of the imagination.

That's just my opinion of course.😛

I'd go with the team suggested by proton, while definitely trying to incorporate Reid when fit as Gallagher and Little both being in the team at the same time won't provide much width. Substituting Browne for king may also be a good idea when we need to be solid. I'd certainly prefer to see him played there than in defence. As long as Welsh isn't in the midfield though, I'll be happy enough.

We don't need 2 holding midfield players in this league! Even if we did Browne is not that type of player.

4-3-3 for me.

Jones

Woods Clarke Wright Laird

Brownhill Killkenny Browne

Little Garner Gallagher

With Reid to challenge when fit
 
Last edited:
Jones
Wiseman, Clarke, Huntington, Buchanan
King
Kilkenny, Brownhill
Gallagher
Little, Garner​

Stuckmann, Wright, Woods, Welsh, Laird, Davies, Hayhurst.
 
What are people's opinions on formations for this season? We all know that Grayson likes to chop and change formation regularly, depending upon the opponent and how the game is going. But I thought on a few occasions last season that when we changed formations during a game we looked disjointed. Successful teams last season like Brentford stuck to one formation regularly, so should we look to nail down a formation and starting X1?

I think that a 4-2-3-1 would work well at the moment, with the players available.

Jones

Woods
Clarke
Wright
Buchanan

Kilkenny
Browne

Little
Brownhill
Gallagher

Garner

There are 2 formations on every pitch - ours and the opposition. A manager therefore has to both consider how we want to play as well as to counter the opposition. You also need the flexibility to vary home and away and even in different phases of the game. You also need to make a formation work with the payers at your disposal in any given game.

A manager therefore has to practice different formations whilst still recognising that players not formations win games. Players have to flexible to adjust this way and be capable of thinking and playing differently to outwit the opposition. Gone are days when the answer was always 4-4-2
 
Kinda defeats the point of having a fans discussion forum.

Grayson may have an excellent record in getting teams out of League 1, but with us he failed when it mattered most and is definitely not beyond criticism.
Nah wasnt criticising the guy, just im useless at it 🙂
 
Jones
Wiseman, Clarke, Huntington, Buchanan
King
Kilkenny, Brownhill
Gallagher
Little, Garner​

Stuckmann, Wright, Woods, Welsh, Laird, Davies, Hayhurst.

I'm sorry Billymac but that is the least convincing side I've seen.

And just for balance here's my team you can pull apart! Based on the pre season,

Jones

Woods Clarke Wright Buchannan

Hayhurst Kilkenny Brownhill Gallagher


Little Garner


And to be honest I'm a "Laird" fan but this pre season I've seen more from Buchannan possibly because he has nothing more to prove here and has got a bit more freedom but it is what it is! And as for Hayhurst (or Humphrey or Reid or Holmes ) the jury is still out but I'd give Will the nod because on his day he's definately better than Humphrey or Holmes, Reid very promising but I've only seen him in one game!

And just to add; my formation is pick your best eleven! simple
 
Last edited:
For me the best formation is 3 5 2.This formation gives us a minimum of five players in each third of the pitch,if you know what I mean, in their box two strikers two wing backs,and an attacking midfielder.In our box three defenders two wing backs and one holding midfielder.This formation also caters for any formation the opps wish to adopt. I will leave the manager to choose who to play in those positions,as someone has said he knows the players better than we do.
 
Winning formation will do for me.

Like the Killkenny, Browne and Brownhill midfield though. Build around that with 4 at the back.
 
I can't see Little and Garner playing together in any other system than one which has two up top, whether it be a 4-4-2 or 3-5-2. I don't want Garner shoved out on the wing, and from what I've seen of Little, he doesn't look the type of player who will suit there either. I hope Grayson tries to rekindle the dying breed of strike partnership. Andy Little looks like everything Kevin Davies was brought in to be.
 
I'd like to see more of this 4-3-3 with Little, Garner and Gallagher.

From that Youtube video (Yeah, I know), Little scored a lot of goals from picking the ball up out wide and cutting inside.

Until we sign another striker I think that system is our best bet for getting out of this league. I'd be very disappointed if we don't bring in another attacking player though.
 
I'm sorry Billymac but that is the least convincing side I've seen.

And just for balance here's my team you can pull apart! Based on the pre season,

Jones

Woods Clarke Wright Buchannan

Hayhurst Kilkenny Brownhill Gallagher


Little Garner


And to be honest I'm a "Laird" fan but this pre season I've seen more from Buchannan possibly because he has nothing more to prove here and has got a bit more freedom but it is what it is! And as for Hayhurst (or Humphrey or Reid or Holmes ) the jury is still out but I'd give Will the nod because on his day he's definately better than Humphrey or Holmes, Reid very promising but I've only seen him in one game!

And just to add; my formation is pick your best eleven! simple

No probs AJ, from what I have seen so far in pre season we have lost goals where Clarke has been easily beaten in the air hence Huntington, not seen enough of Woods either so have picked Wiseman on his previous (uninjured) form for us. I cannot abide seeing left footed players playing on the right and right on the left and think Gallagher given a roaming role will do very well for us. King looked very assured at Halifax playing just in front of the back 4 allowing Brownhill and Kilkenny the freedom to support the front players.

I don't think you can just pick a best X1 as it's a squad game, the others I selected can alter the shape of our side, what do we really know anyway, just guessing much like everyone in here.
 
Back
Top