Skip to main content

Fullbacks

Fullbacks

Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
14,205
Location
San Diego (A Whales Vagina)
Simple debate, at this stage I think there is real competition within these positions so the question is -

Wiseman or Woods ?

Laird or Buchanan ?

For me it's Laird and Wiseman but part of me thinks you can't advocate dropping Woods after his performance yesterday I wouldn't be angry if he kept the shirt but Wiseman has been in very good form.
 
Laird has clearly been working on his fitness. He looks a lot leaner and sharper. Once upon a time, I thought it was Buchanans shirt, but I may have changed my mind!
 
Laird has always been the better left back, it's just he's only now been given a run of games by Grayson. He's a momentum player and needs constant play time to keep him sharp. When at Stevenage I think he rarely ever missed a game. Buchanan isn't bad, but he's not as good as some make him out to be and is a very average footballer. He's had some real shockers that nobody ever seems to remember, including a terrible game in the play offs last season.

As for the right back, when both are available, I'd pick Wiseman every time simply because of his invaluble ability to drive forward from the back. I don't know why he was dropped yesterday though, so if he's not 100% I don't think there'd be any harm in letting an in-form Woods continue.
 
Simple debate, at this stage I think there is real competition within these positions so the question is -

Wiseman or Woods ?

Laird or Buchanan ?

For me it's Laird and Wiseman but part of me thinks you can't advocate dropping Woods after his performance yesterday I wouldn't be angry if he kept the shirt but Wiseman has been in very good form.


Fickle fans , up until yesterday woods wasn't deemed good enough now after 1 good game he owns the shirt , not sure the need to ask these pointless questions its like trying to start a popularity contest ! why not just let form dictate and the manager decide rather than thinking were experts who know best .
 
Laird has always been the better left back, it's just he's only now been given a run of games by Grayson. He's a momentum player and needs constant play time to keep him sharp. When at Stevenage I think he rarely ever missed a game. Buchanan isn't bad, but he's not as good as some make him out to be and is a very average footballer. He's had some real shockers that nobody ever seems to remember, including a terrible game in the play offs last season.

As for the right back, when both are available, I'd pick Wiseman every time simply because of his invaluble ability to drive forward from the back. I don't know why he was dropped yesterday though, so if he's not 100% I don't think there'd be any harm in letting an in-form Woods continue.

Wiseman was ill therefore not selected.

It's great that we have competition in the squad, they all seem to have a positive attitude too even when they aren't in the side ala Huntington and Stuckmann. The squads professionalism must be commended. Laird is a more aggressive full back and can contribute to our attacking play more than Buchanan but I think it is unfair to call Buchanan an average footballer. He is tenacious, does the simple things well and contrary to popular belief, does advance beyond the half way line from time to time. Difficult to pick between the 2 to be honest but Laird has the shirt for now.

As for right back, I am a big fan of Wiseman. A couple of Barnsley fans were critical of his defensive capabilities as he does like to move forward but his pace allows him to get out of trouble should he be found out of position. He had a poor game in the second play off semi last year and I recall a lot of fans giving him grief for it but ultimately he had been injured for some time and really shouldn't have played that game. He's responded well this season though and is a key contributor to the side and was perhaps unlucky that Woods had an apparent stormer yesterday as he may struggle to get back in. I am yet to see Woods play this season so can't comment on his abilities but if he can prove himself to be as effective as Wiseman has been, then he may get himself a consistent run in the side.

It's great to have options and is a good headache for Grayson to have.
 
Last edited:
Fickle fans , up until yesterday woods wasn't deemed good enough now after 1 good game he owns the shirt , not sure the need to ask these pointless questions its like trying to start a popularity contest ! why not just let form dictate and the manager decide rather than thinking were experts who know best .

That's actually an excellent definition of a fans forum and without all the bollocks and dumb ass ( and quality of course ) opinions there would hardly be one......... The Manager doesn't always get it right either Dirk as you well know... Good Christmas ?
 
I think Wiseman will start tomorrow if fit. Two games in 48 hours may be too much for Woods after such a long time out. But Laird has to be a starter every match whilst the defence stays tight. Yesterday was probably his best all around game for a long time and he seemed to be enjoying himself, having a bit of banter with the fans over some of the ref's crazy decisions. Plus, he's also a goal threat as well, something that Buchanan, for all his other attributes, isn't.
 
Fickle fans , up until yesterday woods wasn't deemed good enough nsow after 1 good game he owns the shirt , not sure the need to ask these pointless question its like trying to start a popularity contest ! why not just let form dictate and the manager decide rather than thinking were experts who know best .

Don't think it is a pointless question Dirk, just a matter of opinion, who as a fan you would prefer if fully fit and playing to their potential. It is all a matter of opinion's surely, that's what the forum and people are all about, would not be the same if we all thought along the same lines and agreed with each other all of the time, would it ? 😉
 
I personally think Buchanan has been the better player since Laird got injured. Laird has had runs in the side since, but not performed at the same level he did pre injury. However yesterday he looked back to his best. And his attacking play gives him the edge over Buchanan.
 
Slight change of direction here, but ....

How bloody nice is it to be able to have this discussion involving two decent players for each position, having to have a very real, genuine battle to get into the team. No wonder the left-back position is up in the air to an extent and that Woods came in with a strong performance yesterday - he has too as he knows he has got stiff competition if he wants to stay there.

I'm sure it's a headache Grayson is only too happy to have.
 
Simple debate, at this stage I think there is real competition within these positions so the question is -

Wiseman or Woods ?

Laird or Buchanan ?

For me it's Laird and Wiseman but part of me thinks you can't advocate dropping Woods after his performance yesterday I wouldn't be angry if he kept the shirt but Wiseman has been in very good form.

I think Laird because ATM he is sharp in defence and much more potent in attack than Buchanan. Looks back to his best.
The other one is tricky. wiseman has good quality going forward but cam mess up defending. Woods is yet to fully find his feet at PNE but yesterday looked absolute class. Hudds fans sorry to see him go. So I am going to take a punt on Woods.
 
I personally think Buchanan has been the better player since Laird got injured. Laird has had runs in the side since, but not performed at the same level he did pre injury. However yesterday he looked back to his best. And his attacking play gives him the edge over Buchanan.

+1 I was so pleased for Laird yesterday and he was up there as one of our best players on the day. Had a lean time when he came back from injury but he now looks to be getting back to his best. It's nice to have those two left backs.
 
I personally think Buchanan has been the better player since Laird got injured. Laird has had runs in the side since, but not performed at the same level he did pre injury. However yesterday he looked back to his best. And his attacking play gives him the edge over Buchanan.

Spot on. I'm a big Laird fan, but I said earlier in the season that Buchanan couldn't be dropped. If Laird is back to his best, he should keep the shirt because he gives us better attacking options. Prior to his injury, Laird was in good goal scoring/ assisting form.
 
Was good to see Laird get on the end of one of his near post runs from a corner as well.

He scored a couple of them when he first arrived. He probably connected with it too well and it went straight into the keeper's hands.
 
Back
Top