Skip to main content

Gallagher

Gallagher

Instead of who though? Robinson and McGeady offer pace and trickery to the wide areas and have probably been our greatest attacking threat in recent weeks.

FWIW I like Gallagher a lot, and feel he played the central role very well last season, but at the moment he remains on the bench as we have faster and better wide options, plus a good balance in midfield right now.

Dunno, I've not seen enough of the others. But ignoring everyone else, that's where I personally think he's best used if he plays. Fair enough doing nice stuff with the ball but a good pass from your own half to the half way line has less potential impact on the game than a cross that creates a chance.
 
Instead of who though? Robinson and McGeady offer pace and trickery to the wide areas and have probably been our greatest attacking threat in recent weeks.

FWIW I like Gallagher a lot, and feel he played the central role very well last season, but at the moment he remains on the bench as we have faster and better wide options, plus a good balance in midfield right now.

Our wingers are untouchable at the moment.
 
Might just be me but the last two games we've played without Gallagher I think we look a lot better, we seem to be keeping hold of the ball a lot more and there's a bit more fight in the middle! Considering he's been one our best players over the years I think he seems to have an automatic place in the side. After recent games would you start him and if so who for?

Has he just signed a 2 year extension?,i aint to sure,but if he has seems maybe since signing it hes gone backwards,resting on his laurels maybe.
 
Has he just signed a 2 year extension?,i aint to sure,but if he has seems maybe since signing it hes gone backwards,resting on his laurels maybe.
He played the very next match after signing (Brentford), was rested for Bournemouth with 9 others, started but got injured late in the Wigan game, and was back on the bench on Saturday returning from that injury.

Where has he "gone backwards, resting on his laurels"?
 
On Saturday we played a sort of 4-4-1-1 system with Johnson the 1 behind the strikers.

I could see Gallagher playing in 4-1-4-1 system sat behind Welsh /Grimshaw / Browne and Pearson in a sort of Pirlo role which he plays well. Either that or wide left / right in a 4 man midfield or one of 3 in the middle in a 5-3-2.

At the moment though there is no reason to change tactics or personnel so it's the bench for Gally. And he would previously have been my first name on the sheet.
 
On Saturday we played a sort of 4-4-1-1 system with Johnson the 1 behind the strikers.

I could see Gallagher playing in 4-1-4-1 system sat behind Welsh /Grimshaw / Browne and Pearson in a sort of Pirlo role which he plays well. Either that or wide left / right in a 4 man midfield or one of 3 in the middle in a 5-3-2.

At the moment though there is no reason to change tactics or personnel so it's the bench for Gally. And he would previously have been my first name on the sheet.

I'd say Pearson was our most advanced midfielder on Saturday, did his pressing really high up the pitch and always looked to get in their box.

That was probably the best defensive performance i've seen from Daniel Johnson.

The midfield three was excellent though, perfect balance.
 
We are developing a great squad.

Baptiste has made a difference in defence, we have multiple options in midfield, we could just do with that Gestede guy up front.
 
Baptiste has made a difference in defence, we have multiple options in midfield, we could just do with that Gestede guy up front.

Beckford is on his way back. Hugill is beginning to develop the striker's essential knack of being in the right place at the right time. Robinson can be clinical when he wants. Yes - a ready-made top class striker would be more than useful but just as the defence and even more so the midfield have started to get their act together the strikeforce is as well.
 
Beckford is on his way back. Hugill is beginning to develop the striker's essential knack of being in the right place at the right time. Robinson can be clinical when he wants. Yes - a ready-made top class striker would be more than useful but just as the defence and even more so the midfield have started to get their act together the strikeforce is as well.

Not forgetting Makienok's hat-trick away at a Premier League side a couple of weeks ago.

I certainly wouldn't be against the addition of another striker (maybe a loan) in the January window considering Beckford struggles to stay fit, Garner was sold and Doyle has once again been ineffective so far - but the striking situation certainly looks a damned sight better than about a month ago thanks to a couple of individuals stepping up to the plate.
 
We are developing a great squad.

Baptiste has made a difference in defence, we have multiple options in midfield, we could just do with that Gestede guy up front.

And yet a few weeks ago, people thought our starting 11 was weaker. That's what happens with some fans when we have a freak result like against Brentford - they panic!

I said it now and I will say it again. As dissapointed as I was with not replacing Garner, I feel that selling him will do the squad some good. He was always first name on the team sheet last season even after getting suspended, but in the games I've seen this season Hugil has offered a lot more then Garner ever did in the championship. People will disagree, but with Garner starting for some reason we always felt like we had to hoof the ball to him. Hugil makes runs, which makes creating chances easier.
 
And yet a few weeks ago, people thought our starting 11 was weaker. That's what happens with some fans when we have a freak result like against Brentford - they panic!

I said it now and I will say it again. As dissapointed as I was with not replacing Garner, I feel that selling him will do the squad some good. He was always first name on the team sheet last season even after getting suspended, but in the games I've seen this season Hugil has offered a lot more then Garner ever did in the championship. People will disagree, but with Garner starting for some reason we always felt like we had to hoof the ball to him. Hugil makes runs, which makes creating chances easier.

Baasically I think its pace. With Garner, Gallagher and Reach, whilst good on the ball we were pretty pedestrian. With Robinson, Hugill, McCeady and Johnson played in a freer role, we are far more fluid and quick, which in this league I think is whats needed, and I believe before we made any summer signings was something that Grayson said he had identified as needing improving. Not signing Reach may prove to be a blessing in disguise, although a good player, he would probably have kept Robinson out and stalled his blossoming development.
 
a freak result like against Brentford - they panic!

The last 15 minutes was a shambles - not just down to ten men but an already weak central midfield made even worse by teaming Johnson up with Gallagher there. But defeat was written into the initial team selection - that flat 4.4.2 with just Gallagher and Browne asked to win the ball in central midfield and then use it creatively which just meant either aimless balls punted forward or square passes out wide to a static McGeady or Robinson who had to wait for the ball and then try to invent something from nothing from a standing start. It was awful and we must never see that again.

But, as the phrase has it, that was then and this is now and finally we are putting out sides with both enough strength to win the ball in midfield and the pace and creativity to use it in a fluid attacking style. If we continue like that we can compete against anybody in this division and keep climbing up it.
 
Last edited:
Baasically I think its pace. With Garner, Gallagher and Reach, whilst good on the ball we were pretty pedestrian. With Robinson, Hugill, McCeady and Johnson played in a freer role, we are far more fluid and quick, which in this league I think is whats needed, and I believe before we made any summer signings was something that Grayson said he had identified as needing improving..........

I think this is the crucial difference (well going forward, I hope it is), between early season displays and more recent ones, and something for which SG should be applauded.
 
The last 15 minutes was a shambles - not just down to ten men but an already weak central midfield made even worse by teaming Johnson up with Gallagher there. But defeat was written into the initial team selection - that flat 4.4.2 with just Gallagher and Browne asked to win the ball in central midfield and then use it creatively which just meant either aimless balls punted forward or square passes out wide to a static McGeady or Robinson who had to wait for the ball and then try to invent something from nothing from a standing start. It was awful and we must never see that again.

But, as the phrase has it, that was then and this is now and finally we are putting out sides with both enough strength to win the ball in midfield and the pace and creativity to use it in a fluid attacking style. If we continue like that we can compete against anybody in this division and keep climbing up it.

No it was a shambles, and the starting 11 didn't help especially when we went down to ten men.
But the point is, people on here starting calling for Grayson's head saying he had lost the dressing room etc, but it was a freak result in terms of Grayson tenure, as we hadn't conceded that many goals before of lost by that scoreline before. Saturday's team should be the team for the foreseeable future, and if we get injuries along the way then we have good replacements ready who should be able to step up.
 
The last 15 minutes was a shambles - not just down to ten men but an already weak central midfield made even worse by teaming Johnson up with Gallagher there. But defeat was written into the initial team selection - that flat 4.4.2 with just Gallagher and Browne asked to win the ball in central midfield and then use it creatively which just meant either aimless balls punted forward or square passes out wide to a static McGeady or Robinson who had to wait for the ball and then try to invent something from nothing from a standing start. It was awful and we must never see that again.

No it was a shambles, and the starting 11 didn't help especially when we went down to ten men.
There's some revisionist bollocks being written here about the Brentford game.

To say "defeat was written into the initial team selection" is nothing short of bullshit.

Brentford was the game where chances were at a premium, but we missed all ours. That was the key problem - our strikers either held onto the ball for too long so the chance was lost, or they fluffed their shot.

And when we went down to 10 men, we inexplicably stopped defending properly, which led directly to the ridiculous scoreline - there was absolutely no sign of a 5-0 defeat before that. The 10 men brought it on, nothing else.
 
No it was a shambles, and the starting 11 didn't help especially when we went down to ten men.
But the point is, people on here starting calling for Grayson's head saying he had lost the dressing room etc, but it was a freak result in terms of Grayson tenure, as we hadn't conceded that many goals before of lost by that scoreline before. Saturday's team should be the team for the foreseeable future, and if we get injuries along the way then we have good replacements ready who should be able to step up.

Now, I have said Grayson In during the recent disputes but in the interest of balance, I don't recall anyone, even MarsBars, saying that "Grayson had lost the dressing room".

Provide evidence of this. Don't post BS if there is no truth in it. It makes you look, at best, plain daft.
 
There's some revisionist bollocks being written here about the Brentford game.

If we had equalised straight after half-time at Brentford - as we nearly did - then yes we might even have gone on to win because though we were poor Brentford were not that that much better. I said as much in my contribution to the match thread on the same day. But that does not alter the fact that the formation we used was fundamentally inadequate to the demands of this division - slow and predictable - and would have come unstuck somewhere else even if it had got something on that occasion.

The Wigan game proves the point - we used the same formation as at Brentford for the first 70 minutes and though we had scraped the lead the truth is that we looked unconvincing and, frankly, had they equalised before half-time as they nearly did they would probably have won easily. We looked a totally different side after we brought Johnson and even more so Pearson on - it was like turning a light on. Finally we had a formation that could do more than just hang on but actually play fast, fluid attacking football. Can you really not see the difference between that and the dross we served up at Brentford - apart from a 15-minute burst straight after half-time - even before we went down to ten men.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Saturday's team should be the team for the foreseeable future

Certainly for home games though I would not quibble if for at least some away fixtures SG tweaked it by replacing McGeady with Vermilj or Humphrey to enable us to start with the wing-back formation.
 
Back
Top