Skip to main content

Garner and Gallagher

Garner and Gallagher

Saturday is the last game Gallagher will miss before returning from this current suspension.

The inclusion of Garner on Saturday is a boost, no question.
 
Remember that curse put on Deepdale several years ago?
Well I've just had a witch wish us luck against Brentford! (A true Wicca practicing hedgewitch who has been a friend of mine for over 20 years).
 
Once they're all back, I'd play Gallagher up front with Garner, with Hume in the gap, and Bevs to come on after 30 minutes (replacing Humphries, Larry's favourite.) A nailed on 4-2 win doing that.
 
Garner has thrived alongside a big man so why change that

By the way, does everybody here think that Garner deserves to get his place in the starting line-up straight back on Saturday?

Remember that Garner was pretty stupid in getting himself the red card and the 3 match suspension. He let his team and team mates down with that behaviour. (The same is true with Gallagher and his red card, of course.)

There was a more permament place in the starting line-up up for grabs for Stuart Beavon.

However, Beavon didn't particularly impress during his 3 match spell in the starting line-up: his goal drought just continues, unfortunately (even though PNE did record 2 wins and a draw in those 3 matches).

So all in all: Joe Garner deserves to be back in the starting XI next Saturday, I reckon.
 
No other forward has carried anything like the goal threat that Garner did for those few games.

Straight back in the side - no question about it.
 
By the way, does everybody here think that Garner deserves to get his place in the starting line-up straight back on Saturday?

I would say he's a certain starter alongside Davies despite winning 2 and drawing 1 of the 3 games he's missed. That little break might just have freshened him up at the right time for the run over the Christmas period.
 
Wouldn't mind this with Beavon as a creative attacking midfielder

I think Brownhill would be the better choice as the attacking midfielder. Especially when you consider how well Brownhill played in the last game at times, alongside the fact we have never seen Beavon play anywhere other than as a striker before.
 
I think Brownhill would be the better choice as the attacking midfielder. Especially when you consider how well Brownhill played in the last game at times, alongside the fact we have never seen Beavon play anywhere other than as a striker before.



I would have Brownhill too in fact since he's been around the first team i honestly think he's inspired others , i just didn't want to look as though i had a downer on Beavon .
 
By the way, does everybody here think that Garner deserves to get his place in the starting line-up straight back on Saturday?

Remember that Garner was pretty stupid in getting himself the red card and the 3 match suspension. He let his team and team mates down with that behaviour. (The same is true with Gallagher and his red card, of course.)

There was a more permament place in the starting line-up up for grabs for Stuart Beavon.

However, Beavon didn't particularly impress during his 3 match spell in the starting line-up: his goal drought just continues, unfortunately (even though PNE did record 2 wins and a draw in those 3 matches).

So all in all: Joe Garner deserves to be back in the starting XI next Saturday, I reckon.

You basically just argued with yourself
 
In the absence of Gallagher the question is do we even bother with an attacking central midfielder - in addition to two more defensive players - or just go with a more conventional 4.4.2. If the former then Brownhill is the only real option though Holmes can play that role to a limited extent and Beavon might make a go of it. The one certainty is that Hume is utterly wasted there. If the latter then with Davies and Garner upfront we have Humphrey, Holmes and Hayhurst as the options for the wide positions - though I would still like to see how Keane might play on the right - with, presumably, Welsh and Kilkenny in the centre.

But the truth is that though this formation with Gallagher or whoever behind a front two works well in away games where we aim to hit the opposition on the break it has not proved so good at breaking down oppostion teams at our place. There seem to have been two reasons - one is a lack of an attacking fullback on the right to balance Laird on the left which is still the case, the other is that the midfield further back has lacked creativity though that is why Kilkenny was brought in and why he should start on Saturday.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top