Skip to main content

Garner benched

Garner benched

Dirty Harry

The voice of reason
Joined
Jun 2, 2015
Messages
18,711
Garner benched today. Injury? Out of form? Or does Grayson just fancy trying something different?
 
We're now not playing for anything. Give Doyle and Beckford a go. Doyle seems to have pretty good linkup play and I reckon it'll suit us as we'll keep it on the floor with reach Gally and DJ. Bring Garner on after 70 minutes and he'll be hungry for a goal.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
We're now not playing for anything. Give Doyle and Beckford a go. Doyle seems to have pretty good linkup play and I reckon it'll suit us as we'll keep it on the floor with reach Gally and DJ. Bring Garner on after 70 minutes and he'll be hungry for a goal.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
If we are not playing for anything, surely give gally his hernia operation?
 
We're now not playing for anything. Give Doyle and Beckford a go. Doyle seems to have pretty good linkup play and I reckon it'll suit us as we'll keep it on the floor with reach Gally and DJ. Bring Garner on after 70 minutes and he'll be hungry for a goal.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Yep. People may talk about how it is important to finish strong and keep a good mentality and momentum but these last few games are meaningless for us. Dingles aside. I'm all for it, try something different.
 
I can only see this as giving Doyle his last chances to impress before we decide what to do with him. Playing with Beckford to make runs and space, with that midfield behind him to create against a team who can't defend for toffee... if he can't do it today, he never will.

As for Garner, it's a deserved rest. He's run himself into the ground for the team all season and he's a hell of an option to bring off the bench.
 
I'm not Doyle's biggest fan but he's scored only 2 less than Garner in significantly less game time and he has looked sharp recently so he probably deserves a run of games.
 
Garner benched

Garner offered very little when he came on.

He is also fairly bad at penalties - and today was unintelligent - his penalty kick should have been an easy choice - straight down the middle - based on a sub keeper obviously going to dive as his first action.

I can't see any clear reason why garner should automatically start games, or be our no questions asked penalty taker.






Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
Does anyone think he should be a guaranteed starter next season ?

Hopefully this doesn't come across as a knee-jerk reaction to the penalty miss because it's not, penalty misses happen and some of the best in the world miss them.

However, I'm starting to think his role next season should probably be more as a squad player.

He has never been prolific at this level with Forest and Watford, and now that's proving to be the case at PNE also. He's only scored twice from open play this season.

He still offers a lot in terms of assists and being a general handful, but the goals just aren't there, and with Beckford returning plus the possibility of 1/2 new forwards coming in over the summer window, I think Garner may have to get used to settling for a place on the bench more often.
 
Does anyone think he should be a guaranteed starter next season ?

Hopefully this doesn't come across as a knee-jerk reaction to the penalty miss because it's not, penalty misses happen and some of the best in the world miss them.

However, I'm starting to think his role next season should probably be more as a squad player.

He has never been prolific at this level with Forest and Watford, and now that's proving to be the case at PNE also. He's only scored twice from open play this season.

He still offers a lot in terms of assists and being a general handful, but the goals just aren't there, and with Beckford returning plus the possibility of 1/2 new forwards coming in over the summer window, I think Garner may have to get used to settling for a place on the bench more often.

Finally, the love-in with Garner seems to be evaporating, not before time.
 
To me Garner has been the key fulcrum that Grayson has built his tactics around for the last few years. And this season our style of play is all about not conceding. Garner's all round play off and on the ball is why Grayson loves him so much. So he is the nearest thing to a guaranteed starter we have right now. And I can't see that changing next season.

People bemoan his lack of goals at this level but 15+ goal strikers at Championship level are not exactly easy to find. The three top goalscorers this season (Gray, Hernandez and Mccormack) cost over 30m combined. There are some quality strikers in this division who havent bagged 10 goals never mind 20.
 
Garner has lead our line all season on his own virtually, Grayson decides his strike partner from last season is fit to start and then drops him, sorry you fucked up SG negativity again at home against a team who will be relegated, piss poor performance and team selection. 😡😡😡😡
 
Back
Top