Skip to main content

Garner to return?

Garner to return?

I'd be for this. We know exactly what we'd be getting, no problems in settling in and he's got unfinished business in the Championship. For me he'd be ahead of Hugill and could pair well with Bark.. or Robinson
 
I'd be up for this. I'd get him and Hugill training to work as a pair over the summer.

And surely he'd come back for no fee? I was also under the impression that we were still owed money for him??
 
I'd be for this. We know exactly what we'd be getting, no problems in settling in and he's got unfinished business in the Championship. For me he'd be ahead of Hugill and could pair well with Bark.. or Robinson

Yeh we know exactly what we'd be getting. A failure at Championship level. This wont happen, Grayson knows we need better.
 
Yeh we know exactly what we'd be getting. A failure at Championship level. This wont happen, Grayson knows we need better.

Sorry but he was not a failure as you put it, he was employed as a lone striker and he didn't have the physical presence to do that. had he been here last season with the supply network that we had plus playing off Hugill then |I think he would have scored a few goals. he has shown in the past that once he gets his confidence up then he can do it.

I will agree that it is a set up from Lge 1 and I couldn't see him being prolific but you never know, he was like a few others instrumental in getting us up don't forget that
 
I'd be for this. We know exactly what we'd be getting, no problems in settling in and he's got unfinished business in the Championship. For me he'd be ahead of Hugill and could pair well with Bark.. or Robinson

So Joey scores 6 including two penalties and Hugill scores 13 but you'd put Garner ahead of him in the pecking order?
 
Sorry but he was not a failure as you put it, he was employed as a lone striker and he didn't have the physical presence to do that. had he been here last season with the supply network that we had plus playing off Hugill then |I think he would have scored a few goals. he has shown in the past that once he gets his confidence up then he can do it.

I will agree that it is a set up from Lge 1 and I couldn't see him being prolific but you never know, he was like a few others instrumental in getting us up don't forget that

Just like Beckford was.

We are trying to improve so let's not go backwards.
 
"According to the report, Preston, who are in the Championship in England, will make a bid of £500,000 for Garner."

Don't they still owe us £750,000?!

Direct Daily Record link: http://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/preston-target-rangers-flop-joe-10508760

Just in this, yes they still owe us £750k. So if we were to bid £500k we'd net £250k in cash.

I guess aside from whether we'd want him back/he'd want to be back, the issue might be wages - I think he was rumoured to have gone for £12-15k per week which we might not want to offer a rotational striker?

To be honest, if he's happy to be in the squad and we can get some money for Doyle or something, I'd rather have Garner back than him, but not if he's our marquee signing up front...
 
I watched a few Ranger's matches with Joe playing and he didn't look up to the pace. On the ball he's fine and you can never fault his passion or ability. SG will be scouring the market looking for the best value and prospect out there-it might not be Joe Garner. I'd like us to take a punt on a young hungry striker from Division 2 or non league.
 
Back
Top