Skip to main content

Garner to return?

Garner to return?

He'll either end up on loan to a team like Hibs, or else end up at one of the 3 teams relegated from the championship. A return to Blackburn wouldn't surprise me. He might even turn up at the lashers!
 
He'll either end up on loan to a team like Hibs, or else end up at one of the 3 teams relegated from the championship. A return to Blackburn wouldn't surprise me. He might even turn up at the lashers!

Or team up with Beckford at Bury (if their budget can stretch to his wages!)
 
Despite his relatively poor scoring record at Championship level a team now at this level which has money and a great need of the sort of character that Garner possesses is Sunderland.
 
Take off the googles, do you really think Joe Garner is the player to help the challenge for the Premier League?
Good in league 1, proved again, average in Scotland at best.
Please drop this nonsense.

Never did I mention anywhere that Garner is the player to help us challenge for the Premier League? But on that note I don't think Hugill is that player either. The only way North End are going to get a striker like that is of we find a gem like we did with Nugent.

I've no doubts with the squad from this season though Garner would of scored a lot of goals. No one can say he doesn't know where the back of the net is.

He's not going to be coming back here anyway. Seen him in Preston a few times in the past few weeks though so wouldn't be surprised to see him go to a local team like plastics if he is gonna leave Rangers.
 
Despite his relatively poor scoring record at Championship level a team now at this level which has money and a great need of the sort of character that Garner possesses is Sunderland.

Surely Hugill would be a better option for them?
 
Surely Hugill would be a better option for them?

I would hope not - the only players currently on our books who I would want to see move out are Pringle and Doyle, though neither is as poor as is sometimes made out. But what we have to focus on now is ourselves. Assuming this fellow Maguire comes in and we can get Baptiste and McGeady back then we need a keeper, a big central defender, an aggressive central midfielder and centre forward type striker.
 
So Garner is their Hugill replacement. Be interesting to compare how both do next season. I have no doubts that
Garner will bag a few, but am confident that Hugill will bag a few more.

Ernest it seems he has gone to a club where they score very few goals and create less chances than most, so he is likely to be doing the same role as he did for us first year back in the Championship. ie lone striker for a team that's hard to break down, makes a lot of draws and a few wins by the odd goal. Good Luck Joe.
 
That was last season. They could be a completely different beast this time around, impossible to say until the season starts. Either way I hope he does well.
 
That was last season. They could be a completely different beast this time around, impossible to say until the season starts. Either way I hope he does well.

You may be right Chris, however that's the way Mick McCarthy sets his teams up. I am sure Joe will do well there, but I doubt he will get the chances to become a prolific scorer in the Championship.
 
I agree, MM is a very good manager but a stubborn Yorkshire man much like SG, which can be very frustrating, as we know. He managed to get a carthorse like Murphy scoring in this division, hopefully he can do the same for Garner.

Thankfully Grayson has relented a bit this past season and become a bit more open to some attacking play.
 
I agree, MM is a very good manager but a stubborn Yorkshire man much like SG, which can be very frustrating, as we know. He managed to get a carthorse like Murphy scoring in this division, hopefully he can do the same for Garner.

Thankfully Grayson has relented a bit this past season and become a bit more open to some attacking play.

He's become more open because he now has the raw material to do so.
Prior to Barkhuizen and McGeady we were seriously short on pace, add Horgan to the mix and you now have the sort of pace that can frighten any defence, so you can now be more open knowing that defences will be reluctant to push too far up the field.
 
Back
Top