Skip to main content

Garner

Garner

I dont think Garner is playing bad at all, His overall gameplay is very very good, as for teams in this league finding him out, what an absolute load of rubbish, garner has given every defender he has been up against a real game and if anything always comes out on top in his battles with centre halves, The only criticism of Garner is that he appears to be having a bit of a nightmare in front of goal, but as we all know strikers are confidence players and as soon as Garner gets a goal im sure he will be back firing on all cylinders.
He is either taking a touch to many or snatching at shots. But he is in the positions to miss, and to be fair, we havent really created a lot of clear cut chances for him.
 
Then Beckford would have come on - But it's all if, buts and maybes. IF a player suffered from a serious injury e.g. broken leg would you start them straight away or ease them in from the bench. I know beckford hasn't had a serious injury but starting him could have had repercussions. Just because a player is fit enough for the bench doesn't mean he is fit enough to start. Anybody with any football knowledge would know that.

I think you have therefore agreed that Beckford would have been asked to play 60/70 minutes or whatever if Garner was injured,Beckford was not coming back from a serious injury so yes possible repercussions as you put it, but this could also happen if someone comes on for 5,10,15 20 minutes or whatever as anybody with any football knowledge would also know.
All a matter of opinions, glad to bow to your superior football knowledge.🙄
 
Last edited:
Doing everything but score. Still our best bet for goals, the luck will change soon for him I'm sure.
 
Mine hasn't changed. Still our best striker in my opinion. He's not exactly being set up with any straight forward chances. He's also been asked to play on the wing at times.

100% this.

No service, hit the woodwork a few times & being asked to lead the line on his own most of the time.
 
Once he puts one in the back of the net he`ll take off again.

Kevin Gallachers attitude to him on Radio Lancs is unbelivably negative. Agenda?
 
I understand he`s had more shots than anyone else in the Championship, without scoring.

From that, I`d guess he`s not getting as many clear cut opportunities, and is doing his level best to overcome the loss of Beckford, etc....but is up against better keepers and defenders. In League One, he`d already be well on his way.
 
At the moment we don't have a better striker than him so he can't be dropped. It's not like he's the only one who isn't scoring.
 
I understand he`s had more shots than anyone else in the Championship, without scoring.

That stat (24 shots I think it is) is quite surprising but I think most of those efforts have been half chances rather than sitters. Garner has also had a degree of bad luck, such as hitting the woodwork. The main issue is how wise referees are to his antics now rather than his finishing. For me, our failure to create many clear cut chances is more of a long term concern than the strikers failing to convert them. Garner, Beckford, Doyle and May should on paper be good enough at this level, although obviously we'll have to do without one of them for some time, while Doyle and May need more time to settle into the side.
 
That stat (24 shots I think it is) is quite surprising but I think most of those efforts have been half chances rather than sitters. Garner has also had a degree of bad luck, such as hitting the woodwork. The main issue is how wise referees are to his antics now rather than his finishing. For me, our failure to create many clear cut chances is more of a long term concern than the strikers failing to convert them. Garner, Beckford, Doyle and May should on paper be good enough at this level, although obviously we'll have to do without one of them for some time, while Doyle and May need more time to settle into the side.

Yep...that was what I was figuring from the stat...but without seeing many games.
 
Back
Top