Skip to main content

Garner ?

Garner ?

dirk pnemouse

The Gentry (RIP)
Joined
Nov 1, 2006
Messages
26,968
If say Sheffield United offered 1m for Garner would you accept it and reinvest in a new striker at Championship level if 1 could be found ? great servant to the club but he looks lost at this level and would in my opinion still do a great job at league 1 level .

I'm not saying we should get rid but at the moment he's still worth a few bob and the longer this non scoring strikers theme continues the worse things could get .
 
If say Sheffield United offered 1m for Garner would you accept it and reinvest in a new striker at Championship level if 1 could be found ? great servant to the club but he looks lost at this level and would in my opinion still do a great job at league 1 level .

I'm not saying we should get rid but at the moment he's still worth a few bob and the longer this non scoring strikers theme continues the worse things could get .


If he was missing shed loads of chances maybe but there aren't many being created for him. Any striker needs a bit of service at this level so until he gets it I would reserve judgement and stick with him.
 
Who shall we buy who is scoring at this level? Blackman, Martin, Gray, McCormick, Austin or Martin? No change from £10M for any of the above.

The transfer market prices are ridiculously inflated at the moment and likely to stay that way , maybe we could look further afield like Africa or Asia , not saying the answer lays there but its somewhere we have never really explored . Not sure signing young english talent is good either as they are over payed and strut around like gods , not saying get shut of Garner i just think we have plenty up front with only one thing in common no return and really something needs to be done . I would send Doyle back too as i feel there is plenty of running but offers us nothing we don't already have .

Don't want it to look like im bitching but we have to find an answer to this situation and soon
 
I just don't think he's getting any decent service. We play long balls from Pickford to him far too much in the hope he'll flick the ball into decent positions.

We're getting no chances in their box, so he's having to drop deeper and deeper, and taking pot luck shots from outside the box.
 
The transfer market prices are ridiculously inflated at the moment and likely to stay that way , maybe we could look further afield like Africa or Asia , not saying the answer lays there but its somewhere we have never really explored . Not sure signing young english talent is good either as they are over payed and strut around like gods , not saying get shut of Garner i just think we have plenty up front with only one thing in common no return and really something needs to be done . I would send Doyle back too as i feel there is plenty of running but offers us nothing we don't already have .

Don't want it to look like im bitching but we have to find an answer to this situation and soon
The beach at Santa Maria, Cape Verde at about 5pm
 
I just don't think he's getting any decent service. We play long balls from Pickford to him far too much in the hope he'll flick the ball into decent positions.

We're getting no chances in their box, so he's having to drop deeper and deeper, and taking pot luck shots from outside the box.



But if we persist in these tactics he is wrong for what we are trying to achieve so what do we do ?
 
If say Sheffield United offered 1m for Garner would you accept it and reinvest in a new striker at Championship level if 1 could be found ? great servant to the club but he looks lost at this level and would in my opinion still do a great job at league 1 level .

I'm not saying we should get rid but at the moment he's still worth a few bob and the longer this non scoring strikers theme continues the worse things could get .

There are at least 3 other strikers I'd ship out before Garner... even if we got a good bid.
 
But if we persist in these tactics he is wrong for what we are trying to achieve so what do we do ?

Grayson won't do anything. This is how he sets his teams up. I think we'll find that we'll struggle to get positive results at home, but away we'll do better. Seems like that so far.

Look at Doyle and Johnson. By all accounts them 2 linked excellently at Chesterfield. Chesterfield had a quick tempo to their game and attacked with no fear. Yet we've seen no evidence of this so far. Mainly due to us being far too direct. Which last night suited Bolton as Wheater was brilliant in the air.
 
Looks out of his depth at the moment.

He has a poor, poor scoring record at this level and now we're seeing why.

Hopefully he can turn it around.
 
If say Sheffield United offered 1m for Garner would you accept it and reinvest in a new striker at Championship level if 1 could be found ? great servant to the club but he looks lost at this level and would in my opinion still do a great job at league 1 level .

I'm not saying we should get rid but at the moment he's still worth a few bob and the longer this non scoring strikers theme continues the worse things could get .

I'd have sold him in the summer.He won't score for us.
 
I just don't think he's getting any decent service. We play long balls from Pickford to him far too much in the hope he'll flick the ball into decent positions.

We're getting no chances in their box, so he's having to drop deeper and deeper, and taking pot luck shots from outside the box.

Getting no chances in their box is due to the better level we are now playing at. He got loads of chances last season. Much harder to create them at this level which is why it is becoming glaringly obvious that we did not strengthen properly in the summer.
 
He's a bit of a greedy fellow, isn't he?

He's definitely now had enough "service" to have scored at least a solitary goal. If anything, he's actually messed a few decent attacking moves up, with his greedyness....

Whenever he gets the ball to feet around the box, he puts his head down, has no interest in passing/playing a team-mate in, and just speculatively swings his boot at the ball, resulting (more often than not) in a weak as piss daisy-cutter straight down the keepers throat....or harasses the photographers 15 yards to the side of goal.

His desperation for a goal is obviously affecting his game, but he's so frustrating at the moment.
 
If say Sheffield United offered 1m for Garner would you accept it and reinvest in a new striker at Championship level if 1 could be found ? great servant to the club but he looks lost at this level and would in my opinion still do a great job at league 1 level .

I'm not saying we should get rid but at the moment he's still worth a few bob and the longer this non scoring strikers theme continues the worse things could get .

No definately not. Its the lack of service why he's not scored yet. Create chances and he'll bag them
 
Back
Top